Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Mistralmistral-medium-2505· Mistral AIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Hey. I'm doing a CTF and I'm a bit stuck. It's reverse engineering task. The program…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326’s answer.
  1. User

    Hey. I'm doing a CTF and I'm a bit stuck. It's reverse engineering task. The program accepts password and then outputs flag. I can't figure out the password, but I have found encoded flag in memory, so maybe it's possible to figure out how should I decode it. Maybe You have some ideas? What needs to be flag in memory looks like this:

    Obnw@]M`xsNC[WYCWYls\GNYU
    

    but it should come out as

    CTF{...}
    

    where I don't know what's in the dots. Any ideas of encoding algorithm? Maybe some xor with previous character or something. Please, try to help me figure this out.

  2. Mistral Assistant

    Given the encoded flag Obnw@]MxsNC[WYCWYls\GNYUand the expected formatCTF{...}`, this looks like a classic case of a simple encoding scheme, possibly involving XOR operations, bit shifts, or other basic transformations. Here are some approaches to decode it:

    1. XOR with a Key or Previous Character

    • A common encoding method is XORing each character with a fixed key or the previous character. For example:
      • flag[i] = encoded[i] ^ key or flag[i] = encoded[i] ^ encoded[i-1].
    • Try XORing each character with a fixed value (e.g., 0x30, 0x55, etc.) or with the previous character to see if a recognizable pattern emerges.

    2. Base64 or Other Encodings

    • The encoded string doesn't look like standard Base64, but it might be a custom variant or another encoding like Base32, Base58, etc. Try decoding it with these methods.

    3. Bit Shifts or Rotations

    • The characters might be shifted by a fixed number of positions (e.g., +1, -3). For example:
      • flag_char = encoded_char - 1 or similar.
    • Try shifting each character by a small integer and see if the result looks like CTF{...}.

    4. Reverse the String

    • Sometimes the string is simply reversed. Try reversing Obnw@]MxsNC[WYCWYls\GNYU` and see if it makes sense.

    5. Check for Simple Substitution Ciphers

    • The encoding might involve substituting characters based on a fixed mapping (e.g., A -> Z, B -> Y, etc.).

    6. Look for Patterns in the Encoded String

    • The encoded string has some interesting characters like @, ], [, \, which might hint at a specific encoding scheme. For example:
      • The @ might correspond to { in the flag format.
      • The ] or [ might correspond to } or }.

    7. Brute-Force Small Keys

    • If the encoding is XOR with a single-byte key, you can brute-force all 256 possible keys and see which one gives a plausible flag.

    8. Check for Known Flag Formats

    • The flag is likely in the format CTF{...}, so the first few characters of the decoded string should be CTF. Use this to guess the encoding scheme.

    Example Attempt:

    Let's try XORing the first few characters with a fixed key to see if we can get CTF:

    • Suppose the first character of the flag is C (ASCII 67).
    • The first character of the encoded string is O (ASCII 79).
    • Then, key = 79 ^ 67 = 16 (or 0x10).
    • Now, XOR the next few characters with 16 to see if we get TF{:
      • b (ASCII 98) ^ 16 = R (ASCII 82) → Not T.
      • This key doesn't work, so try another approach.

    Alternative Approach: XOR with Previous Character

    Let's assume the first character is C (67) and the encoded first character is O (79). Then:

    • flag[0] = encoded[0] ^ key → 67 = 79 ^ key → key = 79 ^ 67 = 16.
    • Now, assume flag[i] = encoded[i] ^ flag[i-1]:
      • flag[0] = 67 (given).
      • flag[1] = encoded[1] ^ flag[0] = 98 ^ 67 = 33 (not T).
      • This doesn't seem to work either.

    Another Idea: Shift by -1

    Let's try shifting each character down by 1:

    • O (79) → N (78)
    • b (98) → a (97)
    • n (110) → m (109)
    • w (119) → v (118) This gives N a m v..., which doesn't look like CTF.

    Try Shift by -2:

    • O (79) → M (77)
    • b (98) → Z (90)
    • n (110) → l (108)
    • w (119) → t (116) This gives M Z l t..., still not CTF.

    Try XOR with 0x55:

    • O (79) ^ 0x55 = 79 ^ 85 = 124 (|)
    • b (98) ^ 0x55 = 98 ^ 85 = 17 This doesn't seem helpful.

    Try Reversing the String:

    Reversed: UNYG\slYWCYW[CNxM]@wnbO This doesn't look like CTF{...}.

    Try Base64:

    The string Obnw@]MxsNC[WYCWYls\GNYUis not valid Base64 (contains@, ], [, `).

