Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
grok-3-preview-02-24· xAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

What about specifically for three-row SUV EVs?

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-maverick-03-26-experimental’s answer.
  1. User

    What about specifically for three-row SUV EVs?

  2. Assistant

    Three-row SUV EVs are a niche but growing segment in the U.S. market, catering to families and those needing more seating and cargo capacity. However, the depreciation trends for these vehicles are influenced by the same broader EV market dynamics discussed previously—such as Tesla's pricing strategies, federal tax credits, rapid technological advancements, and higher initial MSRPs—while also being affected by segment-specific factors like competition, demand, and brand perception.

    Below is an analysis of the depreciation of three-row SUV EVs in the U.S. over the first three years of ownership, focusing on the most prominent models in this category as of 2024. Since specific depreciation data for this niche segment is less widely published compared to the broader EV market, the figures provided are informed estimates based on industry trends, general EV depreciation patterns, and model-specific factors.


    Average Depreciation for Three-Row SUV EVs

    Three-row SUV EVs in the U.S. generally follow the high depreciation trend of the broader EV market, with average depreciation ranging from 45% to 55% over the first three years. However, luxury models in this segment tend to depreciate faster than mainstream models due to their higher initial MSRPs and the rapid pace of technological obsolescence in the luxury EV space.

    Key Models and Their Estimated 3-Year Depreciation

    Here’s a breakdown of the most notable three-row SUV EVs currently available in the U.S., along with their estimated depreciation over the first three years. Note that these are estimates, as exact depreciation can vary based on market conditions, trim levels, mileage, and regional demand.

    1. Tesla Model X

    • Overview: The Tesla Model X is one of the longest-standing three-row SUV EVs in the U.S. market, known for its performance, falcon-wing doors, and premium pricing. It is a luxury EV with a high starting MSRP, which contributes to its steep depreciation.
    • Starting MSRP (2024): ~79,990(base)toover79,990 (base) to over 100,000 (Plaid trim).
    • Key Depreciation Drivers:
      • Tesla’s frequent price cuts on new Model X vehicles have significantly impacted used values.
      • High initial MSRP means more absolute dollar value is lost, even if the percentage depreciation is similar to other EVs.
      • Competition from newer, more affordable three-row EV SUVs (e.g., Kia EV9, Rivian R1S) has softened demand for used Model X vehicles.
      • Rapid advancements in Tesla’s own technology (e.g., improved range, new features) make older Model X units less desirable.
    • Estimated 3-Year Depreciation: ~50% – 55%
      • Example: A 2024 Model X Long Range with an MSRP of 80,000mightbeworthapproximately80,000 might be worth approximately 36,000–$40,000 after three years, assuming average mileage and condition.

    2. Rivian R1S

    • Overview: The Rivian R1S is a premium electric SUV that has gained significant attention for its off-road capability, luxurious interior, and competitive range. It is positioned as a direct competitor to the Tesla Model X but appeals to a slightly different audience, emphasizing adventure and ruggedness.
    • Starting MSRP (2024): ~74,900(base)toover74,900 (base) to over 90,000 (higher trims).
    • Key Depreciation Drivers:
      • As a newer entrant, the R1S benefits from strong initial demand and brand buzz, which may help it retain value better than some competitors in the short term.
      • However, its high starting price and the broader EV market downturn still result in significant depreciation.
      • Competition from more established brands (e.g., Tesla) and newer, more affordable options (e.g., Kia EV9) could pressure used R1S values.
      • Rivian’s ongoing production scaling and potential price adjustments on new models could further impact resale values.
    • Estimated 3-Year Depreciation: ~45% – 50%
      • Example: A 2024 Rivian R1S Adventure trim with an MSRP of 75,000mightbeworthapproximately75,000 might be worth approximately 37,500–$41,250 after three years, assuming average mileage and condition.
      • Note: The R1S may retain value slightly better than the Model X due to its newer design and strong brand loyalty among early adopters, but it is still subject to the broader EV depreciation trend.

