Give me the best benchmark task that I can ask to compare models on LMArena.
- User
Give me the best benchmark task that I can ask to compare models on LMArena.
- Assistant
The best benchmark task to compare models on LMArena (Large Model Arena) will depend on your specific goals—e.g., general intelligence, reasoning ability, instruction-following, coding, or truthfulness. However, one widely accepted and comprehensive benchmark that balances difficulty, coverage, and model differentiation is:
🔥 "MMLU" (Massive Multitask Language Understanding)
Why it's the best all-around benchmark:
- Diverse subject areas (57 tasks, including history, mathematics, law, medicine, and more).
- Balances knowledge and reasoning.
- Used extensively in academic papers (e.g., GPT-4’s original benchmark).
- Models struggle to "overfit" due to its breadth.
- Great for detecting whether a model is just large vs. truly intelligent.
✅ How to use it on LMArena:
Ask LMArena:
💬 "Run an MMLU benchmark. Show results by subject area and overall accuracy. Also compare reasoning-focused categories like logical reasoning, mathematics, and formal logic."
This will:
- Compare models on both knowledge and reasoning tasks.
- Highlight differences in capability, especially between near-parity models (e.g., GPT-4o vs. Claude 3 vs. Gemini).
🧠 Bonus High-Difficulty Tasks (if you want more specialization):
If you're testing specific capabilities, use these:
- Hellaswag or BBH (Big-Bench Hard) – for reasoning and common sense.
- HumanEval or MBPP – for code generation ability.
- TruthfulQA – for factual reliability.
- ARC – for scientific and abstract reasoning.
Ask:
"Compare models on Big-Bench Hard benchmark with detailed reasoning scores."
"Run HumanEval code generation task to compare models’ coding accuracy."
Summary
Best general benchmark:
✅ MMLU – Most reliable, balanced, and informative across knowledge and reasoning.
Best benchmarks by skill:
Skill Benchmark General Reasoning BBH, MMLU Coding HumanEval, MBPP Truthfulness TruthfulQA Math GSM8K, MATH Science ARC, MMLU (sci) Let me know your focus area and I can craft the exact prompt to use on LMArena.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.