Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.0-flash-001· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

give a rebuttal to: if there were an automated trading strategy to make money that…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with gpt-4.1-2025-04-14’s answer.
  1. User

    give a rebuttal to: if there were an automated trading strategy to make money that actually worked, they wouldn't be sharing it

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Okay, here's a rebuttal to the statement "If there were an automated trading strategy to make money that actually worked, they wouldn't be sharing it":

    While there's definitely a valid point in that statement, it's not universally true and doesn't account for several counter-arguments:

    • Different Motivation: Not everyone is motivated solely by maximizing personal profit. Some people might:
      • Enjoy teaching and sharing knowledge: Some people genuinely enjoy educating others and building a community. Sharing a successful strategy, even if it means diluting its edge slightly, can be a rewarding experience for them.
      • Use it as a Marketing Tool: Sharing a successful, yet incomplete, strategy could attract users to a paid service that gives the more advanced strategy.
      • Build a reputation: By open-sourcing or sharing a strategy, an individual can build a reputation as an expert in the field, which can lead to career opportunities, consulting gigs, or collaborations.
      • Seek validation and improvement: Sharing a strategy allows others to critique it, test it in different market conditions, and suggest improvements. This collaborative approach can lead to an even more robust and profitable system.
    • Limited Scalability: Some trading strategies might only work effectively with a limited amount of capital. Once too many people use it, the market impact diminishes its profitability. Sharing it might be a way to monetize the strategy beyond what the individual could achieve on their own.
    • Partial or Simplified Strategies: What's being shared might not be the entire secret sauce. It could be a simplified version, a specific component of a larger system, or a strategy that requires significant skill and knowledge to implement effectively. The sharer might be giving away the "what" but not the "how" or the full context.
    • Outdated Strategies: The market is constantly evolving. A strategy that worked well in the past might no longer be profitable due to changes in market dynamics, regulations, or the emergence of new technologies. Sharing it might be a way to get rid of a strategy that is no longer effective while still monetizing it.
    • Backtesting vs. Live Trading: A strategy might look amazing in backtests but fail miserably in live trading due to factors like slippage, latency, and unexpected market events. Sharing a backtested strategy is much less risky than sharing a live trading one.
    • The Sharer Isn't Trading: It's possible that the sharer is not even using the strategy themselves, but instead is selling it. They can profit from the sales of the strategy without the risk of live trading.

    In summary: While skepticism is healthy, it's a fallacy to assume that everyone sharing a trading strategy is necessarily lying or incompetent. There can be legitimate reasons for sharing information, and it's important to evaluate each situation on its own merits, considering the source, the claims being made, and the level of detail provided. The reality is often more nuanced than a simple binary of "true" or "false."

    It's still crucial to do your due diligence, test any strategy thoroughly, and understand the risks involved before implementing it with real money.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.