Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.5-pro· Google LMArena Human Preference 140K

i wan t a mixture of experts like prompt. currently i have the following, can you…

  1. User

    i wan t a mixture of experts like prompt. currently i have the following, can you improve it:

    Imagine three different experts are answering this question.
    All experts will write down 1 step of their thinking, then share it with the group. They are not going to use the other experts approach in coming up with the answer. They will think about it independently and will try to be original in thinking. Ensure that there is disagreement that they communicate through. Then all experts will go on to the next step, etc. If any expert realises they're wrong at any point then they leave. Think about it step by step. The question is

  2. Assistant

    Of course. Your current prompt is a great start because it establishes the core mechanics of a Mixture of Experts (MoE) process: multiple agents, turn-based thinking, independence, and conflict.

    The main areas for improvement are:

    1. Specificity: The "experts" are generic. Defining their fields or viewpoints creates more structured and interesting conflict.
    2. Structure: A clear format for the output makes it much easier for the AI to follow and for you to read.
    3. Clarity of Process: Making the "sharing" and "disagreement" phases explicit will yield better results.
    4. Synthesis: The process doesn't explicitly ask for a final, consolidated answer.

    Here are a few improved versions, from a simple enhancement to a more advanced, modular template.


    Option 1: The Enhanced Core Prompt

    This version keeps the spirit of your original but adds specific roles and a clearer structure. It's a great, all-purpose improvement.

    The Prompt:

    System Command: You will act as a panel of three distinct experts debating a question. You must follow these rules strictly:

    1. The Experts:

      • Expert 1 (The Pragmatist): A logical, data-driven, and risk-averse specialist. Focuses on feasibility, evidence, and practical implementation.
      • Expert 2 (The Visionary): A creative, forward-thinking, and unconventional strategist. Focuses on innovation, long-term potential, and challenging assumptions.
      • Expert 3 (The Humanist): An empathetic, ethics-focused, and user-centric advocate. Focuses on the human impact, ethical implications, and stakeholder well-being.
    2. Process: The debate will proceed in turns. In each turn, every expert will perform two actions:

      • A) Thinking Step: Independently write down the next single step of their reasoning process to answer the main question. They must not be influenced by the other experts in this phase.
      • B) Critique: After all experts have presented their thinking step, they will briefly (1-2 sentences) critique the other two experts' steps from their unique perspective.
    3. Rule of Disagreement: Experts must maintain their unique perspectives. They should not concede or merge their approaches unless their line of reasoning is proven to be a dead end.

    4. Rule of Departure: If an expert's approach is definitively proven wrong or irrelevant by the evolving logic, they must state why their perspective is no longer valid and recuse themselves from the rest of the debate.

    5. Final Output: After several turns, the remaining expert(s) will collaborate to synthesize their viewpoints into a final, comprehensive answer.

    The question is: [INSERT YOUR QUESTION HERE]


    Option 2: The Advanced Modular Prompt

    This version is a powerful template. You fill in the blanks to customize the entire simulation for any task. It gives you maximum control.

    The Prompt:

    [INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE AI]

    Objective: Simulate a "Mixture of Experts" roundtable to thoroughly analyze and solve the user's question.

    Persona Roster (3 Experts):

    • Expert A: [Define Persona 1, e.g., A cynical historian focused on past failures.]
    • Expert B: [Define Persona 2, e.g., An optimistic technologist focused on future solutions.]
    • Expert C: [Define Persona 3, e.g., A skeptical economist focused on financial viability.]

    Rules of Engagement:

    1. Turn-Based Progression: The analysis will proceed in synchronized, numbered turns.
    2. Independent Thinking: In each turn, each expert will first state their next step of analysis. This thinking must be original and based on their core persona, without referencing the others' current steps.
    3. Forced Disagreement & Debate: After presenting their independent thoughts, each expert will read the others' steps for that turn and write a short, sharp critique. The goal is to challenge, find flaws, and stress-test the other ideas.
    4. The "Dead End" Protocol: If an expert concludes that their own reasoning path is flawed or has been invalidated, they must announce it, state the reason, and exit the simulation.
    5. Formatting: Use markdown for clarity. Each turn should have a main heading. Each expert's contribution should have a subheading.
      • ## Turn 1
      • ### Expert A: Thinking
      • ### Expert B: Thinking
      • ### Expert C: Thinking
      • ---
      • ### Debate - Turn 1
      • **A critiques B & C:** ...
      • **B critiques A & C:** ...
      • **C critiques A & B:** ...
    6. Resolution: After 3-5 turns, or when only one or two experts remain, produce a final section titled "## Final Synthesis" that combines the surviving, most robust lines of reasoning into a final, actionable answer.

    [THE TASK]

    Question: [INSERT YOUR QUESTION HERE]


    Why these prompts are more effective:

    • Defined Personas: Forces the AI into specific, conflicting modes of thought, which is the engine of a good MoE.
    • Explicit Structure: The markdown formatting and distinct "Thinking" vs. "Critique" phases prevent the AI from getting confused and merging the steps.
    • Clearer Rules: Terms like "The 'Dead End' Protocol" and "Forced Disagreement" are more direct instructions for the model.
    • Actionable Conclusion: Both prompts end with a requirement for a Final Synthesis, ensuring you get a clean, distilled answer out of the process, not just the raw debate.

    You can now use these templates by simply dropping your question into the designated spot. The modular one is particularly useful for complex problems where you want to design the exact expert panel needed for the job.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.