Skip to content
The Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· Google LMArena Human Preference 140K

When working with the architecture of a large language models what does the data…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Metallama-4-scout-17b-16e-instruct’s answer.
  1. User

    When working with the architecture of a large language models what does the data transferred from layer to layer look like? Does the organization of the data of matter?

  2. Assistant

    When working with the architecture of large language models (LLMs), the data transferred from layer to layer is primarily in the form of tensors.

    A tensor is a multi-dimensional array of numerical values. Think of it like:

    • A scalar (0-D tensor) is a single number.
    • A vector (1-D tensor) is a list of numbers.
    • A matrix (2-D tensor) is a table of numbers.
    • A 3-D tensor is a cube of numbers.
    • And so on for higher dimensions.

    In the context of LLMs, specifically Transformer-based models, these tensors represent the processed information at each stage of the model.

    What the Data Transferred from Layer to Layer Looks Like:

    The data is almost exclusively composed of floating-point numbers (e.g., float32, bfloat16, or float16 for memory/speed efficiency).

    Let's break down the typical flow and tensor shapes:

    1. Input Layer (Embeddings):

      • Initial Input: Raw text (e.g., "The quick brown fox").
      • Tokenization: Text is converted into numerical tokens (e.g., [1, 54, 234, 65, 98]).
      • Embedding Lookup: Each token ID is looked up in an embedding matrix, converting it into a dense vector representation. Positional encodings (representing token order) are often added here.
      • Data Shape: (batch_size, sequence_length, embedding_dim)
        • batch_size: Number of input sequences processed simultaneously (e.g., 32 sentences).
        • sequence_length: Number of tokens in each sequence (e.g., 512 tokens).
        • embedding_dim: The dimensionality of the vector representation for each token (e.g., 768 for BERT-base, 1024 for BERT-large). This is also often referred to as d_model or model_dim.
      • Content: Numerical vectors where each value in the embedding_dim dimension represents some learned feature or aspect of the token in its context.
    2. Inside a Transformer Block:

      • A Transformer block typically consists of Multi-Head Self-Attention and a Feed-Forward Network, usually with residual connections and layer normalization.
      • Input to Multi-Head Attention: (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim)
      • Internal Query, Key, Value (Q, K, V) Matrices: The input is linearly transformed into Q, K, V. Before splitting into heads, their shape is still (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim).
      • After Multi-Head Split (Conceptual): For computation, these are often reshaped to (batch_size, num_heads, sequence_length, head_dim), where head_dim = model_dim / num_heads.
      • Output of Multi-Head Attention: After attention calculations and concatenation of head outputs, the result is again transformed back to (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim). This tensor now contains information where each token's representation has been updated by attending to other tokens in the sequence.
      • Input to Feed-Forward Network (FFN): (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim) (this is usually the output of the attention mechanism + residual connection + layer norm).
      • Internal FFN Layers: The FFN typically expands the dimension (e.g., model_dim to 4 * model_dim) and then projects it back down.
      • Output of Feed-Forward Network: (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim). This tensor has further processed the contextualized information.
      • Data Content: As data moves through these layers, the numerical values in the model_dim dimension increasingly represent higher-level, more abstract, and contextually rich features of each position in the sequence.
    3. Output Layer (Logits):

      • Input: After passing through multiple Transformer blocks, the final tensor still has the shape (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim).
      • Linear Projection: A final linear layer transforms the model_dim into the size of the vocabulary.
      • Data Shape: (batch_size, sequence_length, vocab_size)
        • vocab_size: The total number of unique tokens in the model's vocabulary (e.g., 50,000).
      • Content: These are "logits" – unnormalized scores for each possible next token at each position in the sequence.
      • Softmax (optional, usually during training/inference setup): A softmax function is typically applied to these logits to convert them into probabilities. The shape remains the same, but the values now sum to 1 across the vocab_size dimension for each position.

