Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I have this flaky method in Playwright testing framework. It always fails to check the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-3.3-70b-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    I have this flaky method in Playwright testing framework. It always fails to check the absence of the device on the page and fails on this step: await this.buttons.delete.first().click({ timeout: 10_000 });

    I tried many checks: // while (await this.buttons.delete.count() > 0) { and while (await this.buttons.delete.first().isVisible()) { and await expect.poll(async () => await this.buttons.delete.count(), { intervals: [500, 200, 200], timeout: 1000 }).toBe(0).catch(() => { }); //waiting for the UI updated. Best effort But nothing seems work reliably. Please suggest the solution, maybe I miss something here. Don't use try/catch

    /**

    Deletes all devices listed on the Grid.
    @returns {Promise} - Resolves when all devices have been deleted.
    @description
    This method iteratively deletes all devices from the UI until none remain.
    */
    async deleteAllDevices() {
    await waitForPageLoad(this.page);
    while (await this.buttons.delete.first().isVisible()) {
    // while (await this.buttons.delete.count() > 0) {
    await waitForPageLoad(this.page);
    await this.buttons.delete.first().click({ timeout: 10_000 });
    await this.buttons.cancel.waitFor();
    const deviceName = (await this.getDeviceNameInDeleteConfirmationDialog().textContent()).trim();
    console.log(deleteAllDevices. Deleting device: ${deviceName});
    await this.buttons.confirmDelete.waitFor();
    await this.getDeviceNameConfirmInput().fill(deviceName);
    await this.buttons.confirmDelete.click();
    await waitForPageLoad(this.page);
    await expect.poll(async () => await this.buttons.delete.count(), { intervals: [500, 200, 200], timeout: 1000 }).toBe(0).catch(() => { }); //waiting for the UI updated. Best effort
    }
    }
    
  2. Assistant

    The flaky behavior you're experiencing when deleting devices and checking for their absence is a common challenge in UI automation, especially when dealing with dynamic content and asynchronous UI updates.

    Your current approach is close, but a few improvements can make it more reliable:


    Key issues & improvements:

    1. Avoid checking .isVisible() on a possibly stale element handle — after deletion, the DOM changes, so the handle might become detached.
    2. Use stable selectors and count checks instead of .first() element visibility.
    3. Wait explicitly for the UI to update after each deletion — not just waitForPageLoad(), but also wait for the delete button count to decrease.
    4. Use Playwright's expect.poll with a proper timeout and interval to wait for the count to decrease.
    5. Avoid very short timeouts on click — 10 seconds is fine, but ensure the element is ready before clicking.

    Suggested robust implementation:

    /**
     * Deletes all devices listed on the Grid.
     * @returns {Promise<void>} - Resolves when all devices have been deleted.
     */
    async deleteAllDevices() {
      await waitForPageLoad(this.page);
    
      // Poll until no delete buttons remain
      while (true) {
        // Get current count of delete buttons
        const deleteCount = await this.buttons.delete.count();
    
        if (deleteCount === 0) {
          // No devices left to delete
          break;
        }
    
        // Always get the first delete button fresh (avoid stale handles)
        const firstDeleteButton = this.buttons.delete.nth(0);
    
        // Wait for the button to be visible and enabled before clicking
        await expect(firstDeleteButton).toBeVisible({ timeout: 10_000 });
        await expect(firstDeleteButton).toBeEnabled({ timeout: 10_000 });
    
        // Click the delete button
        await firstDeleteButton.click();
    
        // Wait for the cancel button in the confirmation dialog to appear
        await this.buttons.cancel.waitFor({ state: 'visible', timeout: 10_000 });
    
        // Get the device name from the confirmation dialog
        const deviceName = (await this.getDeviceNameInDeleteConfirmationDialog().textContent())?.trim();
        console.log(`deleteAllDevices. Deleting device: ${deviceName}`);
    
        // Wait for confirm delete button to be visible and enabled
        await this.buttons.confirmDelete.waitFor({ state: 'visible', timeout: 10_000 });
        await expect(this.buttons.confirmDelete).toBeEnabled({ timeout: 10_000 });
    
        // Fill the confirmation input with the device name
        await this.getDeviceNameConfirmInput().fill(deviceName);
    
        // Click confirm delete
        await this.buttons.confirmDelete.click();
    
        // Wait for page or UI update after deletion
        await waitForPageLoad(this.page);
    
        // Wait until the number of delete buttons decreases by 1
        await expect.poll(
          async () => await this.buttons.delete.count(),
          {
            timeout: 10_000,
            intervals: 500,
          }
        ).toBeLessThan(deleteCount);
      }
    }
    

    Explanation:

    • Polling the count: Instead of relying on .isVisible() on a single element, we check the count of delete buttons fresh each iteration.
    • Fresh element handles: We get the first delete button fresh every time with .nth(0) to avoid stale element errors.
    • Waiting for visibility and enabled state: Before clicking buttons, we explicitly wait for them to be visible and enabled.
    • Waiting for UI update after deletion: After confirming deletion, we wait for the page load and then poll until the delete button count decreases.
    • No try/catch: We rely on Playwright's built-in waiting and polling mechanisms to handle timing issues.

    Additional tips:

    • If waitForPageLoad is not sufficient to detect UI updates, consider waiting for a specific network request or a UI element that signals the deletion is complete.
    • If the delete confirmation dialog sometimes appears slowly, increase the timeout on waitFor calls.
    • If the device name confirmation input or buttons sometimes take time to become enabled, add explicit waits or checks.

    This approach should make your deleteAllDevices method much more stable and less flaky. Let me know if you want me to help with a version that includes more detailed logging or screenshots on failure!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.