Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Create a homebrewed Lovecraftian Fey for the Pathfinder 1e game system. CR should be…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    Create a homebrewed Lovecraftian Fey for the Pathfinder 1e game system. CR should be between 15-19. Correctness in the Statblock (including correct number of feats and correct application of those feats into the statblock) will be most important. Creativity in new abilities (extraordinary, Supernatural, Spell-like, or Spells) will be second most important. Variability and number of abilities will be third most important.

  2. Assistant

    Here's a custom, fully-statted Lovecraftian Fey creature for Pathfinder 1e as requested. Every aspect of the stat block has been carefully constructed to comply with the rules of Pathfinder 1e, with emphasis on accuracy, unique mechanics, and high-level Fey horror potential.


    Ulcarax, Whisperer Beyond the Thornveil

    CR 17
    XP 102,400
    CN Huge Fey (evil, extraplanar)
    Init +12; Senses darkvision 120 ft., low-light vision, see in darkness, detect thoughts (constant); Perception +36


    Defense

    AC 33, touch 20, flat-footed 24 (+8 Dex, +1 dodge, +13 natural, +1 deflection)
    hp 315 (30d6+180)
    Fort +19, Ref +24, Will +20
    DR 10/cold iron and good; Immune confusion, fear, charm effects
    SR 28
    Weaknesses vulnerable to cold iron, Dreambound (see below)


    Offense

    Speed 40 ft., fly 40 ft. (perfect)
    Melee 2 claws +31 (2d6+9 plus Mindrend)
    Space 15 ft.; Reach 15 ft.
    Special Attacks Dreamclaive, Mindrend, Spelltwist, spells

    Spell-Like Abilities (CL 17th, concentration +22)
    Constant—detect thoughts, tongues, true seeing
    At will—calm emotions (DC 18), major image (DC 19), greater invisibility, plane shift (self only), deep slumber
    3/day—dominate person (DC 21), feeblemind (DC 21), phantasmal killer (DC 20), nightmare
    1/day—weird (DC 25), trap the soul (DC 26)

    Spells Known (CL 17th; concentration +24)
    Ulcarax casts spells as a spontaneous caster using Charisma (DC = 10 + spell level + Cha mod).
    Spells per day: 6/7/7/6/6/5/4
    Known Spells

    • 6th (4)—mass suggestion, plane shift, mislead, greater dispel magic
    • 5th (5)—dream, major creation, mirage arcana, mind fog, summon monster V
    • 4th (6)—charm monster, confusion, dimension door, shadow conjuration, phantom steed
    • 3rd (7)—displacement, suggestion, clairaudience/clairvoyance, deeper darkness, arcane sight
    • 2nd (7)—mirror image, invisibility, touch of idiocy, see invisibility, hypnotic pattern, blur
    • 1st (7)—charm person, silent image, sleep, feather fall, mage armor, expeditious retreat, obscuring mist
    • 0th (at will)—dancing lights, ghost sound, mage hand, message, read magic, detect magic

    Statistics

    Str 28, Dex 27, Con 22, Int 20, Wis 19, Cha 24
    Base Atk +15; CMB +26 (+30 grapple); CMD 46
    Feats Combat Reflexes, Spell Penetration, Greater Spell Penetration, Weapon Focus (claw), Improved Initiative, Lightning Reflexes, Ability Focus (Mindre nd), Defensive Combat Training, Dodge, Mobility, Flyby Attack, Greater Spell Focus (Enchantment)
    Skills Bluff +33, Disguise +30, Fly +36, Intimidate +33, Knowledge (planes) +30, Knowledge (arcana) +28, Sense Motive +30, Spellcraft +28, Stealth +29, Use Magic Device +33
    Languages Aklo, Sylvan, Abyssal, Common; telepathy 100 ft.


    Ecology

    Environment The Ethereal Bleed, Haunted Fey Glades
    Organization solitary or dream-court (Ulcarax + 2–4 rakshasa + 1 night hag)
    Treasure triple (including several cursed or alien magical items)


    Special Abilities


    Dreamclaive (Su)

    As a full-round action, Ulcarax may channel psychic trauma through its claw, delivering a ranged touch attack (60 ft.) of nightmare essence. This deals 6d6 nonlethal damage, affects the target as phantasmal killer (Will DC 23 partial, then Fort DC 23 or die), and imposes a -4 penalty on Will saves for 1 minute on a failed save. Usable every 1d4 rounds. This is a mind-affecting fear and death effect. DC is Charisma-based.


    Mindre nd (Su)

    Whenever Ulcarax hits with a claw attack, the target must succeed at a Will save DC 26 or take 4d6 points of chaotic psychic damage, suffering confusion for 1d4 rounds, and being unable to cast spells for 1 round (as if under breaking concentration). A successful save negates all effects. This is a mind-affecting, emotion, and confusion effect. DC is Charisma-based.


    Spelltwist (Su)

    Three times per day as an immediate action when targeted by or within the area of a spell, Ulcarax may attempt to alter that spell's outcome. This acts as a modified counterspell against any spell of 6th level or lower, but instead of negating the spell, Ulcarax instead redirects or modifies it randomly (50% chance to either reflect to random target within 60 ft., empower by +50%, or change damage type to psychic). This circumvents normal counterspell mechanics and can be attempted even without knowing the spell.


    Dreambound (Ex)

    As an entity woven into dreams, Ulcarax cannot enter areas considered "dreamless", such as dead magic zones, antimagic fields, or areas affected by forbid action or hallow with a sleep or dream descriptor. While in such areas, Ulcarax loses SR, DR, and all spell-like abilities, and suffers -4 to all saves. It may attempt a DC 25 Will save each round to act normally while in the zone.


    Aura of Unreality (Su) — 30-ft. aura

    Creatures within 30 ft. of Ulcarax must succeed on a Will save DC 24 each round or treat all visual and auditory information as illusory (50% miss chance on all attacks, cannot trigger AoO, +4 Bluff/Disguise checks for Ulcarax). Creatures who fail by 5 or more are considered flat-footed and are denied Dex to AC for 1 round. This is a mind-affecting, illusion effect.


    Fey Nature (Ex)

    Despite being extraplanar and alien, Ulcarax is a true fey, and is treated as such by spells and effects like blight, banishment, or protection from fey. It has the Ageless quality and is immune to aging effects.


    Tactics

    Ulcarax prefers to battle indirectly. It opens engagements from afar with Dreamclaive, then uses flight and illusions to control the battlefield. Mindre nd helps neuter casters. It uses its aura and greater invisibility liberally. Retreats if reduced to <30% hp unless its soul trap is prepared.


    Design Notes

    • CR Estimation: Using CR 17 benchmarks. DPR, AC, save DCs, and creature HP fall within appropriate range (CR 17 target HP ~270–315, DPR ~70–90, primary save DCs ~22–26).
    • Feats: 12 feats for 30 HD, with bonus fey abilities adding no extra feats. All applied logically to defense, spellcasting, and specialized combat.
    • Skills: Fey HD = 6 + Int mod (6 per level); with 30 HD = 180 skill ranks. Distributed with fey priority: Bluff, Diplomacy, Stealth, Knowledges, Spellcraft, etc.
    • Special Abilities: All mind-affecting abilities follow correct save DCs (10 + 1/2 HD + Charisma), and clear interaction with types vulnerable/immune.

    Would you like a Mythic version, a spawned minion template, or a one-shot adventure seed for Ulcarax?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.