Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

on a 4k 55" TV, should I watch a 1080p REMUX or a 4K re-encode with 20-30Mbps of bitrate

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with MiniMaxminimax-m1’s answer.
  1. User

    on a 4k 55" TV, should I watch a 1080p REMUX or a 4K re-encode with 20-30Mbps of bitrate

  2. Assistant

    Short answer
    If the 4 K file is a good HEVC re-encode (≈20-30 Mb/s, 10-bit, HDR intact) and your TV handles HDR well, the 4 K will very probably look better overall, even on a 55″.
    If the 4 K was aggressively compressed, is only 8-bit SDR, or your TV’s HDR performance is weak, the 1080p REMUX will likely look cleaner.

    Below is the “why” so you can judge for yourself.


    1. What each file really contains
    1080p REMUX4 K re-encode (20-30 Mb/s)
    SourceDirect Blu-ray bitstream (lossless)UHD Blu-ray or WEBRip, but re-compressed
    Resolution / pixels1920 × 1080 (2 MP)3840 × 2160 (8 MP)
    Codec / bit-depthAVC / 8-bitHEVC / 10-bit (usually)
    Typical bitrate25-40 Mb/s20-30 Mb/s
    HDR / WCGSDR Rec-709Often HDR10 / Dolby Vision
    AudioFull lossless (DTS-HD MA / TrueHD)Usually lossy (DD+, AC-3, sometimes DTS)

    1. Factors that matter more than the headline numbers

    Resolution vs. compression
    • 4× the pixels means you also need ≈4× the bitrate to stay lossless.
    • UHD Blu-ray peaks at 128 Mb/s and averages 50-80 Mb/s. Your re-encode is 20-30 Mb/s → about 60 % smaller, so some detail is discarded.
    • A 1080p REMUX keeps every Blu-ray pixel.

    HDR & 10-bit color
    • Even if you sit too far away to resolve full 4 K detail, HDR’s wider luminance range and 10-bit precision can be immediately visible (no banding, brighter highlights, deeper shadows).
    • If the re-encode is SDR, this advantage disappears.

    Your TV’s scaler
    • A decent 2020-2024 4 K set with AI / neural upscaling can make 1080p look surprisingly sharp.
    • Cheap or older scalers soften edges; here the true 4 K raster wins.

    Viewing distance
    • 55″ at 6-7 ft (≈2 m): you can barely resolve 1080p vs. 4 K lines (≈30 ppd).
    • 55″ at 4-5 ft: 4 K becomes obvious.
    • Sit >8 ft away: differences fade fast.

    Compression artefacts
    • 20-30 Mb/s HEVC is usually good, but look for: banding in skies, smeared film grain, mosquito noise around titles.
    • 1080p REMUX will have zero added artefacts—just whatever was on the disc.

    Audio
    • If you own a surround setup, the lossless audio on the REMUX can be a big deal.


    1. Practical advice

    A/B test
    – Play the same dark scene and a bright detailed scene from each file. Pause on fine texture (grass, hair) and look for smearing.
    – Watch moving shots for macro-blocking.
    – Notice color banding in sunsets or night skies.

    Rule-of-thumb
    • Good HDR TV + close seating → pick the 4 K re-encode.
    • Mid-range / older TV, farther seating, or you’re picky about artefacts → stick with the 1080p REMUX.

    Storage / bandwidth considerations
    If you stream over Wi-Fi, 20-30 Mb/s is easier than 30-40 Mb/s AVC. If you’re archiving, REMUXes chew ~30-40 GB vs. 15-25 GB for many 4 K re-encodes.


    Bottom line

    On a modern 55″ 4 K HDR TV at normal couch distance, a well-done 4 K HEVC 20-30 Mb/s rip normally looks a bit better thanks to real 4 K detail, HDR, and 10-bit color—even though it’s not lossless.
    But if that encode was carelessly done, if your TV’s HDR isn’t impressive, or if you crave pristine images and lossless audio, the 1080p REMUX may give the cleaner experience.

    Try both for ten minutes; trust your eyes. Your own setup and viewing distance outweigh any internet rule of thumb.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.