    In summary, the intermediate data looks like a continuously transforming stream of multi-dimensional arrays of floating-point numbers, primarily maintaining a shape related to (batch_size, sequence_length, feature_dimension).

    Does the Organization of the Data Matter?

    Absolutely, the organization of the data matters immensely! It's not just a collection of numbers; their arrangement dictates their meaning and how they interact.

    Here's why organization is critical:

    1. Mathematical Compatibility:

      • Deep learning operations (matrix multiplications, additions, convolutions, etc.) are highly sensitive to tensor shapes. For example, to multiply two matrices, their inner dimensions must match. If A is (m, n) and B is (p, q), for A * B to be valid, n must equal p.
      • Every layer in an LLM is designed to expect input of a specific shape and produce output of a specific shape. Any mismatch will lead to errors.
    2. Preserving Semantic Meaning:

      • Batch Dimension (batch_size): Ensures that operations are performed independently for each sequence in the batch. Swapping sequences within the batch would make no sense.
      • Sequence Dimension (sequence_length): Maintains the order of tokens within a sequence. This is fundamentally important for language understanding. "Dog bites man" means something different than "Man bites dog." Positional encodings explicitly inject this order information.
      • Feature Dimension (embedding_dim / model_dim): Each position in this dimension corresponds to a specific learned feature or representation component. The model learns what each of these features means. If you arbitrarily permute values within this dimension, you completely scramble the learned representation, making the model output gibberish. Each number at a specific index in model_dim contributes to a specific abstract characteristic of the token.
    3. Computational Efficiency:

      • Modern deep learning frameworks (like PyTorch, TensorFlow) and hardware (GPUs) are highly optimized for computations on contiguous blocks of memory, which tensors inherently provide.
      • Specific memory layouts (e.g., row-major vs. column-major) can impact performance, though frameworks usually handle this under the hood.
    4. Model Design and Interpretability:

      • The consistent flow of (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim) across Transformer blocks simplifies the architecture design. Each block can be thought of as processing the same "type" of information, just at a deeper level of abstraction.
      • Understanding the shape and meaning of tensors at different stages is crucial for debugging, analyzing, and potentially interpreting what the model has learned.

    In essence, the precise organization of these tensors is the language through which the neural network operates, encodes meaning, and learns complex patterns. Without it, the entire system would collapse into meaningless numerical noise.

  3. User

    It’s it the KV cash that’s in the forward pass? I’m confused on what changes going from layer to layer

  4. Assistant

    That's an excellent point of confusion, as the KV cache is a specific optimization that can easily be misunderstood in the broader context of the forward pass. Let's clarify both:

    Is the KV Cache in the Forward Pass?

    Yes, but specifically during autoregressive inference (generation), not during the initial training or a standard, single-pass forward computation for tasks like classification or sequence-to-sequence translation where the entire output sequence is generated in one go.

    Here's the breakdown:

    1. Standard Forward Pass (Training or Batch Inference):

      • During training or when you pass an entire input sequence to get an output (e.g., classifying a text, translating a sentence where the model predicts all output tokens in parallel), the KV cache is not typically used.
      • Each self-attention layer recomputes the Key (K) and Value (V) matrices for all tokens in the input sequence from scratch for every forward pass.
      • The data flowing between layers is just the (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim) tensor, updated by attention and FFN.
    2. Autoregressive Inference (Token-by-Token Generation):

      • This is where the KV cache shines. When an LLM generates text (e.g., "Write me a poem about dogs"), it typically generates one token at a time:
        • Predict "The"
        • Then predict "quick" given "The"
        • Then predict "brown" given "The quick"
        • And so on.
      • The Problem Without KV Cache: For each new token, the model would have to recompute the K and V for all previous tokens in the sequence in every self-attention layer. This is computationally very expensive, especially for long sequences.
      • The Solution (KV Cache):
        • When the first token is processed, its K and V values (from each attention head in each layer) are computed and stored in memory (the KV cache).
        • When the second token is processed, the model computes its K and V values.
        • Then, for the attention calculation, it concatenates the newly computed K and V for the current token with the cached K and V from all previous tokens. This creates the full K and V matrices for the entire current sequence without recomputing the old parts.
        • This process continues: for each subsequent token, its K and V are computed and added to the cache, and attention is performed over the expanded cached K and V.
      • So, yes, the KV cache is used within the forward pass during autoregressive decoding to optimize the attention mechanism by reusing previously computed K and V values. It's an important optimization for efficiency, not a fundamental change to the data's content or meaning, but rather to how that content is made available for the attention computation.

