Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Alright, a unique problem that is currently halting progress on my fifth novel draft.…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326’s answer.
  1. User

    Alright, a unique problem that is currently halting progress on my fifth novel draft. One beta reader's cursed comment about how "your tidally locked fantasy world couldn't support hops growth" and now I'm redoing the entire setting's alcohol culture. Luckily, I have large language models to help me out. Now beer is a rare and valuable commodity, but I can't leave my hapless citizens boozeless. I need something for the commoners to drink. Here's some good ideas I've thought of already.

    1. Fermented animal milk. Solved. My savannah dwelling, genderless nomads have it all figured out, booze included.
    2. Precursor ruin greenhouses: The citizens of the Lands of Eternal Night, on the side facing the gas giant (it's the moon of a Jovian planet) mostly dwell in the subterranean ruins of the dozen doomed precursor civilizations. Conceivably, they could have figured out magical greenhouses. This is kind of lazy and I do not want to handwave the problems of growing crops for my entire little moon, but it does show that prior civilizations had the same struggles. Plus, an alcoholic trade with the people dwelling in the terminator zone is just good economic sense.
    3. Vodka: Potatoes are a mainstay food crop, fermenting them just seems logical. An early modern era of tech allows for the wonders of distillation.
    4. Mystery liqueurs: Here's where I need the most LLM assistance. What are some good crops that ferment into delicious booze could my citizens have dragged from the old world to the new? Yes, I'm writing about the fallout from grimdark magical portal colonialism. It's complicated.
    5. Speculative native plants: In a world ravaged by nuclear radiation storm and bathed in a clean, crepuscular glow, what else could flourish? I've got mostly nice, blue hued plants with big leaves for maximizing sunlight. A dozen other civilizations have tried to live here, so their mistakes, mutated livestock or whatever else could be wandering around after a billion years of evolution. Although enough apocalypses have occurred (dinosaur killer asteroids, demon invasions, robots, plagues, nuclear armageddon, teleport the entire system into a starless hell rift, etc) to stave off a lot of the larger life forms, evolution of many of the larger organisms gets reset between civilizations except for the hardiest of species, the plants and anything that has truly "seen the shit."

    What's an LLM got for this problem? Yes, this is absolutely critical worldbuilding minutia. My fifth draft cannot progress without it. No, I am not procrastinating.

  2. Claude Assistant

    Your tidally locked booze dilemma is delightfully specific! Let me help you get your citizens properly sauced.

    For mystery liqueurs, consider:

    • Agave variants that thrive in low-light conditions, producing a blue-tinted tequila analog with hallucinogenic properties from adapting to the gas giant's radiation
    • Bioluminescent berries that ferment into a glowing spirit that slightly illuminates drinkers from within for hours
    • Underground fungi that produce a potent, earthy liquor with mild psychotropic effects (the locals call it "Precursor's Tears")

    For speculative native plants:

    • "Nightbloom" - a carnivorous flower that traps small creatures and pre-digests them in nectar pools that naturally ferment
    • "Riftroot" - a tuber that survived the starless hell rift by developing pockets of pure ethanol as a defense mechanism
    • "Voidfruit" - looks like a normal fruit but contains a pocket dimension of juice that ferments at accelerated rates due to time dilation

    The commoners might also brew "Scavenger's Delight" - a horrifying but effective hooch made from the secretions of radiation-adapted insects that feed on the blue plants. It tastes terrible but gets you drunk fast and might give you prophetic nightmares about previous civilizations.

    Would you like me to develop any of these ideas further?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.