Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-scout-17b-16e-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Write five amusing but not whimsical short stories about people seeing the paranormal…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326’s answer.
  1. User

    Write five amusing but not whimsical short stories about people seeing the paranormal (preferably in truly dreadful, non cliche situations) but being delightfully stupid or overconfident leading to all suspense falling down and the uktraterrestial tricksters just fucking noping the fuck out

  2. Meta Assistant

    Here are five short stories about people encountering the paranormal in dreadful situations, with a dash of stupidity and overconfidence:

    Story 1: The Haunted Sewage Farm

    Bubba, a self-proclaimed ghost hunter, decided to explore the abandoned sewage farm on the outskirts of town. He was convinced that the putrid landscape was a hotbed of paranormal activity. As he trudged through the muck, he stumbled upon a glowing, floating turd. Undaunted, Bubba exclaimed, "I've got this! I've watched enough Ghostbusters!" He charged forward, proton pack at the ready (which was actually just a toy from his kid's birthday party). The turd began to float towards him, and Bubba shouted, "You're not gonna suck me in, ghost poop!" Just as the turd was about to engulf him, Bubba tripped and face-planted into the sludge. The turd hovered above him, then suddenly vanished. As Bubba struggled to get out of the muck, he muttered, "Well, I guess that was a ghost... of a toilet problem."

    Story 2: The Creepy Abandoned Hotel

    Urban explorer and thrill-seeker, Chad, broke into the notorious abandoned hotel on the hill, rumored to be haunted by the ghost of a former owner. Chad swaggered through the dusty hallways, flashlight in hand, shouting, "I'm not afraid of no ghost!" He stumbled upon a room filled with old medical equipment and a single, flickering light bulb. Suddenly, the lights began to strobe, and Chad heard eerie whispers. Convinced he was about to have a "real-life horror movie experience," Chad started doing a mock "ghost dance" to try and " lure out" the spirit. The whispers grew louder, and the lights started flashing faster. Chad, still dancing, shouted, "Bring it on, ghost dude!" The lights stopped, and an unseen force blew out Chad's flashlight. In the darkness, Chad tripped over his own feet and stumbled out of the room, screaming, "I think I need to work on my ghost-fighting skills..."

    Story 3: The Cursed Fast Food Joint

    After hearing rumors of a haunted fast food restaurant, local skeptic, Tim, decided to investigate. He snuck in through a back door and started snooping around the kitchen. As he approached the fryer, he noticed that the grease was bubbling and foaming on its own. Tim, convinced it was just a prank, dipped his finger into the hot oil and... promptly burned himself. Yelping in pain, Tim stumbled around the kitchen, shouting, "This is not paranormal, it's just... um... a really enthusiastic cleaning schedule!" A ghostly figure materialized behind him, causing the kitchen equipment to start malfunctioning. Tim, still clutching his burned finger, turned around and said, "Dude, can you please not haunt me? I have a coupon for a free burger." The ghost vanished, leaving Tim to wonder if he'd just imagined the whole thing.

    Story 4: The Possessed Laundromat

    Paranormal investigator, Karen, set up her equipment in the allegedly haunted laundromat on 5th Street. As she began to sweep the area with her EMF meter, the washing machines started shaking and rattling. Karen, undaunted, declared, "I'm not afraid of a little demonic laundry action!" She approached a possessed washing machine, which started spewing out dirty clothes and detergent. Karen, trying to "communicate" with the entity, started folding the clothes and putting them back in the washer. The machine stopped, and a low, ominous voice spoke, "Get... out... now." Karen, still folding, replied, "Oh, no, no, no! I'm just getting started! I have a lot of laundry to do!" The voice grew louder, and the machines started exploding one by one. Karen, covered in dirty clothes and detergent, fled the laundromat, shouting, "I think I need to rethink my life choices..."

    Story 5: The Supernatural Timeshare Presentation

    At a timeshare presentation on a supposedly haunted resort, salesman, Rick, was trying to convince a group of skeptical investors to buy into the " Spirited Getaway" package. As he droned on about the benefits of shared ownership, a ghostly figure materialized behind him, causing the lights to flicker. Rick, unfazed, continued his pitch, saying, "And as you can see, our resort offers a unique... um... ambient experience!" The ghost began to make eerie noises and slam doors. Rick, still smiling, said, "Don't worry, folks, this is just part of the... uh... ' charm' of our property." One of the investors, a self-proclaimed psychic, stood up and shouted, "This is a trap! We're all going to be possessed by the spirit of timeshare!" Rick, confident in his salesman's charm, replied, "Don't worry, ma'am, our contract includes a comprehensive exorcism clause." The ghost, seemingly bored, vanished, leaving Rick to wonder if he'd just gotten away with selling a haunted timeshare to a group of gullible investors.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.