Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

I have a compressed sensing problem where I am designing a physical linear…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with DeepSeekdeepseek-v3-0324’s answer.
  1. User

    I have a compressed sensing problem where I am designing a physical linear transformation \Phi for an incoherent imaging problem, transforming from input field tensor (flattened) with shape (nx, ny, nwvl) to an output sensor field (also flattened) with shape (nx, ny) by convolving each spatial slice with a different PSF at each frequency, and summing at each monochromatic pixel. I have two schemes for optimizing the transformation for optimal recovery in a sparse basis \Psi. One is minimizing the total coherence, formed by the sum of A_norm^T A_norm where A = \Phi \Psi and A_norm is formed by the normalized columns of A. The other is maximizing: log det(1+A^T A). Currently for few wavelengths, the optimization for both methods converges towards a diffraction limited focusing phase aperture for seemingly any choice of basis \Psi. I believe this to be a result of having many more combinations of non spatially overlapping columns of A vs. spatially overlapping at different wavelengths, and therefore the optimization favours the many over the few, resulting in the optimal phase for a single wavelength slice (diffraction limited pattern). My question is how to increase the weightings of the inner products between the latter in order to avoid this “trivial” focusing aperture function?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    This is a fascinating problem, and your hypothesis about the optimization converging to a single-wavelength diffraction-limited solution due to a mismatch in "information density" or "complexity" between spatial and spectral aspects is very insightful. You're hitting on a core challenge in snapshot spectral imaging or any compressed sensing system where multiple data dimensions are collapsed into fewer measurements.

    Let's break down why this happens and then explore solutions to "increase the weightings of the inner products between the latter" (i.e., columns of AA that are spatially overlapping but spectrally distinct).

    Why the "Trivial" Solution Appears

    Your current setup transforms a 3D input (nx, ny, nwvl) to a 2D output (nx, ny) via convolution and summation. This is a severe undersampling in the spectral dimension.

    1. Dominance of Spatial Information: In typical imaging problems, the spatial resolution (number of pixels nx * ny) is much larger than the number of wavelengths (nwvl). If your basis Ψ\Psi has many more spatial modes than spectral modes, or if the spectral modes get heavily mixed by Φ\Phi, the optimization naturally prioritizes what it can optimize best: the spatial quality.
    2. Spectral Conflation by Summation: The operation "summing at each monochromatic pixel" directly collapses the spectral dimension. If PjP_j (the PSF for wavelength jj) are not sufficiently distinct or designed to encode spectral information, then two input signals that are spatially identical but spectrally different (e.g., a point source at λ1\lambda_1 vs. a point source at λ2\lambda_2) will produce very similar output patterns if P1≈P2P_1 \approx P_2.
    3. Optimization Objectives' Blind Spots:
      • Minimizing total coherence (∑∣∣ai∣∣22\sum ||\mathbf{a}_i||_2^2 where ai\mathbf{a}_i are normalized columns of A=ΦΨA = \Phi \Psi): This objective wants all columns of AA to be as orthogonal as possible. If Φ\Phi makes spectrally distinct inputs produce nearly identical outputs, those resulting ai\mathbf{a}_i columns will be highly correlated, leading to high coherence. The optimization might find it "easier" to achieve low coherence by making PjP_j essentially identical (e.g., diffraction limited at one wavelength), thereby effectively reducing the dimensionality of the problem by ignoring the spectral diversity altogether, making the remaining spatial components more distinguishable.
      • Maximizing log⁡det⁡(I+ATA)\log \det(I+A^T A): This aims to maximize the information captured by the measurements about the sparse coefficients. If the spectral dimension is collapsed, the effective rank of AA with respect to spectral information becomes very low. The optimization might find that maximizing the determinant is best achieved by having very distinct spatial mappings, even if it means sacrificing spectral distinguishability. For instance, if two spectrally distinct basis vectors ψ1\psi_1 and ψ2\psi_2 map to nearly identical a1a_1 and a2a_2, this effectively reduces the useful rank of AA, impacting det⁡(I+ATA)\det(I+A^T A). The optimization might see a "good" solution as one where the measurement matrix is well-conditioned for spatial recovery, even if it's ill-conditioned for spectral recovery.

    Strategies to Encourage Spectral Diversity in Φ\Phi

    The core idea is to force Φ\Phi to encode spectral information into the spatial measurements, rather than just collapse it. This requires either modifying your objective functions to explicitly penalize spectral conflation or changing the physical interpretation of your PSFs and the measurement process.

