Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Amazon Novaamazon.nova-pro-v1:0· AmazonHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Bit confused at the moment. Consider the blowup of A^2 at the origin. There's the notion…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-3-mini-beta’s answer.
  1. User

    Bit confused at the moment. Consider the blowup of A^2 at the origin. There's the notion of the strict transform of a closed subscheme of A^2. But what's the strict transform of the point we blew up?

  2. Amazon Nova Assistant

    When you blow up the affine plane (\mathbb{A}^2) at the origin, the strict transform of the origin itself is not a point in the blown-up space. Instead, it is replaced by the exceptional divisor, which is a projective line (\mathbb{P}^1).

    To elaborate:

    1. Blowup of (\mathbb{A}^2) at the Origin:

      • The blowup of (\mathbb{A}^2) at the origin replaces the origin with the projective line (\mathbb{P}^1).
      • The blown-up space, often denoted as (\text{Bl}_0(\mathbb{A}^2)), consists of the original (\mathbb{A}^2) minus the origin, together with the exceptional divisor (\mathbb{P}^1).
    2. Exceptional Divisor:

      • The exceptional divisor (\mathbb{P}^1) is the set of all lines in (\mathbb{A}^2) that pass through the origin.
      • Each point on (\mathbb{P}^1) corresponds to a direction in (\mathbb{A}^2).
    3. Strict Transform:

      • For a closed subscheme (Z \subset \mathbb{A}^2) that does not contain the origin, its strict transform under the blowup is simply its preimage in the blown-up space, excluding any components that lie entirely in the exceptional divisor.
      • However, for the origin itself, there is no strict transform in the usual sense because the origin is replaced entirely by the exceptional divisor.

    In summary, the "strict transform" of the origin in the blowup of (\mathbb{A}^2) at the origin is the exceptional divisor (\mathbb{P}^1), not a single point.

  3. User

    Ah ok: I think you're saying that Proj(k) is empty, not a point!

  4. Amazon Nova Assistant

    Yes, that's a good way to think about it, especially in the context of projective schemes. Let's clarify a bit more:

    Proj Construction

    The (\text{Proj}) construction is a way to build projective schemes. For a graded ring (S), (\text{Proj}(S)) is a scheme that intuitively represents the projective space associated with (S).

    Case of (k)

    • When (S = k) (where (k) is a field), (k) is a graded ring concentrated in degree 0.
    • The (\text{Proj}(k)) construction yields an empty scheme. This is because there are no homogeneous elements of positive degree in (k) to generate any projective space.

    Blowup and the Origin

    • In the context of blowing up (\mathbb{A}^2) at the origin, the origin itself doesn’t have a strict transform in the traditional sense because it is replaced by the exceptional divisor (\mathbb{P}^1).
    • The exceptional divisor (\mathbb{P}^1) can be thought of as the "projectivization" of the directions through the origin, and it’s what you get when you blow up a point.

    Summary

    • (\text{Proj}(k)) is indeed empty.
    • The origin in (\mathbb{A}^2), when blown up, is replaced by the exceptional divisor (\mathbb{P}^1), not by a single point.

    So, your understanding is correct: (\text{Proj}(k)) is empty, and the origin in the blowup is replaced by the exceptional divisor.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.