    3. Kia EV9

    • Overview: The Kia EV9, introduced in 2023, is the first mainstream, non-luxury three-row SUV EV in the U.S. market. It offers a compelling mix of affordability, range, and features, making it a strong competitor to luxury models at a lower price point.
    • Starting MSRP (2024): ~54,900(base)to 54,900 (base) to ~73,900 (higher trims).
    • Key Depreciation Drivers:
      • The EV9’s lower starting MSRP compared to luxury competitors like the Model X and R1S means it has fewer absolute dollars to lose, potentially resulting in a lower percentage depreciation.
      • Strong initial demand and positive reviews may help it retain value better than luxury models, especially as a more affordable family-oriented option.
      • However, the EV9 is not currently eligible for the full $7,500 federal tax credit when purchased (though it is eligible when leased), which could make new EV9s less competitive against other EVs that qualify, indirectly pressuring used values.
      • As a mainstream brand, Kia’s resale values are generally not as strong as luxury brands, but the EV9’s unique position in the market may mitigate this.
    • Estimated 3-Year Depreciation: ~40% – 47%
      • Example: A 2024 Kia EV9 Wind trim with an MSRP of 60,000mightbeworthapproximately60,000 might be worth approximately 31,800–$36,000 after three years, assuming average mileage and condition.
      • Note: The EV9 is likely to be one of the better performers in this segment in terms of value retention, thanks to its lower starting price and strong demand in the family SUV market.

    4. Mercedes-Benz EQB (Limited Three-Row Option)

    • Overview: The Mercedes-Benz EQB is a compact luxury EV SUV that offers an optional third row, though it is not a full-size three-row SUV like the others on this list. It is included here because it is marketed as a three-row option in the luxury EV space.
    • Starting MSRP (2024): ~52,750(base)to 52,750 (base) to ~60,000 (higher trims).
    • Key Depreciation Drivers:
      • Luxury EVs, especially from traditional automakers like Mercedes-Benz, tend to depreciate quickly due to high initial MSRPs and rapid technological obsolescence.
      • The EQB’s third row is cramped and not as practical as true three-row SUVs, which may limit its appeal on the used market.
      • Competition from larger, more practical three-row EVs (e.g., Kia EV9, Tesla Model X) could further depress used EQB values.
    • Estimated 3-Year Depreciation: ~50% – 55%
      • Example: A 2024 Mercedes-Benz EQB 350 with an MSRP of 58,000mightbeworthapproximately58,000 might be worth approximately 26,100–$29,000 after three years, assuming average mileage and condition.

    5. VinFast VF 9 (Emerging Player)

    • Overview: The VinFast VF 9 is a new entrant to the U.S. market, introduced by the Vietnamese automaker VinFast. It is a full-size three-row SUV EV targeting the luxury segment but at a more accessible price point than competitors like the Model X.
    • Starting MSRP (2024): ~69,800(base)to 69,800 (base) to ~83,000 (higher trims).
    • Key Depreciation Drivers:
      • As a new brand with limited brand recognition and an unproven track record in the U.S., VinFast vehicles are likely to experience steep depreciation, especially in the early years.
      • High initial MSRPs combined with potential reliability concerns and a lack of established resale demand could lead to significant value loss.
      • Aggressive pricing or incentives on new VF 9 models (a strategy VinFast has already employed) could further depress used values.
    • Estimated 3-Year Depreciation: ~55% – 60%
      • Example: A 2024 VinFast VF 9 Eco with an MSRP of 70,000mightbeworthapproximately70,000 might be worth approximately 28,000–$31,500 after three years, assuming average mileage and condition.
      • Note: The VF 9 is likely to be one of the worst performers in this segment in terms of value retention due to its status as an unproven brand.