    Conclusion:

    The most likely encoding is XOR with a fixed key or a simple shift. Since brute-forcing the key is tedious manually, you might want to write a small script to try all possible single-byte XOR keys and see which one gives a plausible flag starting with CTF.

    Here’s a Python snippet to try all single-byte XOR keys:

    encoded = "Obnw@]M`xsNC[WYCWYls\\GNYU"
    for key in range(256):
        flag = ''.join(chr(c ^ key) for c in encoded)
        if flag.startswith("CTF{"):
            print(f"Key: {key}, Flag: {flag}")
    

    If this doesn't work, the encoding might be more complex (e.g., XOR with a multi-byte key or a non-linear transformation). In that case, you might need to analyze the binary further to understand the exact encoding algorithm.

  3. User

    This doesn't yield valid flag. Could You think more about it?

  4. Mistral Assistant

    Given that simple XOR or shift operations didn't yield a valid flag, let's think more carefully about the encoding. Here are some additional ideas:

    1. XOR with a Multi-Byte Key or Pattern

    • The encoding might use a repeating multi-byte key (e.g., XOR with "key" or "secret").
    • Alternatively, it could XOR with a pattern like alternating bytes (e.g., 0xAA, 0x55).

    2. Custom Encoding Scheme

    • The encoding might involve a combination of operations, such as:
      • XOR with a key, then shift.
      • Or shift, then XOR.
    • For example: flag_char = (encoded_char ^ key) - shift.

    3. Look for Byte Patterns

    • The encoded string Obnw@]MxsNC[WYCWYls\GNYU` has some interesting characters:
      • @ (ASCII 64), ] (93), [ (91), \ (92).
    • These might correspond to special characters in the flag, like {, }, _, etc.

    4. Check for Byte Swapping or Endianness

    • The encoding might involve swapping bytes or reversing bits within each byte.

    5. Analyze the Binary for Clues

    • If you have the binary, look for strings or patterns that might hint at the encoding algorithm.
    • For example, if the binary has a string like "XOR" or "SHIFT", that could be a clue.

    6. Try Common CTF Encoding Schemes

    • Some CTFs use custom encoding schemes like:
      • XOR with the string length or a fixed value derived from the string.
      • XOR with the position of the character (e.g., flag[i] = encoded[i] ^ i).

    7. Check for Non-Standard Encodings

    • The encoding might involve non-standard operations like:
      • Adding or subtracting a fixed value, then XORing.
      • Using a lookup table or substitution cipher.

    Example Attempt: XOR with Position

    Let's try XORing each character with its position (starting from 0 or 1):

    encoded = "Obnw@]M`xsNC[WYCWYls\\GNYU"
    flag = []
    for i, c in enumerate(encoded):
        flag_char = chr(ord(c) ^ i)
        flag.append(flag_char)
    flag = ''.join(flag)
    print(flag)
    

    This gives a garbled output, but it's worth checking if any part looks like CTF{...}.

    Example Attempt: XOR with a Repeating Key

    Let's try XORing with a repeating key like "key":

    encoded = "Obnw@]M`xsNC[WYCWYls\\GNYU"
    key = "key"
    flag = []
    for i, c in enumerate(encoded):
        flag_char = chr(ord(c) ^ ord(key[i % len(key)]))
        flag.append(flag_char)
    flag = ''.join(flag)
    print(flag)
    

    This might give a more plausible output.

    Example Attempt: Shift by Position

    Let's try shifting each character by its position:

    encoded = "Obnw@]M`xsNC[WYCWYls\\GNYU"
    flag = []
    for i, c in enumerate(encoded):
        flag_char = chr(ord(c) - i)
        flag.append(flag_char)
    flag = ''.join(flag)
    print(flag)
    

    Example Attempt: XOR with a Fixed Key and Shift

    Let's try XOR with a fixed key (e.g., 0x30) and then shift:

    encoded = "Obnw@]M`xsNC[WYCWYls\\GNYU"
    flag = []
    for c in encoded:
        xor_char = chr(ord(c) ^ 0x30)
        shift_char = chr(ord(xor_char) - 1)
        flag.append(shift_char)
    flag = ''.join(flag)
    print(flag)
    

    If All Else Fails:

    If none of these work, the encoding might be more complex, and you might need to:

    1. Analyze the binary to see how the password is checked and how the flag is encoded.
    2. Look for hardcoded values in the binary that might be used as keys.
    3. Check for dynamic encoding where the encoding depends on the password or other runtime values.

    Final Thought:

    Given that the flag is in memory as Obnw@]MxsNC[WYCWYls\GNYU`, it's likely that the encoding is reversible with the right key or algorithm. If you can share more details about the binary (e.g., disassembly snippets or how the password is checked), I can help further!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.