Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o4-mini-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

if time stops at the speed of light & a photon can travel forever but the CMB is 46.5…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    if time stops at the speed of light & a photon can travel forever but the CMB is 46.5 billion light years in radius & the universe is 13.8 billion years old, then what is the significance of distance vs time since everything visible is a cause of light being reflected while absorbing other wave lengths but at the same time light itself is taking time to move from point A to B?

  2. Assistant

    You’re touching on a few deep points in relativity and cosmology all at once, so let’s unpack them one by one:

    1. “Time stops” for a photon?
      • In Special Relativity we often say “a photon has zero proper time,” meaning there is no valid “rest‐frame” of light. Proper time (τ) is the time measured by a clock traveling alongside the object—and a photon can’t carry such a clock.
      • In our frame, however, a photon takes a finite time (and travels a finite distance) to go from A to B at c.

    2. Distance vs. time in an expanding universe
      • Look-back time is “how long ago the photon was emitted” (e.g. ~13.8 Gyr for the CMB).
      • Proper (or comoving) distance today is “where that patch of space is right now” (~46.5 Gly for the CMB surface).
      • They differ because while the photon was en route, the space itself stretched.

    3. Why reflection/absorption doesn’t change the speed-limit or the look-back logic
      • Whether photons are emitted directly (stars, gas) or scattered/reflected (planets, dust), once they’re on their way they still travel at c—and they still carry only a “time‐lagged” image of whatever interacted with them.
      • Every flash of light you see is your past-light-cone intercepting a world-line of some emitter or scatterer.

    — — —

    A Compact Summary

    QuantitySymbolCMB example
    Age of universe (coordinate)t₀ ≃ 13.8 GyrN/A
    Look-back timet₀−t_emit ≃ 13.8 GyrTime since last-scattering
    Proper (comoving) distance nowD₀ ≃ 46.5 GlyCurrent radius of observable universe
    Photon “proper time”Δτ = 0Not physically meaningful

    Key takeaway:

    • Distance in “light-years” often doubles as “years of light-travel time.”
    • But in cosmology the Universe’s expansion means “light-travel time” ≠ “current distance”
    • Photons never experience time, yet we—stationary observers—measure their finite travel time and infer how far away (and how far back in time) their sources are.

    If you’d like to see the actual integrals behind “13.8 Gyr → 46.5 Gly” in the ΛCDM model, or dig into how we define comoving vs. proper distances, let me know!

  3. User

    is it possible to study the age, distance traveled and source of a photon

  4. Assistant

    You can’t “stop the clock” on a photon itself (it has zero proper time!), but from our vantage point you can infer, for each detected photon, three key things:

    1. Its “age” or look-back time
    2. The distance it’s traveled
    3. The astrophysical source that emitted it

    Here’s how in practice:


    1. Measuring a Photon’s “Age” (Look-back Time)

    • What we actually measure is its redshift z:
    – From spectroscopy (e.g. identifying known emission/absorption lines shifted to longer wavelengths).
    • In a ΛCDM cosmology, redshift ↔ scale factor a(t):
    [ a_{\rm emit} = \frac{1}{1+z} ]
    • We invert the Friedmann equations to get the emission time tₑₘ (after the Big Bang).
    • The look-back time Δt = t₀ – tₑₘ is the photon’s “age” in our frame.

    Example:
    A Lyman-α photon from a galaxy at z=6
    – a_emit = 1/7
    – t_emit ≃ 0.95 Gyr after BB
    – look-back Δt ≃ 13.8 – 0.95 ≃ 12.85 Gyr


    2. Computing the Distance Traveled

    Depending on your definition of “distance,” you get different numbers:

    • Light-travel distance ≃ c·Δt ≃ 12.85 billion light-years
    • Comoving distance
    [ D_C = c \int_{t_{\rm emit}}^{t_0} \frac{dt}{a(t)} ]
    – For z=6 this is ≃ 29 billion light-years
    • Proper distance today = comoving distance

    These integrals are built into most cosmology calculators (e.g. Ned Wright’s, astropy.cosmology).


    3. Pinning Down the Source

    1. Direction on the sky (θ,φ) from the detector’s pointing.
    2. Energy/frequency & polarization – helps classify source (star vs. galaxy vs. quasar vs. CMB).
    3. Cross-match with catalogs or follow-up observations:
      – Does a known galaxy/quasar lie at that redshift in that direction?
      – Is there a transient event (supernova, GRB) at the same coordinates?

    Limits & Caveats

    • A photon’s proper time is always zero — you can only assign an age in our rest-frame.
    • For the CMB we can’t trace individual photons back to a single atom; we only map the statistical last-scattering surface at z≈1100.
    • Gravitational lensing or scattering can subtly change a photon’s path, so your inferred source direction might be offset.

    Summary Table

    QuantityHow to get itExample (z=6)
    Look-back time ΔtInvert a(t) from z~12.85 Gyr
    Light-travel distancec·Δt~12.85 Gly
    Comoving/proper distance∫[dt/a(t)] from t_emit to t₀~29 Gly
    Source IDSky position + spectrum + catalogs/follow-upHigh-z galaxy/quasar

    In short, yes—by measuring its redshift, direction, spectrum and applying cosmological models, we can reconstruct how long a photon has been en route, how far it’s come (in various distance definitions), and what kind of object produced it.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.