Help me decode Sneer Club, please. The headline is "Anthropic AI wins broad fair use for…
- User
Help me decode Sneer Club, please. The headline is "Anthropic AI wins broad fair use for training! — but not on pirated books" and the sneer is "Top-level commenters would do well to read Authors Guild v Google, two decades ago. They’re also invited to rend their garments and gnash their teeth at Google, if they like."
- Assistant
“Sneer-Club translation”
Headline
“Anthropic AI wins broad fair use for training! — but not on pirated books.”
→ A judge (or regulator) just said that Anthropic can legally train its models on huge swaths of text under U.S. fair-use law, except for any text that’s obviously infringing (e.g., scans of still-in-copyright books that were never licensed).Sneer
“Top-level commenters would do well to read Authors Guild v Google, two decades ago. They’re also invited to rend their garments and gnash their teeth at Google, if they like.”Plain-English decode
-
“Before you spout hot takes, go read the Google Books case.”
• Authors Guild v Google (decided at the trial level in 2013, affirmed on appeal in 2015, SCOTUS cert denied 2016) already said that mass-scanning millions of books and using the scans to build a searchable index was fair use because it was “transformative” and didn’t substitute for buying the books.
• That precedent is about as close to an AI-training analogue as you can get: copying the whole work for a purpose (search / machine learning) that is different from just reading the text. -
“If you’re going to freak out about Anthropic, you’d better freak out about Google too.”
• Google has been doing something even more sweeping for ~20 years.
• If you accept Google’s scanning as fair use, it’s hard to argue Anthropic is qualitatively worse.
• Conversely, if you think Anthropic is the devil, consistency demands you “rend garments and gnash teeth” (i.e., weep and wail theatrically) over Google Books. -
Sub-text / attitude
• The poster is rolling their eyes at commenters who act as though this is some radical new legal development.
• The sneer is: “This has been settled law for ages; try catching up before you tweet.”
Why the “pirated books” carve-out still matters
• Even under the Google precedent, copying must be from lawfully obtained copies.
• If Anthropic scraped illicit PDFs of the newest best-seller, that could break the fair-use shield and trigger DMCA damages.
• So the line the court draws is: fair use for lawful text corpora; potential liability for using “shadow library” material.Take-away
• The sneer is basically: “Nothing to see here—this is 2010s Google Books all over again. If you want to be mad, be mad consistently.” -
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.