Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

where to work: Mckinsey, BCG, Microsoft or SAP, Meta, Google, BCG Platinion, McKinsey…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-4-0709’s answer.
  1. User

    where to work: Mckinsey, BCG, Microsoft or SAP, Meta, Google, BCG Platinion, McKinsey Digital, Adobe, BASF. Make a ranking. Concise and shortly please. we are looking for impact on income over whole career.

  2. Meta Assistant
    1. McKinsey (High consulting salaries, bonuses)
    2. BCG (Competitive consulting pay, similar to McKinsey)
    3. Google (Top tech salaries, stock options)
    4. Meta (High tech salaries, significant stock potential)
    5. Microsoft (Strong tech compensation, stock benefits)
    6. McKinsey Digital (High consulting pay, digital focus)
    7. BCG Platinion (Specialized consulting, high pay potential)
    8. Adobe (Good tech salaries, stock options)
    9. SAP (Enterprise software pay, stable but lower)
    10. BASF (Industrial sector pay, generally lower than tech/consulting)

    Ranking based on potential lifetime earnings, with top tech and consulting firms typically offering the highest compensation packages.

  3. User

    where to work: Mckinsey, BCG, Microsoft or SAP, Meta, Google, BCG Platinion, BCG TDA, McKinsey Digital, Adobe, BASF. Make a ranking. Concise and shortly please. we are looking for impact on income over whole career.

  4. Meta Assistant
    1. Google (Top tech salaries, stock options)
    2. Meta (High tech salaries, significant stock potential)
    3. Microsoft (Strong tech compensation, stock benefits)
    4. McKinsey (High consulting salaries, bonuses)
    5. BCG (Competitive consulting pay)
    6. McKinsey Digital (High consulting pay, digital focus)
    7. BCG Platinion (Specialized consulting, high pay potential)
    8. BCG TDA (Likely similar to BCG Platinion, high pay)
    9. Adobe (Good tech salaries, stock options)
    10. SAP (Enterprise software pay, stable)
    11. BASF (Industrial sector pay, generally lower)

    Tech giants (1-3) often lead in compensation; top consulting firms (4-8) follow closely. Enterprise software (9-10) and industrial (11) typically offer lower lifetime earnings.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.