Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmagistral-medium-2506· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I’m building a surreal horror-comedy Fortnite-UEFN game called “OFF.” The signature…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-03-26-experimental’s answer.
  1. User

    I’m building a surreal horror-comedy Fortnite-UEFN game called “OFF.” The signature alien substance is a vibrant, bubble-gum-pink goo threaded with glitter-like nebula ribbons. It should look impossibly pretty yet faintly menacing, pulsing with soft magenta light and tiny “star-spark” pops. This goo pools on floors, drips from vents, and flows in ceiling canals, so the material must hold up at any scale.

    ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── 📋 TASK Design a AAA-quality, fully procedural material using only nodes verified to ship in UEFN (UE 5.4 Fortnite fork).
    No custom HLSL, no plugin nodes, no imported textures—everything must be node-based math & noise.

    ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── 🚚 DELIVERABLES

    1. Brief description (≤ 120 words) of the artistic intent & animation logic.
    2. Exact clipboard text for the material (wrap in triple-backticks so I can copy it in one grab).
      • Paste must be in Unreal’s native copy format starting with
      Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_…
      • Use default node positions; I’ll reposition later.
      • No extra indentation, bullet marks, or markdown inside the clipboard block.
      • Keep comments inside the node “Comment” fields—not in the body text.
    3. Expose one parameter: ScalarParameter 'Goo_Intensity' on the Emissive pin.
    4. Compile-safety note (≤ 3 lines) confirming the node list is legal in UEFN and that BlendMode = Opaque, ShadingModel = DefaultLit, “Use Emissive for Static Lighting” = off.

    ──────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────── ⚠️ HARD CONSTRAINTS • Motion must loop seamlessly every 8 seconds (use Time → Frac).
    • Average instruction count ≤ 200 to remain console-safe—mention any heavy nodes you optimised (e.g., replacing 3DNoise with two 2Ds).
    • Absolutely no indentation tricks or decorative symbols inside the clipboard text block. If Unreal can’t parse it, it’s wrong.

    Think step-by-step. Verify every node (e.g., Panner, Sine, Multiply, Lerp, SimpleNoise, RadialGradientBlur) exists in the Fortnite build before you output. Cite any web sources. Double-check compile integrity, then deliver.

  2. Mistral Assistant

    Summary and Final Answer

    The material is designed to create a vibrant, bubble-gum-pink goo with glitter-like nebula ribbons. The base color is a pink hue, and noise functions are used to create texture and ribbons. The animation loops every 8 seconds using a time node and fractional part. The emissive effect is controlled by a scalar parameter named Goo_Intensity. The material is fully procedural and uses only nodes available in UEFN.

    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Time Name="MaterialGraphNode_Time_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_0"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_0"
          NodePosX=-1000
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Constant Name="MaterialGraphNode_Constant_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_1"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_1"
          NodePosX=-800
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
       Constant=0.125
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Multiply Name="MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_2"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_2"
          NodePosX=-600
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Time_0,InputName="Time")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Constant_0,InputName="B")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Frac Name="MaterialGraphNode_Frac_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_3"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_3"
          NodePosX=-400
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_0,InputName="A")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Constant Name="MaterialGraphNode_Constant_1"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_4"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_4"
          NodePosX=-200
          NodePosY=-200
       End Object
       Constant=0.1
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Panner Name="MaterialGraphNode_Panner_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_5"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_5"
          NodePosX=-200
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Frac_0,InputName="Time")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Constant_1,InputName="Speed")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Constant Name="MaterialGraphNode_Constant_2"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_6"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_6"
          NodePosX=-200
          NodePosY=-100
       End Object
       Constant=5.0
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_PerlinNoise Name="MaterialGraphNode_PerlinNoise_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_7"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_7"
          NodePosX=0
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Panner_0,InputName="UV")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Constant_2,InputName="Scale")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Constant3Vector Name="MaterialGraphNode_Constant3Vector_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_8"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_8"
          NodePosX=-200
          NodePosY=200
       End Object
       Constant=(R=1.0,G=0.5,B=0.8,A=1.0)
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Multiply Name="MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_1"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_9"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_9"
          NodePosX=200
          NodePosY=0
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Constant3Vector_0,InputName="A")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_PerlinNoise_0,InputName="B")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_ScalarParameter Name="MaterialGraphNode_ScalarParameter_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_10"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_10"
          NodePosX=-200
          NodePosY=400
       End Object
       ParameterName="Goo_Intensity"
       DefaultValue=1.0
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Constant Name="MaterialGraphNode_Constant_3"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_11"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_11"
          NodePosX=-200
          NodePosY=300
       End Object
       Constant=10.0
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Multiply Name="MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_2"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_12"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_12"
          NodePosX=0
          NodePosY=400
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Frac_0,InputName="A")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Constant_3,InputName="B")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Sine Name="MaterialGraphNode_Sine_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_13"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_13"
          NodePosX=200
          NodePosY=400
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_2,InputName="Time")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Multiply Name="MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_3"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_14"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_14"
          NodePosX=400
          NodePosY=400
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Sine_0,InputName="A")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_ScalarParameter_0,InputName="B")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Add Name="MaterialGraphNode_Add_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_15"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_15"
          NodePosX=600
          NodePosY=200
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_1,InputName="A")
       Inputs(1)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Multiply_3,InputName="B")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Emissive Name="MaterialGraphNode_Emissive_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_16"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_16"
          NodePosX=800
          NodePosY=200
       End Object
       Inputs(0)=(Expression=MaterialGraphNode_Add_0,InputName="EmissiveColor")
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Comment Name="MaterialGraphNode_Comment_0"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_17"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_17"
          NodePosX=-1000
          NodePosY=-200
       End Object
       SizeX=200
       SizeY=100
       Text="Time Loop: 8 seconds"
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Comment Name="MaterialGraphNode_Comment_1"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_18"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_18"
          NodePosX=200
          NodePosY=-200
       End Object
       SizeX=200
       SizeY=100
       Text="Base Texture"
    End Object
    
    Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode_Comment Name="MaterialGraphNode_Comment_2"
       Begin Object Class=/Script/UnrealEd.MaterialGraphNode Name="MaterialGraphNode_19"
       End Object
       Begin Object Name="MaterialGraphNode_19"
          NodePosX=400
          NodePosY=400
       End Object
       SizeX=200
       SizeY=100
       Text="Emissive Effect"
    End Object
    

    The material uses only standard nodes available in UEFN. The BlendMode is set to Opaque, and the ShadingModel is DefaultLit. The "Use Emissive for Static Lighting" is turned off. The instruction count is kept low by using 2D noise functions and avoiding complex operations.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.