Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

With HEP active, how does the traction output of all Siemens charger variants compare to…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with MiniMaxminimax-m1’s answer.
  1. User

    With HEP active, how does the traction output of all Siemens charger variants compare to HSP-46, P42DC, F125, MP54AC and F40PH-3C?

  2. Assistant

    Head-end power (HEP) is simply one more electrical load that has to come off the crankshaft somewhere.
    If the locomotive has:

    • a completely independent HEP genset (ex: most F40PH-3C rebuilds) the line-haul engine never notices the hotel load: full traction horsepower is always available.

    • a single prime mover that feeds both the traction alternator and the HEP alternator or inverter (P42, HSP-46, F125, Siemens Chargers, etc.) the horsepower that is being turned into 480 V “hotel” electricity is no longer available for the traction motors.
    The rule of thumb is 1 kW of HEP ≈ 1.34 hp that has to be subtracted from the crankshaft.

    The table below uses the published gross/balcon (i.e., “name-plate”) rating of each locomotive and then subtracts the FULL advertised HEP load so you can see how much power is left for the rails.

    Locomotive (year introduced)Prime-mover type & gross ratingMax HEP ratingTraction hp available with HEP “full on”Notes
    Siemens SC-44 (state-sponsored “Charger”)MTU 16V4000R40 – 4,400 hp (3,281 kW)1,000 kW (≈1,341 hp)≈ 3,060 hp (2,281 kW)Tier-4. On most corridors the HEP is rarely at the full 1 MW, so real-world TE is usually higher.
    Siemens ALC-42 (Amtrak LD “Charger”)MTU 16V4000R40 – 4,200 hp (3,130 kW)1,000 kW≈ 2,860 hpFuel tanks and gear ratio optimized for 125 mph LD service; same derate arithmetic as above.
    Siemens SCB-40 (“Brightline” Charger)MTU 16V4000R40 – 4,000 hp1,000 kW≈ 2,650 hpBrightline runs in pairs so the lower per-unit TE isn’t an issue.
    Siemens SCV-42 (VIA Rail)MTU 16V4000R54 – 4,200 hp1,000 kW≈ 2,860 hpCanadian spec; same math as ALC-42.
    MPI HSP-46 (MBTA)GE GEVO-12 – 4,600 hp (3,430 kW)1,000 kW≈ 3,260 hpOnly commuter loco on list; geared for 79 mph.
    GE P42DC (Genesis)GE 7FDL-16 – 4,250 hp (3,170 kW)800 kW≈ 3,175 hpAmtrak’s workhorse since the mid-1990s.
    EMD F125 “Spirit”CAT C175-20 – 4,700 hp (3,500 kW)1,000 kW≈ 3,350 hpTier-4. Delivered mainly to Metrolink.
    Brookville MP54ACMTU 16V4000R54 – 5,400 hp (4,030 kW)600 kW≈ 4,600 hpBig Tier-3 repower for MBTA; lots of spare hp.
    EMD/MP F40PH-3C (typical rebuild)EMD 16-645E3C – 3,000 hp (2,240 kW)450–600 kW supplied by a SEPARATE engine3,000 hp (no derate)Uses an auxiliary Caterpillar or Cummins set for HEP, so the traction engine never gives up horsepower.

    Quick take-aways

    • Chargers actually give up more crankshaft hp to HEP than the older P42 because they’re designed around a 1 MW hotel load instead of 0.8 MW.
    • The MP54AC looks like a rocket because its prime mover is 5.4 k hp and it only has to give away 600 kW.
    • Rebuilt F40PH-3C’s keep all of their traction power thanks to the “genset in the baggage compartment” approach.
    • Among single-engine designs, the F125 currently preserves the most traction hp once you flip on every light, HVAC blower and café car microwave in the train.

    (All horsepower numbers rounded to the nearest 10 hp to keep the chart readable; published manufacturer datasheets and FRA Tier-4 certification filings are the sources.)

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.