    1. Modify the Objective Function: Introduce Specific Spectral Penalties

    This is the most direct way to "increase the weightings of the inner products between the latter."

    • Targeted Coherence Penalty (for the sum of A_norm^T A_norm objective):

      • Identify pairs of basis vectors (ψk,ψj)(\mathbf{\psi}_k, \mathbf{\psi}_j) in your sparse basis Ψ\Psi that are spatially very similar (or identical) but spectrally distinct.
        • Example: If Ψ\Psi is a separable basis Ψ=Ψspatial⊗Ψspectral\Psi = \Psi_{spatial} \otimes \Psi_{spectral}, then a pair might be (ψs0⊗ψλ1,ψs0⊗ψλ2)(\mathbf{\psi}_{s_0} \otimes \mathbf{\psi}_{\lambda_1}, \mathbf{\psi}_{s_0} \otimes \mathbf{\psi}_{\lambda_2}) where s0s_0 is a specific spatial mode and λ1≠λ2\lambda_1 \neq \lambda_2.
      • Add a penalty term to your objective that specifically targets the inner products (coherence) of these resulting columns in AA: Minimize∑i∣∣ai∣∣22+λspectral∑(k,j)∈SpectrallyDistinctPairs∣⟨ak/∣∣ak∣∣,aj/∣∣aj∣∣⟩∣2\text{Minimize} \quad \sum_i ||\mathbf{a}_i||_2^2 + \lambda_{spectral} \sum_{(k,j) \in \text{SpectrallyDistinctPairs}} |\langle \mathbf{a}_k / ||\mathbf{a}_k||, \mathbf{a}_j / ||\mathbf{a}_j|| \rangle|^2
        • The λspectral\lambda_{spectral} weighting factor controls how strongly you enforce spectral separation.
        • This directly tells the optimizer: "These specific spectrally different signals must produce distinct measurement patterns, even if they are spatially similar."
        • You might need to carefully define SpectrallyDistinctPairs to include all relevant spectral modes.
    • Spectral Feature Discriminability Penalty (for both objectives):

      • Define a linear operator S:RNxNy→RNxNyS: \mathbb{R}^{N_x N_y} \to \mathbb{R}^{N_x N_y} that, for example, highlights certain spatial features or focuses specific parts of the image (e.g., a simple blur, a derivative filter, etc. – though this might be too general).
      • A more effective approach might be to try and reconstruct the spectral content from the measurements and penalize errors. This brings you closer to end-to-end learning, which might be overkill.
      • Alternative: Eigenvalue Spread of Spectrally-Relevant Subspace:
        • Consider a subset of columns of AA corresponding to spectrally-varying basis vectors (e.g., Aspectral=[Φ(ψs0⊗ψλ1),Φ(ψs0⊗ψλ2),… ]A_{spectral} = [\Phi(\mathbf{\psi}_{s_0} \otimes \mathbf{\psi}_{\lambda_1}), \Phi(\mathbf{\psi}_{s_0} \otimes \mathbf{\psi}_{\lambda_2}), \dots] for a fixed spatial mode s0s_0).
        • Add a term that encourages these columns to form a high-rank, well-conditioned subspace. For example, maximize det⁡(AspectralTAspectral)\det(A_{spectral}^T A_{spectral}), or minimize the condition number of AspectralA_{spectral}. This is similar to the log⁡det⁡\log \det objective but applied to a specific subspace.
        • Maximizelog⁡det⁡(I+ATA)+λspectral⋅log⁡det⁡(I+Aspectral_subspaceTAspectral_subspace)\text{Maximize} \quad \log \det(I+A^T A) + \lambda_{spectral} \cdot \log \det(I + A_{spectral\_subspace}^T A_{spectral\_subspace})
        • This explicitly tries to ensure that the spectral information within each spatial mode is well-preserved.

    2. Rethink the Physical Transformation Φ\Phi: Spatial-Spectral Multiplexing

    Your current Φ\Phi formulation ("convolving each spatial slice with a different PSF at each frequency, and summing") implies that each pixel on the sensor is a simple sum of convolved images from different wavelengths. This is the bottleneck.

    To truly encode spectral information, you need spatially varying spectral filtering, also known as spatial-spectral multiplexing. This means your "PSF at each frequency" PjP_j is not just a uniform convolution kernel for that wavelength, but also encodes information in the spatial domain that helps disambiguate wavelengths.

