Okay so my origin server is at hydrabad. And I am using fastly, which is caching…
- User
Okay so my origin server is at hydrabad. And I am using fastly, which is caching contents at origin shield and then edge pop both. Now 99.9 % of my users should be from India and of which 85% should be from West Bengal Kolkata. Where should I put the shield location? Kolkata near to 75-80 % user or hydrabad near to origin shield? Ping to hydrabad pop from origin server in 2 ms, kolkata is 25ms. Users to Kolkata pop ping is 5 ms.
- Assistant
Let's break down your decision by considering both the user experience and server efficiency. Here are the key factors to consider:
-
User Proximity:
- 85% of your users are from West Bengal, Kolkata.
- Users to Kolkata POP ping is 5 ms.
-
Origin Server Proximity:
- Your origin server is in Hyderabad.
- Ping to Hyderabad POP from the origin server is 2 ms.
- Ping to Kolkata POP from the origin server is 25 ms.
-
Fastly's Caching Layers:
- Origin Shield: A central, high-capacity cache that sits between your origin server and the Edge POPs. It reduces the load on your origin server by caching content closer to it.
- Edge POPs: These are distributed globally and are closer to the end-users.
Analysis
Option 1: Shield Location in Hyderabad (Near Origin Server)
-
Pros:
- The origin shield is very close to the origin server (2 ms ping), which means that when content is not in the Edge POP cache, it can quickly fetch it from the origin shield.
- Reduces the load on the origin server because the origin shield will cache the content and serve it to the Edge POPs.
-
Cons:
- The Edge POP in Kolkata will have to fetch missed cache content from the origin shield in Hyderabad, which has a 25 ms ping. This could introduce some additional latency compared to if the origin shield were closer to the Edge POP.
Option 2: Shield Location in Kolkata (Near Majority of Users)
-
Pros:
- The Edge POP in Kolkata will have lower latency when fetching missed cache content from the origin shield, as the ping is only 5 ms.
- Since 85% of your users are in Kolkata, this could improve the overall user experience for the majority of your users.
-
Cons:
- The origin shield is farther from the origin server (25 ms ping). This means that when the origin shield needs to fetch content from the origin server it will introduce additional latency compared to if the origin shield were closer to the origin server.
- This could increase the load on your origin server because the origin shield, being further away, might result in more frequent requests to the origin as it takes longer to fetch and cache the content.
Recommendation
Given that 85% of your users are in West Bengal, Kolkata and considering the user experience is often the top priority for content delivery networks (CDNs), the best option is to place the origin shield in Hyderabad.
Here’s why:
-
Origin Server Efficiency: The primary role of the origin shield is to reduce the load on your origin server. By placing it in Hyderabad, you ensure that the origin shield can quickly fetch content from the origin server (2 ms ping). This efficiently reduces the load on your origin server which is crucial for maintaining performance and reducing costs.
-
Edge POP Efficiency: While the Edge POP in Kolkata will have a 25 ms ping to the origin shield this latency is still relatively low and acceptable. More importantly since most requests will be served from the Edge POP cache itself, the instances where the Edge POP needs to fetch from the origin shield will be relatively rare. Therefore, the slight increase in latency when fetching from the origin shield won't significantly impact the majority of user requests.
-
Overall System Performance: By optimising the connection between the origin server and the origin shield you ensure that the entire CDN operates more efficiently. This benefits all Edge POPs including the one in Kolkata because they will more consistently receive cached content from a well-fed origin shield.
In summary placing the origin shield in Hyderabad balances both the need to reduce load on the origin server and to maintain low latency for the Edge POPs thereby optimising the overall performance of your CDN for your user base.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.