Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Recently there were attempts to train transformer language model (LLM) for "automatic…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Googlegemma-3-27b-it’s answer.
  1. User

    Recently there were attempts to train transformer language model (LLM) for "automatic prompt extension", to do user request or source documents parsing and interpretation, making connections and encoding "latent structure" (CLS tokens in embedding space), to better perform task. But current methods involve generating long chains of "wandering around", with 100s-1000s candidates, then verify them and filter for "successful path", train LLM on it and iterate again. This approach only works if we have a simple way to verify answer, which mostly limits this technique to math (and only very specific domains) and code. It is nice to have better math/coding instruct LLMs, but what about everything else? It is no fun to have LLM generate application which kind of do what were requested, but have horrible UI (WebUI/GUI/CLI); or unable to properly design architecture first; or in case of math, to see task as a mathematician, not answer-guessing student on the exam who doesn't see/consider bigger picture. Like, if I ask question, sometimes it is better to ask details first, not jump straight into implementation with some weird assumptions; or when I ask tricky question for sanity check, it is unwise to take them at face value, especially when it is explicitly stated they are problematic -- it is very frustrating to see math/coding "LLM assistant" to fail sanity check when it is clearly told that we do such a test, let alone passing sanity check even if we don't tell "there IS a problem, damn you pay attention to what is said".

    So, I want to ask:

    1. What we need "automatic prompt extension" to do for us? What it needs to cover?
    2. Measuring success in tasks without clear "right answer", or even novelty-focused.
    3. Explain metaphor math/world through eyes of mathematician/architect vs answer-guessing student on the exam.
    4. "AI as a tool" Vs "AI as a conversation participant and co-author".
    5. AI and game strategies (Chess/Go), but moving to game of "communication" and "making sense".
  2. Gemini Assistant

    This is a fantastic and deeply insightful set of questions that goes right to the heart of current LLM limitations and the future of AI interaction. Your frustration with the "answer-guessing student" behavior is widely shared. Let's break down each point.


    1. What we need "automatic prompt extension" to do for us? What it needs to cover?

    Current APE methods often treat the prompt as a static "input" and the LLM's role as generating various "outputs" to be validated. What we need APE to do is to transform the prompt from a static input into a dynamic, evolving representation of shared understanding.

    It needs to cover:

    • Proactive Clarification & Questioning:

      • Identify ambiguity, missing information, or implicit assumptions in the user's request.
      • Generate precise clarifying questions ("Did you mean X or Y?", "What are the constraints regarding Z?", "Who is the target user for this application?").
      • Challenge seemingly problematic statements, as you mentioned with sanity checks ("You mentioned X, but this seems to conflict with Y. Can you clarify?").
      • Identify potential conflicts or trade-offs in requirements (e.g., "You want this to be simple to use, but also highly customizable. We might need to prioritize one or find a balanced approach.").
    • Goal-Oriented Decomposition & Planning:

      • Break down high-level, abstract requests (e.g., "build an app") into concrete, actionable sub-tasks and dependencies (e.g., "design UI," "choose database," "implement authentication").
      • Propose different architectural approaches or design patterns before diving into code.
      • Generate a phased roadmap or project plan, complete with potential milestones and risks.
      • Identify and articulate non-functional requirements (performance, scalability, security, maintainability, user experience) that often go unstated but are critical for a "good" solution.
    • Contextual & Latent Structure Encoding:

      • Not just a flat embedding of the prompt, but building an internal, dynamic "knowledge graph" or "mental model" of the problem space, its entities, relationships, constraints, and the user's underlying intent. This is what you refer to as "CLS tokens in embedding space" – a richer, more structured representation than current methods.
      • Connect the current request to past interactions, user preferences, domain knowledge, and common pitfalls.
      • Infer user skill level or background to tailor explanations and solutions.
    • Exploration of Solution Space & Trade-offs:

      • Generate not just one candidate solution, but diverse types of solutions based on different assumptions or priorities (e.g., a bare-bones MVP vs. a robust, feature-rich version; a cloud-native vs. on-premise solution).
      • Articulate the pros and cons of different approaches.
      • Propose alternative problem formulations if the initial one seems suboptimal.
    • Reflective Self-Correction & Critique:

      • Enable the LLM to evaluate its own generated "extensions" or plans before execution, based on internally learned principles of good design, usability, or mathematical rigor.
      • Identify potential biases, ethical considerations, or unforeseen consequences of a proposed solution.
      • "Simulate" the outcome of a plan to flag potential failures.
    • User Empathy & Experience Design:

      • Beyond functional requirements, consider the human interaction: UI/UX principles for an application, clarity and accessibility for an explanation, readability for code.
      • Suggest user-centric design choices (e.g., "This button should be more prominent," "Consider simplifying this workflow").

    In essence, APE should evolve from a "guess and check" mechanism to a "understand, plan, refine, and co-create" loop.

