Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Why are computers not placed inside toilet tanks? The water could provide cooling and be…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash’s answer.
  1. User

    Why are computers not placed inside toilet tanks? The water could provide cooling and be made more efficient by having dual uses.

  2. Qwen Assistant

    That's an interesting and creative idea! At first glance, placing a computer inside a toilet tank might seem like a clever way to utilize unused space and take advantage of the water for cooling. However, there are several practical, technical, and safety-related reasons why this isn't a good idea or feasible:


    1. Moisture and Corrosion

    • Water is corrosive: Even though the computer would need to be sealed to avoid direct contact with water, small leaks or condensation could damage sensitive electronics over time.
    • Humidity in bathrooms: Bathrooms are naturally humid environments. This increases the risk of moisture getting into components, which can lead to short circuits or long-term degradation.

    2. Cooling Isn't That Simple

    • Water ≠ efficient liquid cooling without engineering: While liquid cooling systems in computers do use water (or other coolants), they are carefully engineered closed-loop systems with pumps, radiators, and heat exchangers. Simply submerging electronics in water (even if insulated) doesn’t equate to effective or safe cooling.
    • Heat dissipation: Computers generate a lot of heat. If you dump that heat into the toilet tank water, it will raise the temperature of the water, potentially affecting flushing performance and possibly causing issues like evaporation or mineral buildup.

    3. Accessibility and Maintenance

    • Toilet tanks require maintenance: Valves, floats, and flappers often need adjustments or replacements. Having a computer in the tank would make servicing much more complicated.
    • Risk of damage during repairs: Any work on the toilet could accidentally damage the computer hardware.

    4. Power and Connectivity

    • Wiring challenges: Running power and data cables into a toilet tank creates a risk of water exposure and complicates installation.
    • Safety concerns: Electrical devices near water always pose a shock hazard unless extremely well isolated.

    5. Space Constraints and Practicality

    • Limited space: Toilet tanks are relatively small and irregularly shaped, making them unsuitable for most computer hardware, especially anything beyond minimal embedded systems.
    • Not scalable: You wouldn’t be able to build a powerful or upgradeable system in such a confined space.

    6. Better Alternatives Exist

    • Purpose-built cooling systems: Dedicated liquid cooling loops or even immersion cooling (where components are submerged in non-conductive coolant) already exist and are far safer and more effective than using toilet water.
    • Unused space elsewhere: There are better places in a home to mount a computer or server — under desks, in walls, or in dedicated closets — where cooling, access, and safety aren't compromised.

    A Fun Thought Experiment

    While not practical for real-world computing, this idea could inspire:

    • Art installations or conceptual tech designs that challenge traditional notions of space and function.
    • Low-power IoT devices, like smart toilet sensors or water usage monitors, that might sit partially inside a tank — but these are far less demanding than full computers.

    Conclusion

    Although the concept of dual-use space and passive cooling sounds appealing, the risks and limitations far outweigh the benefits when it comes to placing actual computers in toilet tanks. Engineering a safe, efficient, and maintainable system for such an environment would be impractical compared to existing alternatives.

    Let me know if you want to explore how to safely cool computers using water — there are some fascinating methods out there!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.