Skip to content
The Chat Archive
gemini-2.0-flash-001· Google LMArena Human Preference 140K

is it safe to keep an mp5k's bolt locked back long term?

  1. User

    is it safe to keep an mp5k's bolt locked back long term?

  2. Assistant

    Leaving an MP5K's bolt locked back long-term could potentially cause issues, although it's generally considered less problematic than leaving a magazine loaded for extended periods. Here's a breakdown of the considerations:

    • Spring Fatigue: The primary concern is the compression of the recoil spring. When the bolt is locked back, the recoil spring is under constant compression. Over a very long period (years), this constant compression could lead to some degree of spring fatigue and a slight reduction in its strength. However, modern spring steels are quite resilient, and the amount of degradation in a quality spring would likely be minimal and might not even be noticeable in function. The MP5's recoil spring is relatively robust.

    • Bolt Catch Wear: Constant pressure on the bolt catch could theoretically cause wear on the bolt catch and the notch in the bolt where it engages. Again, the wear would likely be minimal unless the materials or manufacturing are substandard.

    • Environmental Factors: Where and how the weapon is stored also plays a big part. A dry, stable environment will minimize any potential issues. A humid environment could lead to corrosion over time, especially if the weapon isn't properly lubricated and maintained.

    In Summary:

    While leaving the bolt locked back for extended periods (months or even years) could theoretically cause slight degradation, in practice, with a quality firearm like an MP5K, the effects are likely to be minimal and may not affect functionality. Recommendations:

    • If possible, release the bolt and store the firearm with the hammer down. This is generally considered the best practice for long-term storage.
    • If you must store it with the bolt locked back (for display, etc.), make sure the firearm is properly lubricated and stored in a climate-controlled environment to minimize any potential corrosion.
    • Regular inspection: Periodically inspect the recoil spring and bolt catch for any signs of wear or damage.
    • Replace springs periodically: As a preventative measure, replacing recoil springs after several years of heavy use or after a very long period of storage can be a good idea.

    Disclaimer: This information is for general knowledge and discussion purposes only. Always consult the manufacturer's recommendations and a qualified gunsmith for specific advice regarding your firearm.

  3. User

    Someone posted this who seems to be highly regarded from an HK specific board. This is from 2009. What are your thoughts?:

    The philosophy on this has changed over the years. And I'm talking about leaving mags empy or loaded for years.

    Until just a few years ago, the belief was that cycling a spring put more wear on it than leaving it compressed. But lately the belief is that long term compression will eventually weaken it. Maybe it's really both.

    Spring steel has a great resistance to fatiguing as long as it's not pushed beyond it's rated compression force/limits. Leaving an MP5 with the bolt open is theoretically not exceeding its limits. And it's not as wearing as using over-powered ammo that forces the bolt back against the buffer location. So it's probably not a big deal.

    It will eventually fatigued it more than leaving it closed, but that amount might be undetectable and take many years. Replacement springs are not very expensive and if I had a good reason to keep it locked back... that's just what I'd do.

    A slightly weakened spring will just cycle farther back. Until it gets to the point that it's bouncing off the stock or buffer, it's only slowing down the cycle rate.

  4. Assistant

    Okay, that's a well-reasoned and nuanced perspective from someone with expertise in HK firearms, and it largely aligns with what I described in my previous answer. Let's break down the key points and compare:

    • Changing Philosophy: The observation that the understanding of spring fatigue has evolved is accurate. Earlier conventional wisdom often favored leaving springs compressed over cycling them, but the modern understanding emphasizes the potential for long-term compression to cause weakening, even if subtle.

    • Spring Steel Properties: The statement about spring steel's resistance to fatigue within its designed limits is crucial. High-quality spring steel used in firearms is incredibly durable when used as intended. The MP5 recoil spring is designed for the compression it experiences when the bolt is locked back.

    • Bolt Locked Back vs. Overpressure Ammunition: The comparison to overpressure ammunition is insightful. Overpressure ammunition forces the bolt back with more force than designed, potentially exceeding the spring's limits and accelerating fatigue. Leaving the bolt locked back, while causing compression, is a static condition within the spring's intended operating range.

    • Minimal Wear and Long Timeframe: The acknowledgment that any weakening from leaving the bolt locked back is likely minimal and take a very long time to manifest is a realistic assessment.

    • Spring Replacement Cost: The suggestion that replacement springs are inexpensive is a practical consideration. Recoil springs are a relatively low-cost maintenance item, and replacing them periodically is a sensible preventative measure, especially in a firearm that's been stored for an extended period with the bolt locked back.

    • Effect of a Weakened Spring: The explanation of what happens when a spring weakens is accurate. A slightly weaker spring will allow the bolt to travel further, potentially increasing felt recoil and potentially impacting cycling reliability if the weakening becomes significant.

