Skip to content
The Chat Archive
qwen-max-2025-01-25· Alibaba (Qwen) LMArena Human Preference 140K

the meaning and usage of keepdim in pytorch

  1. User

    the meaning and usage of keepdim in pytorch

  2. Assistant

    In PyTorch, the keepdim argument is used in reduction operations like sum(), mean(), max(), min(), etc., to control whether the reduced dimensions are kept in the output tensor.

    What does keepdim mean?

    • When you perform a reduction operation (such as summing or averaging along a specific dimension), the default behavior is to remove that dimension from the result. This means that if you have a tensor of shape (3, 4) and you reduce along one dimension (e.g., sum over rows), the resulting tensor will lose that dimension and become a 1D tensor.

    • If you set keepdim=True, the reduced dimensions will be retained with size 1. This allows for easier broadcasting when performing further element-wise operations between tensors.

    Usage:

    The keepdim argument is commonly found in functions such as:

    • torch.sum(input, dim, keepdim=False)
    • torch.mean(input, dim, keepdim=False)
    • torch.max(input, dim, keepdim=False)
    • torch.min(input, dim, keepdim=False)

    Here's the breakdown:

    • input: The input tensor.
    • dim: The dimension(s) along which the reduction is performed.
    • keepdim: A boolean (True or False). If True, the reduced dimensions are kept in the output tensor with size 1.

    Example:

    import torch
    
    # Create a tensor of shape (2, 3)
    x = torch.tensor([[1, 2, 3], [4, 5, 6]])
    
    print("Original Tensor:")
    print(x)
    
    # Sum along dimension 0 without keeping the dimension
    sum_without_keepdim = torch.sum(x, dim=0, keepdim=False)
    print("\nSum without keepdim (dim=0):")
    print(sum_without_keepdim)  # Shape: (3,), reduced dimension is removed
    
    # Sum along dimension 0 while keeping the dimension
    sum_with_keepdim = torch.sum(x, dim=0, keepdim=True)
    print("\nSum with keepdim (dim=0):")
    print(sum_with_keepdim)  # Shape: (1, 3), reduced dimension is kept with size 1
    
    # Sum along dimension 1 without keeping the dimension
    sum_without_keepdim_dim1 = torch.sum(x, dim=1, keepdim=False)
    print("\nSum without keepdim (dim=1):")
    print(sum_without_keepdim_dim1)  # Shape: (2,), reduced dimension is removed
    
    # Sum along dimension 1 while keeping the dimension
    sum_with_keepdim_dim1 = torch.sum(x, dim=1, keepdim=True)
    print("\nSum with keepdim (dim=1):")
    print(sum_with_keepdim_dim1)  # Shape: (2, 1), reduced dimension is kept with size 1
    

    Output:

    Original Tensor:
    tensor([[1, 2, 3],
            [4, 5, 6]])
    
    Sum without keepdim (dim=0):
    tensor([5, 7, 9])   # Shape: (3,)
    
    Sum with keepdim (dim=0):
    tensor([[5, 7, 9]])  # Shape: (1, 3)
    
    Sum without keepdim (dim=1):
    tensor([ 6, 15])    # Shape: (2,)
    
    Sum with keepdim (dim=1):
    tensor([[ 6],
            [15]])      # Shape: (2, 1)
    

    Key Points:

    1. Without keepdim (keepdim=False):

      • The reduced dimensions are eliminated from the output tensor.
      • For example, summing along dimension 0 of a (2, 3) tensor results in a (3,) tensor (1D).
    2. With keepdim (keepdim=True):

      • The reduced dimension is retained but has size 1.
      • For example, summing along dimension 0 of a (2, 3) tensor results in a (1, 3) tensor (still 2D, but with the first dimension having size 1).

    When to use keepdim=True:

    • Broadcasting: It’s useful when you want to perform further operations that require matching dimensions, especially when you’re dealing with broadcasting.
    • Matrix operations: In cases where you need to maintain the original structure of the tensor after reduction, keepdim=True ensures that the tensor remains compatible for matrix operations.

    For instance, if you're working on batch processing in deep learning models, maintaining the correct tensor shape can simplify subsequent operations.

    Conclusion:

    • keepdim=True keeps the reduced dimensions in the output tensor with size 1.
    • keepdim=False removes the reduced dimensions entirely.
    • You should choose based on whether you need to retain the dimensionality for further computations.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.