Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
chatgpt-4o-latest-20250326· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Surely this should say otherwise implied (or something similar): 2.2. As of the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon.nova-pro-v1:0’s answer.
  1. User

    Surely this should say otherwise implied (or something similar): 2.2. As of the Termination Date, the Agreement will be of no further force or effect, and the rights and obligations of each of the parties thereunder will terminate, except for any rights or obligations of the parties that are expressly designated under the Agreement and Term Sheet 5 to survive termination.

  2. Assistant

    You're correct in your observation — the phrase “expressly designated under the Agreement and Term Sheet 5 to survive termination” implies that only explicit provisions survive, and that all others terminate. The notion of express designation means there's no room for an implied survival of rights and obligations.

    So, the sentence seems internally consistent. However, if you're concerned about making it clearer that only expressly stated provisions survive — and that nothing survives implicitly — you might adjust the wording slightly.

    Suggested Revision (to emphasize clarity):

    2.2. As of the Termination Date, the Agreement will be of no further force or effect, and the rights and obligations of each of the parties thereunder will terminate, except for any rights or obligations that are expressly designated in the Agreement or in Term Sheet 5 as surviving termination. For the avoidance of doubt, no other rights or obligations shall survive termination, whether implied or otherwise.

    This explicitly handles your concern by preventing an interpretation that any implied rights or obligations could survive termination. Let me know if you’d like it to be more formal or concise.

  3. User

    Well my concern is there is risk that something could be implied to survive which should survive hence my suggestion

  4. Assistant

    Ah, thank you for the clarification — I now understand your concern better.

    You're not worried about excluding implied obligations — you're actually concerned that some rights or obligations, while not expressly stated to survive, may reasonably be understood to do so (such as payment obligations accrued before termination, confidentiality, indemnities, etc.). Your worry is that the original clause, by referring only to "expressly designated" survivals, could unintentionally exclude those commonly implied survivals — and that could be risky or unintended.

    So your suggestion to add “or otherwise implied” (or similar language) is about ensuring that such obligations still survive, even if not explicitly designated.

    Original clause:

    "...except for any rights or obligations of the parties that are expressly designated under the Agreement and Term Sheet 5 to survive termination."

    Risk:

    This could be read narrowly to mean only express survivals — and therefore exclude necessary or reasonably implied survivals, which are common in contracts (e.g., confidentiality, accrued obligations, indemnity).


    Recommendation

    If the intention is to allow for survival of both express and implied rights/obligations, you can revise the clause to reflect that. Here’s a suggested redraft that covers both:

    Revised Clause: 2.2. As of the Termination Date, the Agreement will be of no further force or effect, and the rights and obligations of each of the parties thereunder will terminate, except for any rights or obligations that (a) are expressly stated in the Agreement or Term Sheet 5 to survive termination, or (b) by their nature or necessary implication are intended to survive, including, without limitation, accrued payment obligations, confidentiality, and indemnity provisions.

    This formulation allows for:

    • Express survivals (covered by clause (a)), and
    • Implied/necessary survivals (covered by clause (b)).

    You can also tailor the examples in (b) to the kinds of clauses typical in your agreement.


    If You Prefer Minimal Insertion

    If you like the structure of the original clause and just want to gently broaden its scope, you could go with something like:

    "...except for any rights or obligations that are expressly designated under the Agreement and Term Sheet 5, or that are otherwise reasonably understood to survive termination."

    Or:

    "...except for any rights or obligations of the parties that are expressly designated under the Agreement and Term Sheet 5, or that are implied as surviving by their nature or context."


    Summary

    You're absolutely right to raise this concern. If the goal is to allow survival of key obligations even if not expressly designated, then “or otherwise implied” — or a more precise equivalent — is very appropriate and should be added to avoid unintended waivers or terminations. Let me know if you'd like to tailor this to a specific agreement!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.