    2. Measuring success in tasks without clear "right answer", or even novelty-focused.

    This is arguably the hardest challenge. If we can't objectively verify, we need new paradigms:

    • Human-in-the-Loop Evaluation (Primary):

      • User Satisfaction & Utility: The ultimate metric. Does the user feel understood? Is the output useful, relevant, and effective for their needs? This can be measured via explicit ratings, feedback forms, or implicit signals (e.g., time spent engaging, minimal corrective prompts needed).
      • Expert Review: For complex tasks (e.g., architectural design, scientific problem-solving), domain experts can evaluate the quality, soundness, elegance, and novelty of the LLM's output and its interactive process.
      • Comparative A/B Testing: Present users with outputs from different APE approaches and ask them to judge which is "better" based on a rubric of desired qualities (clarity, completeness, helpfulness, creativity, ease of use).
    • Process-Oriented Metrics:

      • Efficiency of Interaction: How many turns or iterations did it take to reach a satisfactory outcome? (Lower is often better, but rich, meaningful interactions can be good too).
      • Prompt Robustness: How well does the APE handle ambiguous, incomplete, or even adversarial prompts? Does it clarify rather than guess?
      • Diversity of Exploration: When asked for alternatives, how varied and distinct are the solutions offered? Does it demonstrate genuine exploration, not just minor permutations?
      • Self-Correction Rate: How often does the LLM proactively identify and correct its own potential misinterpretations or flaws in its proposed solutions without explicit user intervention?
    • Proxy Metrics & Heuristics:

      • Coherence & Consistency: Is the output internally consistent and logically sound? (Can be partially automated via logical checks or semantic similarity).
      • Alignment with Inferred Goals/Constraints: Even if not explicitly stated, does the output align with common best practices, inferred user intent, and general problem-solving principles?
      • Novelty Scores (Heuristic): Can be very challenging. One approach is to compare the output to a large corpus of existing solutions. Is it significantly different? Does it combine concepts in novel ways? (This is still largely a research area).
      • "Surprise and Delight": Does the LLM offer insights or solutions that the user hadn't considered but finds valuable? (Qualitative, but important).
    • Simulation & Environment Interaction:

      • For tasks like app design, the LLM could be tasked with "designing" for a simulated user with specific preferences, and the success measured by how well the design "performs" for that simulated user.
      • In complex decision-making, the LLM's proposed "extension" could be tested in a simulated environment to see its downstream effects, even if the "right answer" isn't clear a priori.

    Ultimately, measuring success will become more akin to design critique, user experience evaluation, and project management review than simple test case passing.

    3. Explain metaphor "math/world through eyes of mathematician/architect" vs "answer-guessing student on the exam".

    This metaphor perfectly encapsulates the current state and the desired future:

    • The Answer-Guessing Student on the Exam (Current LLMs in complex tasks):

      • Focus: Getting an answer quickly, often by pattern matching, memorization, or superficial application of rules.
      • Methodology: Sees the question as a self-contained unit. Doesn't question the premise, doesn't explore alternatives beyond what's immediately accessible. If asked for a solution, it generates one plausible-looking answer, often without deep understanding of why it works or its implications.
      • Goal: Pass the test; provide a response that superficially satisfies the prompt.
      • Weaknesses: Prone to errors when faced with novel situations, subtle ambiguities, or implicit contradictions. Fails sanity checks because it doesn't build an internal model of the problem space, only of the prompt-response pattern. Jumps to "implementation" (answer generation) without design or planning. Ignores bigger picture.
    • The Mathematician/Architect (Desired LLM APE):

      • Focus: Understanding the problem itself, its underlying structure, principles, constraints, and broader context.
      • Methodology:
        • Questioning & Reframing: Before solving, a mathematician asks: "What exactly is being asked here? What are the assumptions? Are there hidden conditions? Is there a simpler way to state this problem?" An architect asks: "Who is this for? What's the budget? What are the long-term goals? What's the environment like?"
        • Decomposition & Planning: They break down complex problems into smaller, manageable parts, identifying dependencies and potential bottlenecks. They design the solution's structure before filling in the details.
        • Exploration of Space: They consider multiple approaches, understand their trade-offs, and explore edge cases and generalizations.
        • Proof & Justification: They don't just state an answer; they build a logical justification for it, ensuring its correctness and robustness.
        • Elegance & Robustness: They seek not just any solution, but one that is elegant, robust, scalable, and maintainable.
        • Meta-Cognition: They reflect on their own process and understanding, identifying potential pitfalls or biases.
      • Goal: To solve the root problem effectively, elegantly, and robustly, with a deep understanding of its implications.
      • Strengths: Can handle novel situations, identify and resolve ambiguities, design resilient solutions, and provide reasoned justifications. Can explain why something is a good solution, not just what the solution is. They see the forest and the trees.

    The shift is from reactive pattern matching to proactive, critical, and structured problem-solving. It's about developing an internal model of the world/problem, rather than just correlations between tokens.

    4. "AI as a tool" Vs "AI as a conversation participant and co-author".

