Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
DeepSeekdeepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeekHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

The plan is to create a large narrative driven game using a self made engine with Vulkan…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-haiku-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    The plan is to create a large narrative driven game using a self made engine with Vulkan and C++

  2. DeepSeek Assistant

    Based on this plan alone, feasibility is extremely low (1/10). Here's why:

    1. Vulkan's Complexity: Vulkan is a low-level, explicit API. Building a stable, feature-complete engine (renderer, physics, audio, networking, asset pipeline, tools, etc.) requires immense expertise and time.
    2. "Large Narrative-Driven Game": This implies vast amounts of content (art, writing, voice acting, animation, level design, music) and complex systems (dialogue trees, branching narratives, quest logic, scripting). This is a massive production burden on top of engine development.
    3. The Engine Trap: Building the engine becomes the project. Performance optimization, platform support (PC, consoles?), bug fixing, and tool creation will consume years before significant game content is built.
    4. Resource Intensity: This plan requires a rare combination of deep C++/Vulkan expertise, game design skill, narrative design talent, and massive amounts of time/funding. It's typically the domain of large, experienced studios (and even they often use established engines).
    5. Scope Creep: Engine development naturally leads to scope creep as you chase the "perfect" feature set instead of shipping a game.

    Key Risks: Burnout, project abandonment, engine limitations hindering the game's vision, never finishing the game itself.

    Starting Rating: 1/10 (Highly Impractical)

    Let's see how technical achievements change this rating. Provide the first achievement!

  3. User

    The plan is to create a large narrative driven game using a self made engine with Vulkan and C++

  4. DeepSeek Assistant

    Based on your plan to create a large narrative-driven game using a self-made Vulkan/C++ engine, here's my initial feasibility assessment:

    Initial Feasibility Rating:

    1%
    (Extremely High Risk / Borderline Impossible for a Solo/Small Team)

    Key Challenges:

    1. Engine Complexity:
      • Vulkan is a low-level, explicit API requiring deep GPU/rendering expertise.
      • Core systems needed: Renderer, physics, audio, animation, asset pipeline, scripting, UI, etc.
    2. Scope of "Large Narrative Game":
      • Expect 100k+ lines of code for the engine alone.
      • Content creation (writing, art, sound, levels) for a "large" game often requires 10,000+ hours.
    3. Team/Time Constraints:
      • AAA studios with 100+ engineers take 3–5 years for such projects.
      • Solo development could easily exceed 10 years.
    4. Maintenance Overhead:
      • Debugging a custom engine is exponentially harder than using Unreal/Unity.

    Now, provide your first "technical achievement." I'll reassess feasibility after each one.

    (Example achievements: "Implemented Vulkan renderer with PBR," "Built a working scene editor," "Integrated Lua scripting," etc.)

    Current Progress:

    • 🔴 Engine: 0%
    • 🔴 Game: 0%
    • 🔴 Feasibility: 1%

    Waiting for your first achievement...

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.