So, I'm fat and 32. I thought about it for a long time, for years and years, and the…
- User
So, I'm fat and 32. I thought about it for a long time, for years and years, and the fact of it is, I'm just not really attracted to dating fat people. The honest truth is I just want to date conventionally attractive guys. I think it's also kind of like I'm not a super sexually driven person and also like I'm not like super desperate to be in a relationship, so as a result, it's like I'm only really driven to be in a relationship if I were to be with someone who I'm like genuinely very attracted. Like if it was someone where I'm going to think to myself, "I guess maybe they're OK in terms of attractiveness, like I don't really think I would even want to have sex with them at all." If I were thin, I would have dated someone by now at some point probably. Is this like a common thing with that like people just don't ever be in a relationship just because they are really only attracted to people that are more attractive than that they can get?
Assistant
You've touched on a complex and emotionally charged intersection of attraction, self-perception, and dating realities. Here's a breakdown of your situation and the questions you raised:
-
Your Preferences Are Valid (But Complex):
- It's absolutely valid to have physical preferences. Everyone does. Wanting to feel strong attraction to a partner is normal and important for many people, especially if sexual compatibility matters to you at all (even if you're not "super sexually driven").
- The complication arises when your own self-perceived level of attractiveness (based on being "fat") clashes with the level of attractiveness you desire in a partner ("conventionally attractive"). This creates a perceived mismatch.
-
Is This a Common Experience? Yes, in various forms.
- The "League" Concept: The idea of "dating leagues" (attractiveness tiers) is pervasive, though flawed. Many people, regardless of size, experience unrequited attraction or feel they can't "get" the people they find most desirable. This can stem from:
- Societal Beauty Standards: We're bombarded with images equating thinness (and other specific traits) with desirability. Internalizing these standards affects both who we find attractive and how we judge our own dateability.
- Self-Esteem & Self-Perception: If you don't feel attractive yourself, it can be hard to believe someone you find highly attractive would genuinely desire you. This can lead to self-sabotage or avoidance.
- Fear of Rejection: The fear of approaching or being rejected by someone you find extremely attractive can be paralyzing.
- Selectivity Based on Low Motivation: Your lack of desperation and lower sexual drive does make you more selective. If the baseline motivation to date isn't high, only a strong pull (like intense attraction) will overcome the inertia. This is also common, especially as people get older and more settled in their lives. People with lower "relationship drive" naturally have higher thresholds for entering relationships.
- The "League" Concept: The idea of "dating leagues" (attractiveness tiers) is pervasive, though flawed. Many people, regardless of size, experience unrequited attraction or feel they can't "get" the people they find most desirable. This can stem from:
-
The Core Tension & Potential Contradictions:
- Self-Perception vs. Preference: You state a clear preference for conventional attractiveness while labeling yourself in a way (using "fat" somewhat negatively) that you believe excludes you from that category. This creates a fundamental conflict: "I want X, but I am not X, therefore I cannot get X."
- Subjectivity of Attraction: "Conventionally attractive" is a broad cultural standard, but individual attraction is highly subjective. Many people find different body types attractive. Some "conventionally attractive" people prefer partners who don't fit that mold. Assuming that all "conventionally attractive" guys only want thin partners is an overgeneralization.
- Attraction Beyond the Immediate: While initial physical spark is important, attraction often deepens and changes based on personality, connection, shared values, humor, intelligence, confidence, and chemistry. Writing someone off solely because they don't meet an initial "conventionally attractive" standard might mean missing out on someone you could become intensely attracted to once you know them. Your statement about not even wanting to have sex with someone you find only "OK" highlights this – but that "OK" feeling might change with connection.
-
The "If I Were Thin" Assumption:
- This is a natural thought, but it's impossible to know for sure. Being thin doesn't guarantee dating success or guarantee attracting the specific "conventionally attractive" partners you desire. Dating involves compatibility, timing, personality, confidence, social skills, and luck, on top of physical attraction. Thin people also experience rejection, loneliness, and difficulty finding partners they are intensely attracted to.
-
Potential Paths Forward (Not Mutually Exclusive):
- Examine Your Standards & Openness:
- Are you absolutely certain you've never encountered someone outside the strict "conventional" mold who sparked genuine attraction? Could your current mindset be creating a filter that prevents you from even noticing potential?
- Could you be open to connections where the initial physical spark might be "pretty good" or "interesting" rather than "intense," knowing attraction can grow? This doesn't mean dating people you find actively unattractive, but perhaps being less rigid about the immediate intensity of the spark.
- Work on Self-Acceptance & Confidence:
- This is crucial. How you feel about yourself radiates outwards. Confidence (not arrogance) is incredibly attractive, regardless of body size. Working on body neutrality or positivity (focusing on what your body does for you, finding styles that make you feel good, engaging in joyful movement) can shift your energy.
- Therapy can be invaluable for unpacking internalized fatphobia, improving self-esteem, and challenging negative thought patterns about your desirability.
- Expand Your Social Circles & Exposure:
- Put yourself in situations (hobbies, events, interest groups) where you meet new people organically. Shared interests are powerful connectors and can make someone much more attractive. Online dating, while frustrating, does expose you to a wider range of people than you might meet otherwise – be clear about your interests and values in your profile.
- Focus on Connection First: Prioritize meeting people you genuinely enjoy talking to and connecting with intellectually/emotionally. See if attraction develops from there. Sometimes the way someone engages with the world makes them incredibly attractive.
- Accept Your Selectivity: If your current level of attraction is the only thing that will motivate you to date, and you're genuinely content being single, that's a valid choice. Own it without resentment. Focus on building a fulfilling life on your own terms.
- Examine Your Standards & Openness:
In Conclusion: Yes, your experience – feeling restricted in dating due to a mismatch between your own self-perceived attractiveness and your attraction preferences, especially when combined with lower relationship motivation – is a recognizable dynamic. It stems from internalized societal standards, personal self-perception, and the natural selectivity that comes with lower drive.
The key question is: Does this situation cause you distress, or are you content? If it causes distress, the paths forward involve challenging your assumptions (both about attractiveness and your own desirability), working on self-acceptance, and potentially broadening your perspective on how attraction develops. If you're genuinely content being single unless that intense spark hits, then it's simply your current reality. The most important thing is to approach this with honesty towards yourself and kindness towards yourself and others.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.