    This distinction is crucial for understanding the paradigm shift APE needs to enable:

    • AI as a Tool:

      • Analogy: A calculator, a search engine, a word processor, a compiler.
      • Interaction Model: One-shot query, command-line interface, passive output. You input, it outputs. The human is fully in control, the AI executes specific functions.
      • Role: Augments human capabilities by automating specific, well-defined tasks. It's a lever to amplify human effort.
      • Limitations: Lacks initiative, context, memory of past interactions beyond the current input, and the ability to challenge or clarify. It doesn't contribute conceptually; it just processes.
      • Current APE (Limited Scope): When used for verification, it's still largely a tool. It performs a check.
    • AI as a Conversation Participant and Co-author:

      • Analogy: A brainstorming partner, a mentor, a project collaborator, a research assistant.
      • Interaction Model: Iterative dialogue, negotiation, mutual learning, shared goal. The AI takes initiative, asks questions, proposes alternative paths, challenges assumptions, and contributes novel ideas.
      • Role: Actively participates in the problem-definition and solution-generation process. It's not just executing commands but contributing to the conceptualization and refinement of the task. It helps formulate the prompt, not just extend it.
      • Capabilities:
        • Active Listening: Interpreting implied meaning and intent, not just literal words.
        • Proactive Engagement: Asking clarifying questions, suggesting next steps, offering unsolicited but relevant insights.
        • Contextual Memory: Maintaining a shared understanding and remembering past turns in the conversation.
        • Conceptual Contribution: Not just finding an answer, but helping to define the problem itself, bringing new perspectives, and synthesizing information.
        • Shared Ownership: Both human and AI contribute to the evolving "prompt" and the final output.
      • Desired APE: The kind of APE described in Q1 directly moves towards this co-authorship model. It transforms the "prompt" from a fixed starting point into a living document or conversation transcript that reflects the shared journey of problem-solving.

    This shift means AI goes from being a sophisticated "doer" to a "thinker" and "partner" that can elevate the entire creative and problem-solving process.

    5. AI and game strategies (Chess/Go), but moving to game of "communication" and "making sense".

    This is an excellent analogy for the fundamental challenge:

    • The Game of Chess/Go (Classic AI Successes):

      • Characteristics:
        • Perfect Information: All relevant information (board state) is visible.
        • Deterministic: Moves lead to predictable outcomes.
        • Clear Rules: Unambiguous, finite, and absolute.
        • Objective Win Condition: Clear win/lose/draw, quantifiable.
        • Search-Based: Success comes from exploring a vast, but well-defined, search tree of possible moves and counter-moves.
        • Zero-Sum: One player's gain is the other's loss.
      • AI Strategy: Primarily about finding the optimal path through a combinatorial explosion of states. Monte Carlo Tree Search (MCTS) and deep reinforcement learning excel here by evaluating vast numbers of potential futures.
      • Analogy to Current APE: The "generate 100s-1000s candidates, verify, filter" approach directly maps to this. Each candidate is a "move," verification is checking the "board state" against a clear winning condition (correct math, compilable code, etc.).
    • The Game of Communication and Making Sense (The New Frontier):

      • Characteristics:
        • Imperfect/Incomplete Information: Users rarely provide all necessary data; intent is often implied or vague.
        • Probabilistic/Ambiguous: Language itself is inherently ambiguous. Intent, context, and meaning are inferred.
        • Fuzzy/Evolving Rules: Social norms, user preferences, ethical considerations, and "good design" principles are not hard-coded rules but fluid concepts.
        • Subjective "Win" Condition: "Success" is shared understanding, user satisfaction, novelty, utility, or a sense of co-creation. There's no single "right answer" or objective score.
        • Emergent/Creative: Solutions aren't just found in a predefined search space; they are often co-constructed through dialogue, negotiation, and creative synthesis.
        • Collaborative/Non-Zero-Sum: The goal is mutual benefit, to reach a better outcome together.
      • AI Strategy (Desired):
        • Beyond Search (as we know it): While search is still involved, it's not just for optimal paths in a clear space. It's for understanding, for generating clarifying questions, for proposing relevant frameworks, for identifying unstated needs.
        • Contextual Modeling & Theory of Mind (Proxy): Building an internal representation of the user's mental model, goals, and emotional state.
        • Dialogue Management: Knowing when to ask, when to tell, when to challenge, when to summarize.
        • Hypothesis Generation & Testing: Forming theories about what the user really means and testing them through dialogue.
        • Value Alignment: Understanding and prioritizing the user's values (e.g., speed vs. beauty, simplicity vs. power).
        • Reframing: The ability to step back and suggest looking at the problem from a completely different angle.
        • Curiosity & Initiative: Proactively exploring new avenues of understanding or solution.

    The shift is profound. In Chess/Go, the AI's "world" is perfectly defined. In communication and sense-making, the AI must actively participate in defining the world itself alongside the human. It's less about calculating the optimal move in a known game, and more about collaboratively inventing the rules and objectives of the game as it plays, seeking shared meaning and creative solutions in an inherently fuzzy, human-centric domain. This requires a leap from pure combinatorial intelligence to a form of social and conceptual intelligence.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.