"I have 13 coins, one of them is fake. I also have a digital scale. How do I identify…
- User
"I have 13 coins, one of them is fake. I also have a digital scale. How do I identify the fake coin?"
- Assistant
To identify the fake coin among 13 coins using a digital scale, you can do it in just 1 weighing. Here's how:
How to Identify the Fake Coin in 1 Weighing with a Digital Scale:
Assumptions:
- You know the real coins all have the same weight.
- The fake coin has a different weight (either heavier or lighter).
- Coins are labeled (or can be assigned numbers) from 1 to 13.
Step-by-step Approach:
-
Label the coins from 1 to 13.
-
Weigh them together, but place a unique number of each coin on the scale, using their label number as a multiplier.
- For example: place coin 1 once, coin 2 twice, coin 3 three times, ..., coin 13 thirteen times.
- That’s not possible physically with discrete coins, so instead:
Better Method (Using Binary or Arithmetic Weighting):
Here's a proven approach using a digital scale and leveraging the ability to measure exact weight:
✅ Assign each coin a unique weight multiplier.
Assign values to coins:
- Coin 1: contributes 1 gram if real
- Coin 2: contributes 2 grams if real
- Coin 3: contributes 3 grams
- ...
- Coin 13: contributes 13 grams
So:
Put all 13 coins on the digital scale at once, and record the total weight.
Step 3: Determine Expected Total
Let’s say real coins weigh exactly x grams.
Then the expected total weight =
(1 + 2 + 3 + ... + 13) × x = (13 × 14) / 2 × x = 91xThat’s the total you should get if all coins are real.
Step 4: Analyze the Result
Suppose the scale shows a weight that's not 91x, but something else.
Let’s say it shows W grams. Then:
- The difference from 91x tells you:
- Which coin is fake
- Whether it's heavier or lighter
For example:
- Suppose all real coins weigh 10 grams, so 91x = 910 grams
- But the scale says 900 grams ⟶ a 10g difference
- Then the "fake" coin is the one whose position multiplied by 10 gives that difference: e.g., if coin 10 (10th coin) is actually 0g instead of 10g, that’s a 10g drop.
- You can use this logic (difference from expected) to find which coin is fake, and its weight deviation.
This works even if the fake coin is heavier — the difference will come out positive.
Final Notes:
- You only need one weighing because a digital scale gives you exact weight.
- You use a unique numeric encoding of each coin (like 1 to 13) — essentially encoding their identity by their expected contribution to total weight.
- This works because only one coin is fake, so there's only one deviation.
✅ Answer:
Assign values 1–13 to each coin, weigh them all together, and compare the total to what it should be if all coins are real. The difference reveals the fake coin and whether it’s heavier or lighter — in just one weighing.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.