Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Qwenqwen3-235b-a22b-no-thinking· Alibaba (Qwen)Hugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Q.3 (Inventory Management) Consider the following EOQ problem faced by a retailer…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-3-5-haiku-20241022’s answer.
  1. User

    Q.3 (Inventory Management) Consider the following EOQ problem faced by a retailer sourcing a product with quantity discounts and a known defective rate. The key EOQ information is as follows: • Annual demand: 10,000 units • Ordering setup cost: 300perorder•Annualholdingcost:300 per order • Annual holding cost: 0.4 per unit (based on usable units) • Insurance rate is 0%. • Price discount scheme: Order Quantity Price per unit 0– 3,000 units 4.003,001–6,000units4.00 3,001– 6,000 units 3.90 > 6,000 units 3.80.Inaddition,weknowthat2Defectiveunitsincuradisposalcostof3.80. In addition, we know that 2% of the items received from your supplier are defective and cannot be sold. Defective units incur a disposal cost of 0.2 per unit immediately upon receipt and are not returned to the supplier. What is the optimal order quantity and the lowest annual total cost? Detailed solution steps are needed. (10 points)

  2. Qwen Assistant

    We are given an Economic Order Quantity (EOQ) problem with:

    • Quantity discounts
    • Defective rate of 2%, which reduces usable units and incurs disposal cost
    • Holding cost is based on usable units

    Step 1: Understand the Parameters

    Given:

    • Annual demand (D) = 10,000 usable units
    • Ordering cost (S) = $300 per order
    • Holding cost (H) = $0.40 per unit per year (based on usable units)
    • Defect rate = 2%
    • Disposal cost for defective items = $0.20/unit
    • Price discount schedule:
    Order QuantityUnit Price (c)
    0 – 3,000$4.00
    3,001 – 6,000$3.90
    >6,000$3.80

    Step 2: Adjust Demand to Account for Defects

    Since 2% of ordered units are defective, only 98% are usable.

    Let Q be the actual number of units ordered. Then the number of usable units is:

    Usable units=Q×0.98\text{Usable units} = Q \times 0.98

    So to get D = 10,000 usable units, we need to order:

    Qeffective=10,0000.98≈10,204.08 unitsQ_{\text{effective}} = \frac{10,000}{0.98} \approx 10,204.08 \text{ units}

    This will be used in total cost calculations.


    Step 3: EOQ Formula and Total Cost Function

    The classic EOQ formula is:

    Q∗=2DSHQ^* = \sqrt{\frac{2DS}{H}}

    But since there are quantity discounts, we must calculate the total annual cost (TAC) for each price range and determine the best one.


    Step 4: Define Total Cost Components

    Total annual cost includes:

    1. Purchasing cost:

      Cost per unit×Effective order quantity\text{Cost per unit} \times \text{Effective order quantity}
    2. Ordering cost:

      (DQ)×S\left(\frac{D}{Q}\right) \times S
    3. Holding cost:

      (Q⋅0.982)×H\left(\frac{Q \cdot 0.98}{2}\right) \times H
    4. Disposal cost for defective units:

      Q⋅0.02⋅0.20Q \cdot 0.02 \cdot 0.20

    Thus, the Total Annual Cost (TAC) function becomes:

    TAC(Q)=(DQ⋅S)+(Q⋅0.982⋅H)+(D⋅c)+(Q⋅0.02⋅0.20)\text{TAC}(Q) = \left( \frac{D}{Q} \cdot S \right) + \left( \frac{Q \cdot 0.98}{2} \cdot H \right) + \left( D \cdot c \right) + \left( Q \cdot 0.02 \cdot 0.20 \right)

    Where:

    • cc = unit cost from the price table
    • QQ = order quantity
    • D=10,000D = 10,000
    • S=300S = 300
    • H=0.40H = 0.40

    Step 5: Compute EOQ for Each Price Range

    We’ll compute the EOQ under each price level and then check if it lies within that price range. If not, we’ll test the boundary values.


