Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
MiniMaxminimax-m1· MiniMaxHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I have heard that both non-quantum and quantum physics theories can be mathematically…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-sonnet-4-20250514-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    I have heard that both non-quantum and quantum physics theories can be mathematically formulated using C-star algebras (the non-quantum ones happen to be commutative). This applies both to fundamental interactions and to imprecise measurements and subjective lack of information. Let us try to investigate that claim. In non-quantum physics, there is an important process of Bayesian update, when prior information is transformed into posterior information, based on likelihoods of observations. Describe this transformation as formulas using elements of some C-star algebra, then drop the assumption on commutativity. Do we get a unique quantum transformation, or are multiple formulas possible (only becoming equivalent in commutative case)? Does the quantum transformation correspond to something known and specific (for example wave function collapse), or are additional philosophical assumptions needed (for example related to interpretations of quantum mechanics)?

  2. MiniMax Assistant

    Bayesian Update in Commutative C*-Algebra (Non-Quantum Case)

    In non-quantum physics, a commutative C*-algebra models classical observables. Let the algebra be ( \mathcal{A} = C(X) ), where ( X ) is a compact Hausdorff space (the sample space). A state ( \mu ) is a probability measure on ( X ), represented as a positive linear functional on ( \mathcal{A} ):
    [ \mu(f) = \int_X f , d\mu \quad \forall f \in \mathcal{A}. ]

    A Bayesian update occurs when new information (an event ( B \subseteq X )) is incorporated. The posterior state ( \mu_B ) is defined via the conditional expectation: [ \mu_B(f) = \frac{\mu(f \cdot 1_B)}{\mu(1_B)}, ] where ( 1_B \in \mathcal{A} ) is the characteristic function of ( B ). This formula generalizes Bayes' theorem to the algebraic framework.


    Non-Commutative Case (Quantum)

    When commutativity is dropped, ( \mathcal{A} ) becomes a non-abelian C*-algebra (e.g., the algebra of operators on a Hilbert space). Observables are represented by self-adjoint elements, and states are positive linear functionals with ( \mu(1) = 1 ).

    Key Observations:

    1. Non-Uniqueness of Quantum Transformation:
      In the quantum case, there is no unique generalization of the commutative Bayesian update. For an event represented by a projection ( E \in \mathcal{A} ), multiple state-update rules are possible:

      • Lüders Rule:
        [ \mu_E(f) = \frac{\mu(E f E)}{\mu(E)}, ] which generalizes the classical formula ( \mu_B(f) = \mu(1_B f 1_B)/\mu(1_B) ) to non-commuting ( E ) and ( f ).
      • Alternative Orderings:
        If ( E ) and ( f ) do not commute, ( \mu(E f)/\mu(E) ) or ( \mu(f E)/\mu(E) ) yield distinct results. These are not equivalent unless ( E ) commutes with all ( f \in \mathcal{A} ), which reduces to the commutative case.

      Thus, multiple quantum transformations exist, unlike the unique classical Bayesian update.

    2. Connection to Known Quantum Formalism:
      The Lüders rule corresponds to the projection postulate (wave function collapse) when ( E ) is a projection operator. For example, if ( \mathcal{A} ) is the algebra of bounded operators on a Hilbert space ( \mathcal{H} ), and ( E = |\psi\rangle\langle\psi| ), the update becomes: [ \rho \mapsto \frac{E \rho E}{\text{Tr}(\rho E)}, ] which matches the collapse of the density matrix ( \rho ) after measuring outcome ( E ).

      However, this rule is not universally mandated by the algebraic structure alone. Other update rules (e.g., for generalized measurements via POVMs) require additional assumptions.

    3. Philosophical Interpretations:
      The projection postulate is part of the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics but does not resolve interpretational questions:

      • Wave function collapse (e.g., in Copenhagen interpretation) treats the update as physical.
      • No-collapse interpretations (e.g., many-worlds) reject collapse, instead attributing the update to decoherence or branching.

      Thus, while the Lüders rule is a specific quantum transformation, its interpretation as "collapse" requires philosophical assumptions beyond the algebra.


    Summary

    1. Non-Quantum (Commutative): The Bayesian update is uniquely defined via conditional expectation.
    2. Quantum (Non-Commutative): Multiple transformations exist (e.g., Lüders rule vs. alternative orderings), only becoming equivalent in the commutative limit.
    3. Quantum Transformations: The Lüders rule corresponds to wave function collapse in the standard formalism, but interpretations of its physical meaning (e.g., collapse vs. branching) require additional philosophical assumptions.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.