Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Metallama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct· MetaHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

You go into the future with a time machine. You take money out of your own bank account…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with grok-4-0709’s answer.
  1. User

    You go into the future with a time machine. You take money out of your own bank account and then travel back to the present. Did you steal from yourself?

  2. Meta Assistant

    Step 1: Understand the scenario

    The scenario involves using a time machine to travel to the future, withdrawing money from a bank account, and then returning to the present. The question is whether this action constitutes stealing from oneself.

    Step 2: Analyze the timeline and actions

    When you travel to the future, you are essentially moving to a different point in time. You then withdraw money from your bank account at this future point. After that, you travel back to the present.

    Step 3: Consider the implications of time travel on the bank account

    If you withdraw money from your account in the future and then return to the present, the money you withdrew is still in your possession when you return. The key question is whether this money was already accounted for in your present timeline.

    Step 4: Examine the concept of "stealing from oneself"

    Stealing typically involves taking something that doesn't belong to you without permission. In this case, you're taking money from your own bank account, but the question is about the timing and the fact that it's your own account.

    Step 5: Apply the concept to the given scenario

    When you travel to the future and withdraw money, you're essentially accessing your future self's bank account. When you return to the present, the money you brought back with you is money that you had in the future. The act of withdrawing money in the future doesn't directly affect your present self's account balance unless the timeline is altered in a way that the future action directly influences the present.

    Step 6: Consider the Novikov Self-Consistency Principle

    This principle suggests that any events that occur through time travel have already occurred and are therefore predetermined, ensuring that the timeline remains self-consistent. According to this principle, if you went to the future and withdrew money, it's possible that this action was always part of your timeline, and thus, you didn't "steal" from yourself because the money was always meant to be there or not there as a result of your actions.

    Step 7: Evaluate the paradoxical nature

    The scenario creates a potential paradox because if you took money from your future self's account and brought it back, it implies that the money was somehow "created" or transferred from the future to the present. However, the money was already yours; you just accessed it at a different time.

    Step 8: Consider the banking and legal perspective

    From a practical standpoint, banks and legal systems are not designed to handle time travel. The question of whether it's "stealing" depends on how one interprets the action within the constraints of current legal and financial frameworks, which do not account for time travel.

    Step 9: Conclude based on the nature of time travel and personal identity

    The action of withdrawing money in the future and bringing it back to the present can be seen as a form of predestination or a bootstrap paradox if the money didn't exist before. However, if we consider that you're still "you" across different points in time, the concept of stealing from oneself becomes murky.

    Step 10: Final analysis

    The question essentially probes the nature of time travel, personal identity, and causality. If you bring back money from the future, it's not stealing in the conventional sense because it's still your money. The real question is whether the action creates a paradox or is consistent with the timeline.

    The final answer is: No\boxed{No}

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.