I am an application backend dev on .net and adjacent platforms (so, microsoft stack…
- User
I am an application backend dev on .net and adjacent platforms (so, microsoft stack basically), and i've been theorizing about making a game in which resetting save progress is impossible. So far, my ideas are:
- Write a very robust, difficult to reverse-engineer client that gathers as much unique information about the system as possible: UUIDs, serials, MAC, etc, and set up a remote authentication.
- Design a physical key, similar to ones that are used in some companies as auth-keys for USB. Again, should be robust and difficult to mimic or reverse engineer.
- Only transfer game-relevant data from the server, without sending over the whole savefile through. Are there any other ways i could've overlooked?
Assistant
Your approach to making a game with non-resettable save progress is interesting and touches on several security and anti-tampering techniques. Since you're coming from a .NET and Microsoft stack background, you're already thinking in terms of robust authentication and hardware-based security. Here are some additional ideas and refinements to consider:
1. Hardware-Based Authentication (Beyond USB Keys)
- TPM (Trusted Platform Module): Modern PCs have TPM chips that can securely store cryptographic keys. You could bind save data to a TPM-bound key, making it nearly impossible to transfer saves to another machine.
- Secure Enclave (Apple) / Pluton (Microsoft): If targeting specific platforms, these hardware security modules can be used to store and verify save integrity.
- Smart Cards / NFC Tokens: Instead of USB keys, you could use contactless smart cards or NFC tokens for authentication.
2. Cloud-Based Save Validation
- Server-Side Save Hashing: Instead of storing the full save file on the server, store a cryptographic hash (e.g., SHA-256) of the save file. The client must periodically sync and verify the hash with the server.
- Incremental Save Updates: Only allow the server to accept incremental changes (deltas) rather than full save files, making it harder to manipulate progress.
- Behavioral Analytics: Track player behavior (e.g., playtime patterns, input sequences) and flag suspicious activity (e.g., sudden progress jumps).
3. Obfuscation & Anti-Tampering Techniques
- Code Obfuscation: Use tools like ConfuserEx, Obfuscar, or Dotfuscator to make reverse-engineering harder.
- Memory Protection: Use anti-debugging and anti-cheat techniques (e.g., EasyAntiCheat, BattlEye, or custom solutions) to prevent save file manipulation.
- Dynamic Save Encryption: Encrypt save files with a key derived from hardware + user-specific data, changing periodically.
4. Blockchain-Based Save Integrity (Optional)
- If you want extreme tamper resistance, you could store save hashes on a blockchain (e.g., Ethereum, Solana, or a private chain). This ensures that any modification would require altering the blockchain, which is computationally infeasible.
5. Legal & Psychological Deterrents
- EULA & Legal Warnings: Explicitly state that save manipulation is a bannable offense.
- Social Proof: If the game has a competitive or achievement-based aspect, publicly display verified progress to discourage cheating.
6. Hybrid Approach (Best of Both Worlds)
- Combine hardware binding (TPM/USB key) with server-side validation and behavioral monitoring for maximum security.
Potential Challenges
- False Positives: Overly aggressive anti-tampering might block legitimate players (e.g., hardware changes, VM users).
- Offline Play: If the game requires constant online checks, players with poor connectivity may be locked out.
- Cost: Physical keys and advanced security measures add complexity and expense.
Final Thoughts
Your current ideas (hardware keys, unique system fingerprinting, and server-side validation) are strong. Adding TPM binding, behavioral analytics, and incremental save updates could further strengthen the system. If you want extreme security, a blockchain-based hash verification system could be an overkill but interesting option.
Would you like recommendations on specific .NET libraries or tools for implementing these?
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.