Hey, please evaluate idea and answer on some questions. Idea: I want make few datasets…
- User
Hey, please evaluate idea and answer on some questions. Idea: I want make few datasets from simplest one to hardest one for tracking 'how my gnn is learning', e.g. on simplest dataset it gives me 98% occurancy and learns for 1 epoch, more complex dataset I expect some changes. So I want write gnn step by step and if gnn stucks at some dataset it s easier to understand what to change. Question 1: what s better - learn dataset1, test, learn dataset2, test or learn dataset1, test, drop knowledge, learn dataset1+2, test ? Question 2: I have .yaml config for pre_training, better to have other .yaml where I setup sequence for datasets or use same ( in current one I have datasets field with path to dataset ) ?
- Assistant
Below is some guidance on both questions based on curriculum learning and configuration management principles:
Question 1: How to Sequence Training?
You have two options:
-
Sequential Training (Dataset 1; Test; then Dataset 2; Test):
- Pros:
- You can see how well the model learns on each progressively difficult dataset by switching tasks.
- This setup helps pinpoint exactly when the model starts struggling as the difficulty changes.
- Cons:
- If you completely switch to the next dataset, you might risk catastrophic forgetting of what was learned on the simpler dataset.
- Pros:
-
Cumulative Training (Train on Dataset 1; Test; then continue training on the combined Dataset 1+2; Test):
- Pros:
- The model progressively builds on its previous knowledge—this is in line with curriculum learning, where early "simple" tasks ease the learning of later more difficult tasks.
- The model retains the initial representations that were successfully learned on the simple data, which can act as a good inductive bias.
- Cons:
- If the simpler dataset represents only a subset of the true data variability, the combined dataset might unbalance training or require careful tuning of learning rates/epochs.
- Pros:
Recommendation:
For curriculum learning, the typical strategy is to train on the simplest data first and then gradually add harder data while retaining the learned knowledge. In other words, you would train on Dataset 1, test it, then continue training on the combined Dataset 1+2 (instead of dropping previous learning). This lets you see incremental improvements while still leveraging what the model learned first. Monitoring performance on both the simple and the complex cases can also help identify if and where forgetting happens.
Question 2: YAML Configuration for Dataset Sequencing
You mentioned that you currently have a YAML config file for pre-training, which includes a field for the dataset paths. Consider the following options:
-
Single YAML with an Extended Datasets Sequence:
- Pros:
- All training parameters (hyperparameters, dataset paths, curriculum stages, etc.) are in one place, which can simplify management for small projects.
- You can add new keys (e.g.,
dataset_sequence,curriculum_stages) that describe the order and details of each dataset.
- Cons:
- As the configuration grows in complexity (for instance, if the curriculum has many stages or requires different hyperparameters per stage), a single file can become cluttered and harder to maintain.
- Pros:
-
Separate YAML for Curriculum Sequencing:
- Pros:
- Separating curriculum structure from generic pre-training settings offers better modularity and clarity.
- This approach makes it easier to experiment with different curriculum orders without changing the core training configuration.
- Cons:
- It adds an extra file and possibly an extra layer of configuration management. You’ll need to combine or reference these configurations in your training code.
- Pros:
Recommendation:
If your curriculum sequencing is simple (for example, you have one or two extra parameters like which dataset to load at each step), you could extend your existing YAML config file. However, if you envision this part of your pipeline evolving into a more complex curriculum logic (with multiple stage definitions, specific hyperparameters per stage, etc.), then separating the curriculum configuration into its own YAML file might be the cleaner and more scalable solution.
Summary
-
For the Training Sequence:
It’s generally better not to drop the knowledge gained from the simple dataset; instead, start with Dataset 1, test, and then continue training on the combined datasets. This approach builds on the earlier learning and aligns with curriculum learning practices. -
For the YAML Config:
If your project is simple, extend your current YAML file with fields for the dataset sequence. For a more complex or evolving curriculum, consider managing curriculum specifics in a dedicated YAML configuration file.
Both approaches are valid—the best choice depends on the complexity of your experiments and how much you expect your curriculum or pre-training configurations to diverge over time.
-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.