    Segment-Specific Factors Influencing Depreciation

    In addition to the broader EV market dynamics, three-row SUV EVs face unique factors that influence their depreciation:

    1. High Initial Costs:

      • Most three-row SUV EVs are positioned in the luxury or premium segment, with starting MSRPs often exceeding $70,000. This high starting price naturally leads to greater absolute dollar depreciation, even if the percentage is similar to other vehicle types.
    2. Limited Competition (For Now):

      • The three-row SUV EV segment is still relatively small, with only a handful of models available. This limited competition can help some models (e.g., Kia EV9) retain value better than they might in a more crowded segment. However, as more automakers enter this space (e.g., Hyundai, Volvo, and others), increased competition could accelerate depreciation.
    3. Family-Oriented Demand:

      • Three-row SUVs are primarily purchased by families, who often prioritize practicality, safety, and cost-effectiveness. Used buyers in this segment may be particularly sensitive to concerns about battery degradation, range, and charging infrastructure, which can depress demand for older models and increase depreciation.
    4. Technological Advancements:

      • Three-row SUV EVs are often flagship models for their brands, meaning they are early adopters of new technology. However, this also means that older models can quickly become outdated as newer versions offer improved range, faster charging, and better features, driving down resale values.
    5. Federal Tax Credits:

      • The 7,500federaltaxcreditundertheInflationReductionActappliestosomethree−rowSUVEVs(e.g.,TeslaModelX,RivianR1S)butnotothers(e.g.,KiaEV9,unlessleased).Thisdisparityaffectsthecompetitivenessofnewmodels,whichinturnimpactstheresalevalueofusedmodels.Forexample,ausedModelXmustcompetewithanewModelXthatiseffectively7,500 federal tax credit under the Inflation Reduction Act applies to some three-row SUV EVs (e.g., Tesla Model X, Rivian R1S) but not others (e.g., Kia EV9, unless leased). This disparity affects the competitiveness of new models, which in turn impacts the resale value of used models. For example, a used Model X must compete with a new Model X that is effectively 7,500 cheaper, accelerating depreciation.

    Summary of 3-Year Depreciation for Three-Row SUV EVs

    ModelStarting MSRP (2024)Estimated 3-Year DepreciationApprox. Value After 3 Years (Base Model)
    Tesla Model X~$79,990~50% – 55%~36,000–36,000 – 40,000
    Rivian R1S~$74,900~45% – 50%~37,500–37,500 – 41,250
    Kia EV9~$54,900~40% – 47%~31,800–31,800 – 36,000
    Mercedes-Benz EQB~$52,750~50% – 55%~26,100–26,100 – 29,000
    VinFast VF 9~$69,800~55% – 60%~28,000–28,000 – 31,500

    Key Takeaways for Three-Row SUV EVs

    1. Luxury Models Depreciate Fastest:

      • Luxury three-row SUV EVs like the Tesla Model X, Rivian R1S, and VinFast VF 9 tend to lose the most value due to their high initial MSRPs and the rapid pace of technological obsolescence in the luxury EV space.
    2. Mainstream Models Fare Better:

      • The Kia EV9, as the only mainstream, non-luxury option in this segment, is likely to retain value better than its luxury competitors due to its lower starting price and strong demand among family buyers. However, it still depreciates faster than the average gasoline-powered three-row SUV.
    3. Opportunities for Used Buyers:

      • The steep depreciation of three-row SUV EVs creates significant opportunities for used car buyers. For example, a three-year-old Tesla Model X or Rivian R1S can often be purchased for nearly half its original price, offering substantial savings for those willing to buy used.
    4. Future Trends:

      • As more three-row SUV EVs enter the market (e.g., Hyundai Ioniq 9, Volvo EX90), increased competition could further pressure resale values, especially for luxury models. However, growing consumer acceptance of EVs and improvements in battery longevity may help stabilize depreciation in the long term.

    Final Note

    These depreciation estimates are based on current market conditions and trends as of 2024. Depreciation can vary significantly based on factors such as mileage, condition, regional demand, and future changes in EV pricing, incentives, and technology. For the most accurate and up-to-date information, consulting resources like Kelley Blue Book (KBB), Edmunds, or iSeeCars, or checking local used car listings, is recommended.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.