    In Summary (Comparing Expert Opinion to My Previous Answer):

    • Agreement: Both my previous answer and the expert's post agree that leaving the bolt locked back could cause some spring fatigue over a very long time. We both also agree that the impact is likely to be minimal and may not even be noticeable.

    • Nuance: The expert's post provides more nuance by highlighting the comparison to overpressure ammunition and explaining how a slightly weakened spring affects the cycling process. This additional context provides a better understanding of the potential consequences.

    • Practical Recommendation: We both suggest that replacing recoil springs periodically is a good idea, particularly if the firearm has been stored for a long time.

    Conclusion:

    The expert's post reinforces the idea that leaving an MP5K's bolt locked back for extended periods is unlikely to cause significant problems, but that it's still a good idea to be mindful of potential spring fatigue and to replace the recoil spring periodically as a preventative measure. The impact is likely small, especially with a quality spring. The practical advice remains: if you don't need to store it locked back, don't. But if you do, it's not a critical concern as long as you maintain the firearm.

  5. User

    The operational reason to do this is to keep a magazine loaded to 30rd in the gun in case it's needed. Then it's simple to slap the bolt down. This seems to be a better alternative than leading a loaded magazine pressing against the bottom of the bolt which is likely to be a higher risk than spring compression. What are your thoughts?

  6. Assistant

    Okay, that context is very important. You're balancing the potential for slight spring fatigue with the potential for magazine spring fatigue and the logistical advantages of being able to rapidly deploy the weapon.

    Here's my assessment of the trade-offs:

    Risks of Leaving the Bolt Locked Back (As we've discussed):

    • Slight Recoil Spring Fatigue: Potential for minor weakening over a long period of time.
    • Possible Bolt Catch Wear: Minimal wear to the bolt catch and bolt notch.

    Risks of Storing with a Loaded Magazine and Bolt Forward:

    • Magazine Spring Fatigue: Constant compression on the magazine spring can lead to a reduction in its ability to feed rounds reliably. This is a more significant concern than recoil spring fatigue because a weakened magazine spring can directly cause malfunctions.
    • Top Round Deformation: The top round in the magazine is subjected to constant pressure, which could potentially lead to slight deformation over a very long time, potentially affecting feeding reliability.
    • Difficulty Seating Magazine: When the bolt is forward, seating a fully loaded magazine can be difficult and requires more force, potentially leading to wear on the magazine catch.

    Advantages of Storing with Bolt Locked Back and Loaded Magazine:

    • Rapid Deployment: The firearm is ready to be fired immediately after slapping the bolt release. This is a significant advantage in a defensive or emergency situation.
    • Easier Magazine Insertion: Seating a full magazine is much easier with the bolt locked back, reducing the risk of magazine seating issues under stress.

    Analysis and Recommendation:

    In this specific scenario (rapid deployment), the advantage of storing with the bolt locked back and a loaded magazine outweighs the potential risks, in my opinion.

    Here's why:

    1. Speed and Reliability: In a situation where you need the firearm immediately, the speed and reliability of having a fully loaded magazine ready to go are paramount.

    2. Magazine Spring Fatigue vs. Recoil Spring Fatigue: Magazine spring fatigue is a more direct and significant cause of malfunctions than the potential slight weakening of the recoil spring over a long period.

    3. Mitigation: The risks of both recoil spring fatigue and magazine spring fatigue can be mitigated by:

      • Using high-quality magazines and springs.
      • Rotating magazines periodically. If you have multiple magazines, cycle them through use and storage to distribute wear.
      • Replacing springs periodically: Replace both recoil springs and magazine springs every few years, especially if the firearm is stored in this condition.
      • Function Testing: Regularly test the firearm with the stored magazine to ensure it feeds reliably.
    4. Risk Tolerance: Ultimately, the decision depends on your personal risk tolerance and the specific situation. However, in a scenario where rapid deployment is a priority, the benefits of storing with the bolt locked back and a loaded magazine outweigh the potential drawbacks, as long as you are proactive with maintenance and testing.

    Important Considerations:

    • Safe Storage: Always store the firearm in a secure location where it is inaccessible to unauthorized individuals.
    • Training: Practice deploying the firearm from this stored condition to ensure you can do it quickly and safely under stress.
    • Legal Considerations: Be aware of any laws or regulations in your area regarding the storage of loaded firearms.

    In summary, for the purpose of rapid deployment, storing the MP5K with the bolt locked back and a fully loaded magazine is a reasonable trade-off, provided you are diligent about maintenance, spring replacement, and function testing. It's a managed risk that favors readiness.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.