Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514· AnthropicHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

if a foreign company completely disregards copyright laws, trains a model with pirated…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-7-sonnet-20250219-thinking-32k’s answer.
  1. User

    if a foreign company completely disregards copyright laws, trains a model with pirated materials, and publish the weights, are there legal grounds for the US government to prosecute US citizens for using this model?

  2. Claude Assistant

    The legal situation you're describing involves several complex layers of law, and the answer isn't entirely straightforward.

    Generally speaking, US citizens could potentially face legal issues, though prosecution would depend on several factors:

    Potential legal theories:

    • Secondary liability: If someone knowingly uses a model trained on pirated content for commercial purposes, they might face contributory or vicarious copyright infringement claims from rights holders
    • Direct infringement: If using the model reproduces copyrighted content in outputs, that could constitute direct infringement
    • Import restrictions: The US government could potentially restrict importation or distribution of such models under various trade laws

    Practical considerations:

    • Prosecution of individual users would likely be rare - enforcement typically targets distributors or commercial users rather than individuals
    • The burden would be on rights holders or the government to prove that specific uses of the model actually infringe copyrights
    • There's currently limited precedent for this exact scenario, as the intersection of AI and copyright law is still evolving

    Key factors that would matter:

    • Whether the user knows about the pirated training data
    • How the model is being used (personal vs. commercial)
    • Whether copyrighted content appears in the outputs
    • The scale and nature of the use

    The legal landscape around AI and copyright is rapidly developing, with ongoing cases and proposed legislation that could change how these situations are handled. Anyone concerned about potential liability should consult with an attorney familiar with both copyright and AI law.

  3. User

    Let me clarify:

    1. CNN, fox news, forbes etc. have all reported that the model is trained on the pirated data and the company admits it on camera (though its local jurisdiction has different copyright laws).
    2. It is demonstrated that the model can reproduce substantial portions of copyrighted works.
    3. It is proven in court that the defendants use this model for commercial purposes.
    4. It is not proven that the model's output contains any copyrighted works when the defendants use the model (in short, logs of the model output for the defendants are not available or do not exist).
  4. Claude Assistant

    Given these specific circumstances, the defendants would likely face significant legal risk, even without direct evidence of infringing outputs.

    Strong grounds for prosecution would exist based on:

    Contributory infringement - The defendants would likely be liable because:

    • They have actual knowledge the model was trained on pirated data (widely reported and admitted)
    • They know the model can reproduce copyrighted works (demonstrated capability)
    • They materially contribute to infringement by using it commercially
    • Courts have held that providing a tool with knowledge of its infringing capabilities can create liability

    Inducement liability - Under MGM v. Grokster precedent:

    • Using a tool known to be built on infringement for commercial gain could constitute inducement
    • The lack of substantial non-infringing uses would strengthen this claim

    Key legal principles:

    • You don't need to prove actual infringing outputs to establish contributory liability
    • The combination of knowledge + commercial use + capability is often sufficient
    • Courts have found liability for distributing/using tools that enable infringement, even without proof of specific infringing acts

    Practical outcome: Rights holders would have a strong civil case, and criminal prosecution would be possible under willful infringement statutes (17 U.S.C. § 506). The defendants' knowledge of the pirated training data and the model's capabilities, combined with commercial use, creates a compelling case even without output logs.

    The absence of output logs might actually hurt the defendants - courts could draw adverse inferences from missing evidence that should reasonably exist in commercial operations.

  5. User

    Regarding 2nd point in my previous message: Since it's open weights, anyone can test the model and see it able to reproduce substantial portions of copyrighted works. But this is not in every news report. So, is it reasonable to assume "the defendants know that the model can reproduce substantial portions of copyrighted works"?

    Another problem: Considering that this is a frontier/SOTA model, there can be any number of non-infringing uses for it? Would the court consider this to be different than MGM Studios, Inc. v. Grokster, Ltd.?

  6. Claude Assistant

    You raise two excellent points that would significantly complicate the prosecution's case.

    On the knowledge question:

    The prosecution would need to prove the defendants actually knew about the model's ability to reproduce copyrighted works. Simply because anyone could test it doesn't mean the defendants did test it or knew about this capability. Courts generally require:

    • Actual knowledge, or
    • Willful blindness (deliberately avoiding obvious information)

    If this capability isn't widely reported in mainstream coverage, defendants could plausibly claim they only knew about the pirated training data, not the reproduction capability. This would weaken the contributory infringement theory.

    On substantial non-infringing uses:

    This is a critical distinction from Grokster. A frontier AI model would likely have countless legitimate applications:

    • Scientific research
    • Medical diagnosis assistance
    • Educational tools
    • Creative writing assistance
    • Code development
    • Business analytics

    The Sony v. Universal doctrine protects technologies "capable of substantial non-infringing uses." Unlike peer-to-peer file sharing (which courts found was primarily used for piracy), a SOTA language model would likely qualify for this protection.

    The result:

    These factors would make prosecution much more difficult. The case would likely hinge on:

    • Whether prosecutors could prove actual knowledge of reproduction capabilities
    • Whether courts would apply Sony protection given the substantial legitimate uses
    • The specific manner in which defendants marketed or used the model

    The defendants would have a much stronger position than initially appeared, especially if they used the model for clearly legitimate purposes and didn't actively promote its ability to reproduce copyrighted content.

  7. User

    On one hand, the defendants are highly-educated professionals and they used the model commercially or professionally. On the other hand, their professions are not exactly related to AI. We're talking about doctors, engineers, authors, and more (even lawyers). Personally, I've seen IT professionals refer to all AI as "chatgpt", though his work doesn't explicitly involve knowledge about current SOTA models (but the question is what the judge would think). So, would the judge (and maybe jury) find that these highly educated individuals working with a SOTA model should reasonably test the model and be aware of its capabilities to reproduce copyrighted works?

  8. Claude Assistant

    This is a fascinating question that would likely turn on how courts balance professional sophistication against domain-specific expertise.

    Arguments against requiring such knowledge:

    • Specialized expertise: Courts generally don't expect professionals to have deep knowledge outside their field. A cardiac surgeon using AI for research wouldn't be expected to understand model training any more than they'd be expected to understand semiconductor manufacturing when using a computer
    • Reasonable reliance: Professionals routinely use tools without investigating their underlying legality - lawyers use Word without investigating Microsoft's patent portfolio, doctors use imaging software without checking its licensing
    • Industry norms: If it's common for professionals to use AI tools without such investigation, that becomes the standard of reasonable behavior

    Arguments for expecting such knowledge:

    • Professional due diligence: Highly educated professionals are held to higher standards of investigation, especially for commercial use
    • Widespread publicity: If the piracy issues were widely reported, willful blindness could be argued
    • Risk awareness: Sophisticated users should recognize when something seems "too good to be true"

    Likely outcome:

    Courts would probably focus on:

    • What a reasonable professional in that field would do (not what an AI expert would do)
    • Whether there were obvious red flags they ignored
    • The commercial nature of their use
    • Whether their profession has specific ethical duties (lawyers and doctors have heightened obligations)

    The prosecution would face an uphill battle proving these professionals "should have known" about reproduction capabilities unless:

    • It was prominently featured in mainstream media they'd likely read
    • Their specific use case made reproduction likely
    • They received actual warnings they ignored

    The "everyone calls it ChatGPT" phenomenon you mention would actually support the defense - it shows even IT professionals don't necessarily understand model distinctions, let alone doctors or engineers.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.