Suppose Y is the binary ground truth of a question. X1, X2, X3 are three conditioned…
- User
Suppose Y is the binary ground truth of a question. X1, X2, X3 are three conditioned independent samples of Y with the same noise rate. Are X1 and X2 independent conditioned on X3?
Assistant
No, X1 and X2 are not independent conditioned on X3.
This is because X3 provides information about Y, but not perfect information. When we observe X3, we update our beliefs about the ground truth Y. However, since X3 is noisy, uncertainty about Y remains.
In this situation, knowing X1 gives us additional information about Y beyond what X3 tells us, which in turn affects our beliefs about X2. This creates a dependency between X1 and X2 even after conditioning on X3.
To verify this mathematically, we can check whether P(X1,X2|X3) = P(X1|X3)×P(X2|X3). Using Bayes' rule and the given conditional independence properties, we can show this equality doesn't hold in general for this setup.
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.