Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmistral-medium-2505· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I'm setting an arbitrage trade. Basically I can buy google winning ai contest at 78 or…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon.nova-pro-v1:0’s answer.
  1. User

    I'm setting an arbitrage trade. Basically I can buy google winning ai contest at 78 or 79 cents (effectively probabilities). I can buy no google on a different market at 10 or 11 cents (effectively selling yes at 89 or 90). I'm seeing this as a risk free arbitrage trade, and wondering what the payouts will be? How much do I make?

  2. Mistral Assistant

    To determine the potential profit from your arbitrage trade, let's break down the scenario step by step.

    Understanding the Positions:

    1. Buying "Google wins AI contest" at 78 or 79 cents:

      • This means you are buying a "Yes" share at a price of 0.78or0.78 or 0.79.
      • If Google wins, this share will pay out $1.00.
      • If Google does not win, this share will pay out $0.00.
    2. Selling "Google wins AI contest" at 89 or 90 cents (by buying "No" at 10 or 11 cents):

      • Buying a "No" share at 0.10or0.10 or 0.11 is equivalent to selling a "Yes" share at 0.90or0.90 or 0.89.
      • If Google does not win, this "No" share will pay out $1.00.
      • If Google wins, this "No" share will pay out $0.00.

    Arbitrage Strategy:

    You can lock in a risk-free profit by simultaneously buying the "Yes" share at the lower price and selling the "Yes" share at the higher price. Here's how:

    1. Buy "Yes" at $0.79 (worst-case scenario for buying).
    2. **Sell "Yes" at 0.89∗∗(worst−casescenarioforselling,sincesellingat0.89** (worst-case scenario for selling, since selling at 0.90 is better but we'll use $0.89 for conservatism).

    Profit Calculation:

    • Initial Outlay:

      • Buy "Yes" at $0.79.
      • Sell "Yes" at 0.89(whichmeansyoureceive0.89 (which means you receive 0.89 for selling the "Yes" share).
      • Net initial cash flow: 0.89(received)−0.89 (received) - 0.79 (paid) = $0.10 profit per share.
    • Outcomes:

      • If Google wins:
        • Your bought "Yes" share pays $1.00.
        • Your sold "Yes" share means you owe 1.00(sincethebuyerofyour"Yes"sharegets1.00 (since the buyer of your "Yes" share gets 1.00).
        • Net payout: 1.00(received)−1.00 (received) - 1.00 (paid) = $0.00.
        • Total profit: Initial $0.10 (since no additional payout).
      • If Google does not win:
        • Your bought "Yes" share pays $0.00.
        • Your sold "Yes" share means you owe 0.00(sincethebuyerofyour"Yes"sharegets0.00 (since the buyer of your "Yes" share gets 0.00).
        • Net payout: 0.00−0.00 - 0.00 = $0.00.
        • Total profit: Initial $0.10 (since no additional payout).

    Conclusion:

    In both scenarios (Google wins or does not win), you lock in a profit of $0.10 per share (or 10 cents per share) from the initial arbitrage setup. This is because you are buying low and selling high on the same outcome, ensuring a risk-free profit.

    Example with 1 Share:

    • Buy "Yes" at $0.79.
    • Sell "Yes" at $0.89.
    • Net profit: $0.10.

    Scaling Up:

    If you execute this trade with more shares, your profit scales linearly. For example:

    • 100 shares: $10.00 profit.
    • 1,000 shares: $100.00 profit.

    Notes:

    • Ensure that the markets you are trading on allow you to hold both positions simultaneously (some markets may have restrictions).
    • Transaction fees or other costs could eat into your profit, so account for those if they apply.
    • The actual prices you can execute at may vary slightly due to liquidity or order book depth, so the 0.10profitisaconservativeestimatebasedonthegivenprices.Ifyoucanbuyat0.10 profit is a conservative estimate based on the given prices. If you can buy at 0.78 and sell at 0.90,yourprofitwouldbe0.90, your profit would be 0.12 per share.
  3. User

    Run it again. What is the percentage made

  4. Mistral Assistant

    To calculate the percentage return on your arbitrage trade, we need to consider the initial capital invested and the profit earned.

    Arbitrage Setup Recap:

    1. Buy "Google wins" (Yes) at $0.79 (worst-case buy price).
    2. **Sell "Google wins" (Yes) at 0.89∗∗(worst−casesellprice,equivalenttobuying"No"at0.89** (worst-case sell price, equivalent to buying "No" at 0.11).

    Profit Calculation:

    • Net profit per share = Sell price - Buy price = 0.89−0.89 - 0.79 = $0.10.
    • Initial capital invested = You only need to put up the **0.79∗∗tobuythe"Yes"share(sincethe0.79** to buy the "Yes" share (since the 0.89 from selling is received immediately).

    Percentage Return:

    The return is calculated based on the capital at risk, which is the $0.79 you spent to buy the "Yes" share.

    [ \text{Percentage Return} = \left( \frac{\text{Profit}}{\text{Initial Investment}} \right) \times 100 = \left( \frac{0.10}{0.79} \right) \times 100 \approx 12.66% ]

    Alternative Interpretation (If Using Both Legs):

    If you consider the net cash flow (where you receive 0.89fromsellingbutpay0.89 from selling but pay 0.79 to buy), your net investment is $0.00 (since you receive more than you spend).

    However, in arbitrage, the true capital at risk is the lower of the two prices (since you must hold the long position until settlement). Thus, the $0.79 is the correct base for calculating the return.

    Best-Case Scenario (If Prices Are Better):

    • If you buy at 0.78∗∗and∗∗sellat0.78** and **sell at 0.90, your profit is $0.12 per share.
    • Percentage return = (0.12/0.12 / 0.78) × 100 ≈ 15.38%.

    Conclusion:

    • Worst-case return (buy at 0.79,sellat0.79, sell at 0.89): ~12.66%.
    • Best-case return (buy at 0.78,sellat0.78, sell at 0.90): ~15.38%.

    This is a risk-free return because the arbitrage locks in the profit regardless of the outcome. The exact percentage depends on the execution prices, but it's a very strong return for a short-term, no-risk trade.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.