I'm using a custom loss function that optimizes for predicting the loss of the main…
- User
I'm using a custom loss function that optimizes for predicting the loss of the main prediction as well. Should the ".detach" be there?
class HuberLoss_conf(nn.Module): def __init__(self, conf_weight=1.0): super().__init__() self.Huber_no_reduce = nn.HuberLoss(reduction='none') self.conf_weight = conf_weight def forward(self, preds, conf, target): loss = self.Huber_no_reduce(preds, target) loss2 = self.conf_weight * self.Huber_no_reduce(conf, loss.detach()) combined_loss = loss + loss2 return torch.mean(combined_loss) Assistant
In your custom loss function, the
.detach()is indeed necessary and correctly placed. Here's why:-
Purpose of
.detach(): The.detach()operation creates a new tensor that shares the same data as the original tensor but doesn't require gradients. This is crucial in your case because: -
Avoiding Circular Dependencies: Your loss function has two components:
- The main prediction loss (
loss) - The confidence loss (
loss2) which tries to predict the main loss
- The main prediction loss (
Without
.detach(), you would create a circular dependency in the computation graph:- The main loss depends on the predictions
- The confidence loss depends on the main loss
- But the main loss would then also depend on the confidence predictions through the gradient flow
This circular dependency would make the optimization unstable and potentially lead to gradient explosion or other training issues.
-
What you want to achieve: You want the confidence predictions to learn to predict the main loss values, but you don't want the gradients from the confidence loss to propagate back through the main loss calculation. The
.detach()breaks this gradient flow while still using the actual loss values for the confidence prediction target. -
Alternative perspective: Think of the main loss values as "targets" for your confidence predictions. Just like you wouldn't want gradients to flow through your ground truth targets in a standard loss function, you don't want gradients to flow through these derived targets either.
So yes, the
.detach()should be there to maintain proper gradient flow and stable training. The current implementation is correct for what you're trying to achieve.-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.