Presbyterians and baptists would agree that those who fall away were not real…
- User
Presbyterians and baptists would agree that those who fall away were not real Christians. The difference is inn the nature of the new covenant. Presbyterians use these texts to prove that the new covenant is mixed. How would baptists respond?
Assistant
Reformed Baptists would respond to the Presbyterian claim (that Hebrews 6:4–6 and 10:26–29 prove the New Covenant is mixed) by making several key distinctions:
1. The New Covenant is Not Like the Old Covenant in Composition
Presbyterians argue that the New Covenant, like the Old, includes both believers and unbelievers (a "mixed" community). But Baptists insist:
- Jeremiah 31:31–34 and Ezekiel 36:25–27 describe the New Covenant as one where all members know the Lord and have their sins forgiven.
- Unlike the Old Covenant (which included unbelieving Israelites), the New Covenant is unbreakable and made only with the elect.
- Therefore, those who fall away in Hebrews were never truly in the New Covenant—they were merely part of the visible church (the external covenant community).
Baptist Response:
"The warnings in Hebrews don’t prove the New Covenant is mixed; they prove that the visible church is mixed. The New Covenant itself is unbreakable and consists only of the regenerate."
2. The Warnings Are Addressed to the Visible Church, Not the Covenant Itself
Presbyterians see Hebrews as addressing the covenant community (including some who may apostatize), but Baptists argue:
- The warnings are given to professing Christians, not necessarily to those in the covenant of grace.
- 1 John 2:19 ("They went out from us, but they were not of us") shows that apostates were never truly saved.
- The descriptions in Hebrews 6:4–6 (enlightened, tasted heavenly gifts, shared in the Spirit) refer to external privileges, not regeneration.
Baptist Response:
"The warnings are real, but they don’t imply a mixed New Covenant—they imply a mixed visible church. The true New Covenant is only with the elect."
3. Baptism Reflects the Nature of the New Covenant
Presbyterians argue that baptism, like circumcision, is a sign of the covenant given to believers and their children, implying a mixed community. Baptists counter:
- Baptism is for believers only because the New Covenant is for believers only.
- The Old Covenant included physical descendants, but the New Covenant is spiritual and regenerate (John 1:12–13; 3:5–8).
- Apostasy in Hebrews shows why baptism should only follow credible profession—it guards the purity of the covenant sign.
Baptist Response:
"If the New Covenant were mixed, infant baptism would make sense. But since it’s regenerate, baptism should follow faith."
4. The New Covenant’s Promises Are Only for the Elect
Presbyterians see covenant membership as broader than election, but Baptists argue:
- Hebrews 8:10–11 ("I will put my laws into their minds… they shall all know me") applies only to the regenerate.
- Those who fall away in Hebrews never had this inward transformation—they only had outward association.
- The New Covenant’s blessings (forgiveness, the Spirit, perseverance) are only for the elect.
Baptist Response:
"The New Covenant’s promises don’t fail—those who apostatize were never part of it to begin with."
Summary of the Baptist vs. Presbyterian Debate
Issue Presbyterian View Baptist Response Nature of the New Covenant Mixed (includes some unbelievers) Regenerate-only (Jer. 31, Ezek. 36) Hebrews 6 & 10 Apostates Covenant members who fell away Never in the covenant; only in the visible church Baptism Sign for believers + infants Sign for believers only (credible profession required) Warnings in Hebrews Prove the covenant is mixed Prove the visible church is mixed, not the covenant itself
Final Baptist Answer to the Presbyterian Claim
"Hebrews 6 and 10 don’t teach that the New Covenant is mixed; they teach that the visible church is mixed. The true New Covenant is unbreakable and consists only of the elect. Those who fall away were never truly part of it—they merely tasted its blessings externally. Therefore, the Baptist view preserves both the warnings of Hebrews and the regenerate nature of the New Covenant."
This maintains the doctrine of perseverance while rejecting the idea that the New Covenant includes unbelievers.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.