Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Is irc chats still useful today? Don't there are more secure ways of communication?…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-sonnet-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    Is irc chats still useful today? Don't there are more secure ways of communication? Isn't irc vulnerable in today's modern web?

  2. Qwen Assistant

    Great questions! Internet Relay Chat (IRC) is one of the oldest real-time communication systems still in use today. While it's not as mainstream as it once was, it still has relevance and utility in certain contexts. Let’s break down your concerns:


    1. Is IRC Still Useful Today?

    Yes — but with a niche audience.
    Despite being over 40 years old, IRC remains useful in specific communities and use cases:

    • Open-source development: Many Linux distributions and open-source projects still maintain active IRC channels for developer discussions.
    • Technical users and hobbyists: People who value simplicity, low bandwidth usage, and scriptability often prefer IRC.
    • Bots and automation: IRC supports bots well, making it ideal for automated notifications or integrations.
    • Privacy-focused individuals: Some people appreciate that many IRC networks don’t require personal information to join.

    However, for general consumer use, modern chat platforms like Discord, Slack, WhatsApp, and Signal have largely replaced IRC due to their richer features and better user experience.


    2. Aren't There More Secure Ways of Communication?

    This is a nuanced question. Here's how IRC stacks up security-wise:

    ✅ Pros:

    • Plain-text protocol: Makes it easy to audit and understand.
    • Supports encryption via TLS/SSL: Most modern IRC clients and servers support secure connections.
    • End-to-end encryption (with extensions): Tools like OMEMO or plugins can add E2EE to IRC-like communication.
    • Self-hosting options: You can run your own server and control security policies.

    ❌ Cons:

    • Not end-to-end encrypted by default: Without additional tools, messages are only encrypted between client and server, not from sender to recipient.
    • Lack of built-in authentication: User identity verification is limited unless using services like NickServ.
    • Older implementations may have vulnerabilities: Some legacy IRC servers or clients may not be maintained securely.

    So while there are more secure protocols today (e.g., Signal Protocol, Matrix with Olm), IRC can be made secure, especially when configured properly and used with modern clients and extensions.


    3. Isn't IRC Vulnerable in Today's Modern Web?

    It can be — but vulnerability depends on how it's used.

    ⚠️ Potential Vulnerabilities:

    • DDoS attacks on IRC servers: Centralized networks can be targets.
    • Lack of forward secrecy: Older logs can be compromised if keys are exposed.
    • Limited moderation tools: Compared to platforms like Discord or Slack, managing spam, trolls, or abuse can be harder.
    • No standard file/media sharing controls: Can lead to phishing or malware risks if users share links or files.

    ✅ Mitigations:

    • Use TLS/SSL for encrypted connections.
    • Join well-maintained networks with active moderation.
    • Run self-hosted or private channels to limit access.
    • Combine with tools like OTR (Off-the-Record Messaging) for private conversations.

    Alternatives to Consider (More Modern & Secure)

    If you're looking for something more secure and feature-rich than traditional IRC:

    PlatformFeaturesSecurity Highlights
    Matrix (via Element)Decentralized, bridging with IRC, rich mediaEnd-to-end encryption, open source
    SignalPrivate messaging, voice/videoStrong E2EE, minimal metadata
    DiscordVoice, video, screen sharingModeration tools, TLS encryption
    XMPP with OMEMODecentralized IMModular, supports E2EE
    ToxPeer-to-peer, no serversFully decentralized, E2EE by default

    Conclusion

    • Is IRC still useful? Yes, especially in technical and privacy-conscious circles.
    • Are there more secure options? Definitely — many modern protocols offer stronger default encryption and better UX.
    • Is IRC vulnerable? It can be, but so can any system if misconfigured. With proper setup, it can still be reasonably secure.

    If you're looking for a balance between IRC's simplicity and modern security, consider Matrix or XMPP with E2EE, which combine decentralization with strong encryption.

    Let me know if you'd like recommendations for secure, IRC-like alternatives!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.