    Price Range 1: 0–3,000 units; c = $4.00

    Compute EOQ:

    Q∗=2DSH=2⋅10,000⋅3000.4=15,000,000≈3,873Q^* = \sqrt{\frac{2DS}{H}} = \sqrt{\frac{2 \cdot 10,000 \cdot 300}{0.4}} = \sqrt{15,000,000} \approx 3,873

    But this falls outside the 0–3,000 range → Not applicable. So we'll use Q = 3,000.

    Now compute TAC at Q = 3,000:

    • Purchasing cost:

      D⋅c=10,000⋅4=$40,000D \cdot c = 10,000 \cdot 4 = \$40,000
    • Ordering cost:

      DQ⋅S=10,0003,000⋅300=3.333⋅300=$1,000\frac{D}{Q} \cdot S = \frac{10,000}{3,000} \cdot 300 = 3.333 \cdot 300 = \$1,000
    • Holding cost:

      Q⋅0.982⋅H=3,000⋅0.982⋅0.4=1,470⋅0.4=$588\frac{Q \cdot 0.98}{2} \cdot H = \frac{3,000 \cdot 0.98}{2} \cdot 0.4 = 1,470 \cdot 0.4 = \$588
    • Disposal cost:

      Q⋅0.02⋅0.20=3,000⋅0.02⋅0.2=$12Q \cdot 0.02 \cdot 0.20 = 3,000 \cdot 0.02 \cdot 0.2 = \$12

    Total Cost = 40,000 + 1,000 + 588 + 12 = $41,600


    Price Range 2: 3,001–6,000; c = $3.90

    Compute EOQ again:

    Q∗=2⋅10,000⋅3000.4=3,873Q^* = \sqrt{\frac{2 \cdot 10,000 \cdot 300}{0.4}} = 3,873

    This lies within the range 3,001–6,000 ⇒ Use Q = 3,873

    Compute TAC:

    • Purchasing cost:

      10,000⋅3.90=$39,00010,000 \cdot 3.90 = \$39,000
    • Ordering cost:

      10,0003,873⋅300≈2.582⋅300=$774.60\frac{10,000}{3,873} \cdot 300 \approx 2.582 \cdot 300 = \$774.60
    • Holding cost:

      3,873⋅0.982⋅0.4=1,897.02⋅0.4=$758.81\frac{3,873 \cdot 0.98}{2} \cdot 0.4 = 1,897.02 \cdot 0.4 = \$758.81
    • Disposal cost:

      3,873⋅0.02⋅0.2=$15.493,873 \cdot 0.02 \cdot 0.2 = \$15.49

    Total Cost ≈ 39,000 + 774.60 + 758.81 + 15.49 ≈ $40,548.90


    Price Range 3: >6,000; c = $3.80

    Compute EOQ:

    Same as before ⇒ Q* = 3,873 < 6,000 ⇒ Not in range

    So we test the lower bound of this range: Q = 6,000

    Compute TAC at Q = 6,000:

    • Purchasing cost:

      10,000⋅3.80=$38,00010,000 \cdot 3.80 = \$38,000
    • Ordering cost:

      10,0006,000⋅300=1.6667⋅300=$500\frac{10,000}{6,000} \cdot 300 = 1.6667 \cdot 300 = \$500
    • Holding cost:

      6,000⋅0.982⋅0.4=2,940⋅0.4=$1,176\frac{6,000 \cdot 0.98}{2} \cdot 0.4 = 2,940 \cdot 0.4 = \$1,176
    • Disposal cost:

      6,000⋅0.02⋅0.2=$246,000 \cdot 0.02 \cdot 0.2 = \$24

    Total Cost = 38,000 + 500 + 1,176 + 24 = $39,700


    Step 6: Compare Total Costs

    Order QtyUnit PriceTotal Cost
    3,000$4.00$41,600
    3,873$3.90$40,549
    6,000$3.80$39,700 ✅

    ✅ Final Answer:

    • Optimal Order Quantity: 6,000 units
    • Lowest Annual Total Cost: $39,700

    This accounts for:

    • Quantity discounts
    • 2% defect rate
    • Disposal costs for defective units
    • Holding cost based on usable units

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.