Skip to content
The Chat Archive
qwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen) LMArena Human Preference 140K

Shouldn't I put generated_vars.auto.tfvars into the artifacts or "manifests" folder too,…

  1. User

    Shouldn't I put generated_vars.auto.tfvars into the artifacts or "manifests" folder too, because it was generated?

  2. Assistant

    Yes, you're absolutely right to question this — and your intuition is spot-on.

    ✅ Short Answer: Yes, generated_vars.auto.tfvars should go in the manifests/ (or "artifacts") folder.


    🧠 Why?

    Because:

    • It's a generated file — not source code.
    • It's not version-controlled directly; it's derived from source (config_src/).
    • It's used as an input to Terraform, which is part of the deployment pipeline — like other generated manifests.
    • It aligns with the principle that only source files live in config_src/, and everything else (including generated config for tools like Terraform) lives under manifests/.

    🔁 Updated Structure Proposal

    Here’s how your structure would look after moving the .auto.tfvars file into the manifests/ directory:

    .
    ├── config_src/
    │   ├── common/
    │   └── clusters/
    │       ├── cluster-1/
    │       │   ├── app_definitions.kcl
    │       │   ├── cluster_definitions.kcl
    │       │   └── infra_variables.kcl  # KCL logic to generate Terraform inputs
    │       └── cluster-2/
    │
    ├── infrastructure/
    │   ├── modules/
    │   └── live/
    │       ├── cluster-1/
    │       │   ├── main.tf
    │       │   ├── backend.tf
    │       │   └── terraform.tfvars      # Static vars (optional)
    │       └── cluster-2/
    │
    ├── manifests/
    │   ├── cluster-1/
    │   │   ├── apps/
    │   │   ├── cluster-config/
    │   │   └── terraform/
    │   │       └── generated_vars.auto.tfvars  # Generated by KCL
    │   └── cluster-2/
    │
    └── scripts/
    

    💡 CI/CD Workflow Update

    This change affects your pipeline slightly:

    Stage 1: Generation

    1. Run KCL on config_src/clusters/cluster-1/infra_variables.kcl.
    2. Output is written to:
      manifests/cluster-1/terraform/generated_vars.auto.tfvars
    3. Also generate Kubernetes/Talos YAMLs into:
      manifests/cluster-1/apps/ and manifests/cluster-1/cluster-config/
    4. Commit or push all generated content (if needed).

    Stage 2A: Infrastructure Deployment

    1. Copy the generated .auto.tfvars file into the appropriate Terraform root module:
      cp manifests/cluster-1/terraform/generated_vars.auto.tfvars \
         infrastructure/live/cluster-1/
      
    2. Then run:
      cd infrastructure/live/cluster-1/
      terraform init && terraform apply
      

    🔁 You can also symlink the file during CI if you don't want to copy it, but copying is safer and more explicit.


    ✅ Benefits of This Change

    BenefitDescription
    Separation of concernsSource code vs generated artifacts are clearly separated.
    Cleaner GitOps storyEverything in manifests/ is deployable, including Terraform inputs.
    Safer state managementNo risk of accidentally committing .tfstate or .auto.tfvars files back into the repo unless explicitly desired.
    Better modularityYour infrastructure/live/ directories stay clean and generic. The actual values come from the generated artifacts.

    🚫 What Not to Do

    Avoid putting anything like .tfstate, .tfstate.backup, or even .auto.tfvars into your primary repo without good reason. These files should be treated like build artifacts or logs — ephemeral and environment-specific.

    If you do commit them, make sure:

    • They don’t contain secrets (use remote state instead).
    • They are isolated in a dedicated branch or repo (e.g., a "gitops" repo or a "terraform-state" repo).
    • You have protections against accidental merge conflicts.

    🏁 Summary

    Yes — move generated_vars.auto.tfvars into the manifests/ directory, alongside other generated output.

    This keeps your repository structure logically consistent:

    • config_src/: source templates (KCL)
    • manifests/: generated artifacts (YAML + Terraform input variables)
    • infrastructure/: executable IaC code (Terraform)

    Let me know if you'd like help writing the KCL → .auto.tfvars generation script or structuring your CI pipeline accordingly!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.