I have water in a Pipe W1 It it warmed from the outside, it passes through an Exchange…
- User
I have water in a Pipe W1 It it warmed from the outside, it passes through an Exchange point E1 And then returns outside to be warmed again.
I have FRESH air in Pipe A1 It comes from outside. It mixes with the water at the exchange point E1. It then travels though a radiator in the ROOM. And then it travels outside again, it is not recirculated
If the room is initially at the Outside temperature. Would the radiator cool the room, heat the room, or neither?
Please take into account latent heat transfer via evaporation.
- Assistant
Here’s the bottom line:
• If you really just run water and outside‐air (both at the same ambient temperature T₀) through an adiabatic “mixing” exchanger (E1) and then dump that mixture into a room that’s also sitting at T₀, there is no source of extra sensible heat to raise the room above T₀. In other words, if you do only sensible (temperature) exchange between two streams that start at the same T, nothing happens → neither heating nor cooling.
• HOWEVER, the moment you allow liquid water to evaporate into the air at E1, you invoke latent‐heat transfer. Evaporation removes heat from the gas+liquid stream (the enthalpy of vaporization is drawn out of the mixture), so the air–water mixture leaving E1 will be colder than T₀ (down toward the wet‐bulb temperature). When that sub-T₀ stream hits your room at T₀, it pulls sensible heat out of the room air → you get net cooling.
—
1) Pure sensible exchange (no phase change)
Tin,air = Tin,water = T₀
Heat balance at E1:
ṁair·cₚ,air·(Tout–T₀) + ṁw·cₚ,w·(Tout–T₀) = 0
⇒ Tout = T₀
⇒ No temperature difference → neither heating nor cooling.2) Adiabatic humidification (liquid → vapor)
Let ṁair = 1 kg/s, ṁw(evap) = Δṁw kg/s evaporated.
Enthalpy balance (dropping subscripts):
ṁair·h_air(T₀,φ₀) + Δṁw·h_lw(T₀)
= (ṁair + Δṁw)·h_vaporous(Tout,100%RH)Because h_vapor ≈ h_liquid + L_v, the only way to satisfy this is for Tout < T₀. In fact, Tout approaches the wet-bulb temperature T_wb(T₀,φ₀).
Numerical example (20 °C, 50 % RH):
T₀ = 20 °C, φ₀ = 0.50 ⇒ T_wb ≃ 14 °C.
If you evaporate enough water to saturate the air, the mixed stream cools to about 14 °C. Send that into a room at 20 °C and it cools the room.—
Conclusion
• With no evaporation: neither heating nor cooling.
• As soon as you allow evaporation at E1: your “radiator” becomes an evaporative cooler and will cool the room (down toward the wet-bulb).Feel free to play with the mass‐flow ratio air∶water and the outside humidity – that will set exactly how far below ambient you can drive the leaving‐E1 temperature, and therefore how much cooling you get in the room. 😊
- User
Is it possible to figure out the formulas for this?
- Assistant
Below is a sketch of how you set up the mass‐ and energy‐balances around your “exchange” E₁ and then solve for the outlet temperature (and water‐evaporation rate). We’ll denote
• ṁₐ = dry‐air mass flow (kg/s)
• ṁw,in = liquid‐water mass flow into E₁ (kg/s)
• ṁw,ev = portion of that water which evaporates (kg/s)
• Tₐ,in = inlet‐air temperature = T₀
• T𝚠,in = inlet‐water temperature = T₀
• Tₒᵤₜ = common outlet temperature of both the moist air and the remaining liquid water
• cₚ,ₐ ≃ 1.0 kJ/kg·K (specific heat of air)
• cₚ,𝚠 ≃ 4.18 kJ/kg·K (specific heat of liquid water)
• Lᵥ ≃ 2 500 kJ/kg (latent heat of vaporization)
1) Mass balances
- Dry air
ṁₐ,in = ṁₐ,out (no air is created or destroyed)
- Water
ṁw,in = ṁw,liquid,out + ṁw,ev
- Vapor in the outgoing gas stream
ṁ_vapor,out = ṁw,ev
so the total mass of the exiting moist‐air stream is
ṁₐ,moist,out = ṁₐ + ṁw,ev
2) Energy balance across E₁
Total enthalpy in = total enthalpy out
Inlet enthalpy
Ḣ_in = ṁₐ·(cₚ,ₐ Tₐ,in) + ṁw,in·(cₚ,𝚠 T𝚠,in)Outlet enthalpy
• The moist air (dry air + vapor) leaves at Tₒᵤₜ and carries the vapor enthalpy.
• The remaining liquid water also leaves at Tₒᵤₜ.Ḣ_out =
ṁₐ·[cₚ,ₐ Tₒᵤₜ + (ṁw,ev/ṁₐ)·(Lᵥ + cₚ,𝚠 Tₒᵤₜ)]
+ (ṁw,in – ṁw,ev)·(cₚ,𝚠 Tₒᵤₜ)
3) Putting it together
Set Ḣ_in = Ḣ_out and solve for Tₒᵤₜ (and/or ṁw,ev). One convenient rearrangement is:
ṁₐ cₚ,ₐ Tₐ,in
- ṁw,in cₚ,𝚠 T𝚠,in
– ṁw,ev·Lᵥ
= Tₒᵤₜ·[ ṁₐ cₚ,ₐ + ṁw,in cₚ,𝚠 + ṁw,ev cₚ,𝚠 ]
⇓
Tₒᵤₜ =
[ ṁₐ cₚ,ₐ Tₐ,in + ṁw,in cₚ,𝚠 T𝚠,in – ṁw,ev Lᵥ ]
─────────────────────────────────────────────
( ṁₐ cₚ,ₐ + ṁw,in cₚ,𝚠 + ṁw,ev cₚ,𝚠 )– if no evaporation ⇒ ṁw,ev = 0 ⇒ Tₒᵤₜ = T₀ ⇒ no sensible change (neither heating nor cooling).
– if evaporation occurs, the –ṁw,ev·Lᵥ term drives Tₒᵤₜ below T₀. In the limit of full saturation the outlet temperature actually equals the wet‐bulb of the incoming air.
4) Finding the evaporation rate
You can also solve for ṁw,ev by imposing that the outgoing humid air is at saturated humidity at Tₒᵤₜ. Let w₁ = inlet humidity ratio (kg_vapor/kg_dry_air) and w₂ = saturation at Tₒᵤₜ. Then
ṁw,ev = ṁₐ (w₂ – w₁).
Plugging that into the energy balance closes the system and lets you solve numerically for Tₒᵤₜ (and hence w₂ and ṁw,ev).
In practice
- Guess Tₒᵤₜ
- Compute w₂ = saturation-humidity(Tₒᵤₜ)
- Compute ṁw,ev = ṁₐ(w₂–w₁)
- Check the energy balance above; iterate on Tₒᵤₜ until it closes.
Once you have Tₒᵤₜ you know exactly how much sensible cooling you’ll deliver to the room and how much water must evaporate. 😊
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.