Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-mini-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Please suggest new powerful, usefull and realistic SIMD instructions…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Qwenqwq-32b’s answer.
  1. User

    Please suggest new powerful, usefull and realistic SIMD instructions (permutations/bit-manipulation/others) that are not present in the main stream SIMD architectures AVX-512/NEON/SVE/RVV.

  2. Assistant

    Certainly! Here are some novel and practical SIMD instruction ideas focusing on permutations, bit-manipulation, and other useful operations that are not currently present in mainstream SIMD ISAs like AVX-512, NEON, SVE, or RISC-V Vector (RVV). These instructions aim to enhance performance and programmability in common and emerging workloads:


    1. Vectorized Bit-Field Extract and Deposit with Variable Widths

    • Description:
      Extract or deposit arbitrary bit fields from/to each lane, where the bit offset and width are specified per lane in vector registers.
    • Why useful:
      Current SIMD bitfield instructions (like BMI2's BEXTR/PDEP) are scalar or fixed-width. Vectorized variable-width bitfield ops enable efficient parsing/packing of compressed data formats, bitstreams, or network protocols in parallel.
    • Example:
      For each lane i, extract width[i] bits starting at bit offset[i] from src[i] and place them in dst[i].
    • Potential opcode: VBFEXTR.VV / VBFDEP.VV

    2. Cross-Lane Bit Permutation (Bit-Scatter/Gather Across Vector Lanes)

    • Description:
      Scatter or gather bits across lanes according to a vector mask or index, allowing arbitrary bit-level permutations spanning multiple lanes.
    • Why useful:
      Enables fine-grained bit rearrangement for cryptography, compression, and data encoding without scalarizing or multiple shuffle steps.
    • Example:
      Given a vector of bits, rearrange them so that bits from lane 0 go to lane 3, bits from lane 1 go to lane 0, etc., at the bit granularity.
    • Potential opcode: VBITSCATTER.VV / VBITGATHER.VV

    3. Vectorized Population Count with Early-Out

    • Description:
      Compute population count (popcount) per lane but stop counting once a threshold is reached, returning a saturated count or a flag.
    • Why useful:
      Useful in approximate algorithms, early-exit conditions in similarity search, or cryptographic checks where exact popcount is not always needed.
    • Example:
      For each lane, count bits set in src[i] but stop if count exceeds threshold[i].
    • Potential opcode: VPOPCNT_THRESH.VV

    4. Vectorized Bit-Reversal and Bit-Interleaving

    • Description:
      Reverse bits in each lane or interleave bits from two vectors at the bit level (e.g., Morton code generation).
    • Why useful:
      Bit-reversal is common in FFTs and signal processing; bit-interleaving is critical in spatial indexing and graphics.
    • Example:
      VBITREV.V reverses bits in each lane; VBITINTERLEAVE.VV interleaves bits from two vectors.
    • Potential opcode: VBITREV.V, VBITINTERLEAVE.VV

    5. Vectorized Variable-Stride Permutation

    • Description:
      Permute elements in a vector with a stride that varies per lane, allowing complex strided access patterns in a single instruction.
    • Why useful:
      Enables efficient implementation of gather/scatter with non-uniform strides, useful in signal processing, matrix transposition, and irregular data access.
    • Example:
      For lane i, load element at base + i * stride[i].
    • Potential opcode: VPERM_STRIDE.VV

    6. Vectorized Bitwise Majority and Minority

    • Description:
      Compute the bitwise majority (or minority) across multiple vectors per lane, i.e., for each bit position, output 1 if majority of inputs have 1.
    • Why useful:
      Useful in error correction, voting algorithms, and cryptographic masking.
    • Example:
      Given 3 vectors, output a vector where each bit is the majority bit of the corresponding bits in the inputs.
    • Potential opcode: VBITMAJ.VVV, VBITMIN.VVV

    7. Vectorized Leading/Trailing Zero Count with Masked Early Termination

    • Description:
      Count leading or trailing zeros per lane but stop counting once a mask bit is set or a limit is reached.
    • Why useful:
      Useful in parsing variable-length codes or compressed data where early termination is common.
    • Example:
      VLZCNT_MASK.VV counts leading zeros but stops if a mask bit is set.
    • Potential opcode: VLZCNT_MASK.VV, VTRZCNT_MASK.VV

    8. Vectorized Bitwise Rotate with Per-Lane Variable Amounts

    • Description:
      Rotate bits left or right in each lane by a variable amount specified in another vector register.
    • Why useful:
      Bit rotations are common in cryptography and hashing; variable rotations per lane enable more flexible algorithms.
    • Example:
      VROTL.VV rotates bits left by rot[i] in lane i.
    • Potential opcode: VROTL.VV, VROTR.VV

    9. Vectorized Bit-Field Compression/Expansion

    • Description:
      Compress or expand bit fields from each lane into a contiguous bitstream or expand a bitstream into fields per lane.
    • Why useful:
      Useful for serialization, compression, and bitstream manipulation in parallel.
    • Example:
      VBITCOMPRESS.VV packs bits from lanes into a dense bitstream; VBITEXPAND.VV does the reverse.
    • Potential opcode: VBITCOMPRESS.VV, VBITEXPAND.VV

    10. Vectorized Permutation with Dynamic Index Generation

    • Description:
      Generate permutation indices on-the-fly based on arithmetic or bitwise operations on lane indices, then permute accordingly.
    • Why useful:
      Enables complex data rearrangements like butterfly patterns, matrix transposes, or cryptographic permutations without multiple instructions.
    • Example:
      VPERM_GEN.VV generates indices as (i XOR mask[i]) mod vector_length and permutes.
    • Potential opcode: VPERM_GEN.VV

    Summary Table

    Instruction IdeaCategoryUse Case Highlights
    Vectorized Bit-Field Extract/Deposit (variable width)Bit ManipulationParsing/packing compressed data
    Cross-Lane Bit Scatter/GatherBit PermutationCryptography, compression
    Vectorized Popcount with Early-OutBit ManipulationApproximate algorithms, early-exit conditions
    Bit-Reversal / Bit-InterleavingBit ManipulationFFTs, spatial indexing
    Variable-Stride PermutationPermutationIrregular data access, matrix operations
    Bitwise Majority/MinorityBit ManipulationError correction, voting algorithms
    Leading/Trailing Zero Count with MaskBit ManipulationVariable-length code parsing
    Bitwise Rotate (variable per lane)Bit ManipulationCryptography, hashing
    Bit-Field Compression/ExpansionBit ManipulationSerialization, compression
    Permutation with Dynamic Index GenerationPermutationComplex data rearrangements

    If you want, I can also provide pseudocode or microarchitectural hints for implementing any of these instructions efficiently. Would you like that?

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt