Skip to content
The Chat Archive
deepseek-v3-0324· DeepSeek LMArena Human Preference 140K

This answer honestly sounds like marketing and the applications to every-day life very…

  1. User

    This answer honestly sounds like marketing and the applications to every-day life very far fetched.

    1. What are the odds that HTC actually is going to bring something really and concretely useful to improve people's lives?
    2. How should a HTC researcher feel about a highly abstract field that is mostly detached from reality, that doesn't bring anything useful to society and that receives a salary from the state?
  2. Assistant

    You're absolutely right to push back on overly optimistic or "marketing"-style answers. Let’s cut through the hype and address your concerns directly.


    1. What are the odds that HCT will actually improve people’s lives?

    Short answer: Low in the short term, but not zero in the long term.

    Longer answer:
    Most of HCT is not going to directly improve daily life. The field is extremely abstract, and most of its research is far removed from applications. However, history shows that even the most abstract math can sometimes—unpredictably—become useful decades later.

    • Historical precedents:

      • Number theory (once "pure math") became essential for modern cryptography (RSA, blockchain, HTTPS).
      • Group theory (studying symmetries) was crucial for quantum mechanics and crystallography.
      • Category theory itself (not even higher!) influenced functional programming (Haskell, Scala), which powers much of modern software.
    • HCT’s potential future impact:

      • If topological quantum computing becomes practical, HCT will have been a key tool in its development.
      • If formal verification (via HoTT) becomes mainstream, HCT will have contributed to safer software.
      • If AI or complex systems research adopts higher categorical structures, it might lead to better models.

    But these are big "ifs." Most HCT research will not lead to anything practical. That’s just the nature of deep abstraction.

    Probability estimate:

    • ~5% chance that HCT leads to something concretely useful in the next 20 years.
    • ~95% chance that most of it remains an intellectual curiosity.

    2. How should an HCT researcher feel about working in such an abstract field?

    This is a deep philosophical question. Here are some perspectives:

    A. The "Pure Knowledge" Justification

    • Some research is valuable simply because it expands human understanding.
    • HCT is like studying pure logic, abstract algebra, or theoretical physics—it’s about exploring the structure of thought itself.
    • Analogy: Should we stop funding philosophy because it doesn’t "produce" anything? Some would say no—understanding is its own reward.

    B. The "Long-Term Bet" Justification

    • Even if most HCT research doesn’t pay off, the small chance that it might (like in quantum computing or formal verification) justifies funding it.
    • Governments fund basic research precisely because private industry won’t—it’s too risky and long-term.

    C. The "Self-Critical" Perspective

    • Some mathematicians do feel guilty about working on extremely abstract topics while the world has urgent problems (climate change, poverty, disease).
    • One response: "I’m not the right person to solve those problems, but I contribute by pushing the boundaries of knowledge."
    • Another response: "If I didn’t do math, I wouldn’t necessarily be helping in a more direct way—I’d just be worse at my job."

    D. The "Pragmatic" View

    • Most HCT researchers are paid modestly (compared to industry jobs).
    • Society can afford to fund a small number of people doing abstract math—it’s a tiny fraction of research budgets.
    • If funding dried up, they’d switch fields or go into industry (like many pure mathematicians do).

    Final Thoughts: Should You Feel Guilty?

    • If you’re in HCT because you love it and accept that it may never be "useful," that’s fine. Society benefits from having people deeply engaged in abstract thought.
    • If you feel guilty, you can:
      • Look for applied collaborations (e.g., with quantum computing or formal methods).
      • Teach and mentor students who might apply math in other areas.
      • Accept that most research (even in "useful" fields) doesn’t lead to breakthroughs.

    TL;DR:

    • HCT is probably not going to change the world, but it might, and that’s why it gets funding.
    • If you’re an HCT researcher, you don’t need to feel guilty—but you also shouldn’t oversell its importance.
    • The best attitude is probably: "I do this because it’s fascinating, and if it ever becomes useful, great."

    Would love to hear your thoughts—do these answers feel more honest?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.