    Common architectures for this in snapshot spectral imaging include:

    • Coded Aperture Snapshot Spectral Imagers (CASSI):

      1. Light from the scene passes through a coded aperture (a spatial mask that varies intensity, often binary or grayscale).
      2. It then passes through a dispersive element (prism or grating) that spreads different wavelengths to different spatial locations.
      3. Finally, it's recorded on a 2D sensor.
      • How this relates to your Φ\Phi: In this setup, your effective PjP_j for each wavelength jj would be a spatially-shifted and perhaps spatially-filtered version of the common system PSF, where the shift depends on the wavelength and the dispersion. The "convolution" is no longer just a simple blurring, but includes a spatial encoding.
      • The output y(u,v)\mathbf{y}(u,v) would then be a sum over wavelengths of the dispersed, coded, and convolved input fields. The structure of these PjP_j functions (which would no longer be just simple spatial kernels but rather a combination of the coded aperture pattern and the dispersion properties) would be optimized.
      • Your Φ\Phi would essentially be designed by choosing the coded aperture pattern. The different PjP_j would arise naturally from the interaction of the fixed coded aperture with the variable dispersion.
    • Spatially-varying filters / Filter arrays:

      • Instead of a single coded aperture, you could imagine a filter array where different spatial regions of your optical element apply different spectral filters. For example, a "patchwork" of narrowband filters, or continuously varying filters.
      • This is harder to represent as a single, simple convolution per wavelength. The matrix Φ\Phi would become block-diagonal (for different spatial regions) with each block representing the distinct wavelength-dependent filter.

    Recommendation for Φ\Phi Design: If you are truly designing a physical linear transformation, consider a design space for Φ\Phi that allows for spatial-spectral encoding.

    • Instead of yu,v=∑j(xj∗Pj)u,vy_{u,v} = \sum_j (x_j * P_j)_{u,v}, where PjP_j is a simple PSF, think about: yu,v=∑j(xj(u′,v′)⋅Cj(u′,v′))∗K(u−u′,v−v′)y_{u,v} = \sum_j (x_j(u',v') \cdot C_j(u',v')) * K(u-u', v-v') where Cj(u,v)C_j(u,v) is a wavelength-specific spatial coding mask and KK is a common system PSF. Your optimization would then be over the parameters of Cj(u,v)C_j(u,v) or a single combined mask for all wavelengths (as in CASSI). This requires a more sophisticated optical model for Φ\Phi.

    3. Refine the Sparse Basis Ψ\Psi

    While not directly about Φ\Phi, the choice of Ψ\Psi influences A=ΦΨA=\Phi\Psi significantly.

    • Ensure Spectral Diversity in Ψ\Psi: Make sure your sparse basis Ψ\Psi has sufficient representation of spectral variations. If Ψ\Psi is primarily spatially oriented (e.g., only spatial wavelets applied identically across all wavelengths), then AA will mostly reflect spatial information, and the optimization will naturally focus there.
    • Separable Bases: If Ψ\Psi is a Kronecker product of a spatial basis and a spectral basis (Ψ=Ψspatial⊗Ψspectral\Psi = \Psi_{spatial} \otimes \Psi_{spectral}), it makes it easier to identify "spatially similar, spectrally distinct" pairs for objective function penalties.

    Summary and Actionable Steps

    1. Prioritize Spectral Disambiguation: The core problem is that your current Φ\Phi formulation (or its optimization outcome) treats different wavelengths as too similar in the final measurement space. You need to explicitly encourage Φ\Phi to make them distinguishable.

    2. Implement Targeted Penalties (Easier to start):

      • For the coherence objective, add a weighted penalty for coherence(ak,aj)\text{coherence}(\mathbf{a}_k, \mathbf{a}_j) where ψk\mathbf{\psi}_k and ψj\mathbf{\psi}_j are spatially similar but spectrally distinct.
      • For the log⁡det⁡\log \det objective, add a term that maximizes the determinant of a submatrix of ATAA^T A (or similar) corresponding to spectrally-distinguishing components.
    3. Consider a More Sophisticated Φ\Phi (More impactful, but harder):

      • If possible, incorporate principles from snapshot compressive spectral imaging (e.g., coded apertures, dispersion) into your model of Φ\Phi. This allows Φ\Phi to intrinsically encode spectral information into spatial patterns. Your "PSF at each frequency" would then become a more complex function that includes the spatial encoding unique to that wavelength. This is often the most effective solution for multi-spectral CS.

    By modifying the objective function to directly penalize spectral conflation, or by designing a Φ\Phi that inherently performs spatial-spectral multiplexing, you can guide your optimization away from the "trivial" diffraction-limited solution and towards one that prioritizes robust multi-spectral recovery.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.