Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What's the highest energy density you can likely reach without creating a black hole?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Geminigemini-2.5-flash’s answer.
  1. User

    What's the highest energy density you can likely reach without creating a black hole?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    The highest energy density you can likely reach without forming a black hole is governed by the point at which compressing matter or energy into a region of space causes its Schwarzschild radius to exceed the size of that region — i.e., when it collapses into a black hole.


    Key Concept: Schwarzschild Radius

    For any mass MM, the Schwarzschild radius rsr_s is:

    rs=2GMc2r_s = \frac{2 G M}{c^2}

    This is the radius below which the mass MM would form a black hole. Since energy and mass are equivalent via E=Mc2E = Mc^2, we can reframe this in terms of energy density.


    Energy Density Limit

    Let’s define energy density ρ\rho as energy per unit volume:

    ρ=EV\rho = \frac{E}{V}

    If we compress energy EE into a spherical volume of radius rr, then:

    • Volume V=43πr3V = \frac{4}{3} \pi r^3
    • The critical condition for black hole formation is: r≤rs=2GEc4r \leq r_s = \frac{2 G E}{c^4}

    Substitute E=ρVE = \rho V into the inequality:

    r≤2Gc4⋅ρ⋅(43πr3)r \leq \frac{2 G}{c^4} \cdot \rho \cdot \left( \frac{4}{3} \pi r^3 \right)

    Solving this gives a limit on the energy density before collapse:

    ρ≳3c68πG3M2\rho \gtrsim \frac{3 c^6}{8 \pi G^3 M^2}

    Alternatively, simplifying directly gives an approximate maximum energy density before black hole formation:

    ρmax∼c6G2ℏ≈10113 J/m3\rho_{\text{max}} \sim \frac{c^6}{G^2 \hbar} \approx 10^{113} \text{ J/m}^3

    But this is actually the Planck energy density, and is more relevant to quantum gravity.


    Practical Maximum (Without Quantum Gravity)

    A more practical upper bound — based on classical general relativity and avoiding quantum effects — occurs when the energy density becomes so high that the region would collapse into a black hole of comparable size. This gives us the critical energy density:

    ρBH∼c6G2M2\rho_{\text{BH}} \sim \frac{c^6}{G^2 M^2}

    Or in terms of Planck units:

    • Planck energy density ρP=EPℓP3=mPc2ℓP3≈10113 J/m3\rho_P = \frac{E_P}{\ell_P^3} = \frac{m_P c^2}{\ell_P^3} \approx 10^{113} \text{ J/m}^3

    But again, this is a theoretical extreme.


    Realistic Upper Bound

    In reality, the highest known energy densities achieved in nature are in:

    • Particle collisions (e.g., LHC): ~1034 J/m310^{34} \text{ J/m}^3
    • Neutron star cores: ~1035−1036 J/m310^{35} - 10^{36} \text{ J/m}^3
    • Early universe (microseconds after Big Bang): up to 1050 J/m310^{50} \text{ J/m}^3

    However, these are still far below black hole-forming thresholds.


    Final Estimate

    To avoid forming a black hole, the energy density must be below the threshold where the enclosed energy within a given radius satisfies:

    ρ<c4Gr2\rho < \frac{c^4}{G r^2}

    So, the maximum energy density depends inversely on the square of the size of the region. For example:

    • In a region of size r=1 fm=10−15 mr = 1 \text{ fm} = 10^{-15} \text{ m}: ρmax≈(3×108)4(6.67×10−11)(10−15)2≈1046 J/m3\rho_{\text{max}} \approx \frac{(3 \times 10^8)^4}{(6.67 \times 10^{-11})(10^{-15})^2} \approx 10^{46} \text{ J/m}^3

    Beyond that, a black hole would form.


    Summary

    ScenarioApproximate Max Energy Density
    Particle Colliders1034 J/m310^{34} \text{ J/m}^3
    Neutron Star Core1035–1036 J/m310^{35}–10^{36} \text{ J/m}^3
    Pre-Big Bang UniverseUp to 1050 J/m310^{50} \text{ J/m}^3
    Black Hole Threshold (1 fm)∼1046 J/m3\sim 10^{46} \text{ J/m}^3
    Planck Energy Density∼10113 J/m3\sim 10^{113} \text{ J/m}^3

    ✅ Answer:
    You can likely reach energy densities up to roughly 1046 J/m3\mathbf{10^{46} \text{ J/m}^3} without forming a black hole, depending on the scale of the region. Beyond that, gravitational collapse becomes inevitable.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.