    What Changes Going from Layer to Layer?

    This is the core of how deep learning models like LLMs work! The data's shape often remains the same, but its content and level of abstraction/contextualization change dramatically.

    Imagine it like refining raw ore into a finished product, or analyzing a complex document:

    1. Initial Layer (Input Embeddings): (batch_size, sequence_length, embedding_dim)

      • Content: Each vector (embedding_dim) primarily represents the base meaning of a single token, plus its position in the sequence. It's like raw vocabulary definitions with some sense of order.
      • Example: For "The dog barked loudly", vector_dog might encode properties like "noun," "animal," "canine."
    2. Inside a Transformer Layer (e.g., Layer 1, Layer 2, ..., Layer N): (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim)

      • The data maintains the same shape (each sequence has the same number of tokens, each token has a vector of the same model_dim).

      • What changes? The numerical values within each token's vector are transformed to incorporate more complex and contextual information.

      • Self-Attention Mechanism:

        • This is where each token's vector representation is updated by "looking at" and "mixing in" information from all other tokens in the sequence.
        • It identifies relationships (e.g., "dog" is the subject of "barked").
        • Change: After attention, vector_dog doesn't just mean "dog" anymore; it now also contains information about what the dog is doing and what is happening around it. It's a "contextualized dog" vector.
        • Example (Layer 1 after Attention): vector_dog now subtly encodes that it's the subject of an action, vector_barked encodes it's an action performed by an animal, vector_loudly encodes it's an adverb modifying an action.
      • Feed-Forward Network (FFN):

        • This part processes each token's vector independently (though the weights are shared across tokens). It applies non-linear transformations to further refine the contextual information received from attention.
        • It allows the model to learn more complex patterns and features from the blended information.
        • Change: The values within each model_dim vector are further adjusted to represent even higher-level features and combinations of information.
        • Example (Layer 1 after FFN): The refined vector_dog might now more strongly activate features related to "performer of action," and vector_barked to "past tense action," etc.
      • Residual Connections and Layer Normalization:

        • Residual Connections: Crucially, the output of a sub-layer (attention or FFN) is added to its input. This allows information to flow directly through the network, preventing vanishing gradients and enabling the model to learn "residual" updates rather than completely re-learning the representation at each step. It ensures that the basic information from previous layers is preserved and enhanced, not overwritten.
        • Layer Normalization: Normalizes the activations within each layer, helping to stabilize training.
    3. Progression Through Deeper Layers:

      • Each successive layer refines this contextual understanding.
      • Layer N-1 (e.g., mid-layers): Vectors here might encode complex grammatical structures, semantic roles (agent, patient), sentiment, or abstract relationships between concepts. vector_dog might now encode not just "subject of barked," but also "happy dog" or "threatening dog" based on other implicit information from the sequence.
      • Final Layer (before projection to logits): The vectors here represent the most abstract, holistic, and task-specific understanding of each token within the entire sequence's context. This is the model's ultimate internal representation before it makes a prediction.

    In essence, the data doesn't change its fundamental organization (it's always a tensor of contextualized token representations), but its meaning and the complexity of information it encapsulates evolve from simple word definitions to highly abstract, context-aware features. Each layer acts as a sophisticated filter and mixer, transforming the input into a richer, more nuanced representation, building up a hierarchy of learned features.

  5. User

    In your example vector_dog might encode properties like “ noun”, “ animal”, “ canine”, do layers look at the organization of those properties? As in noun shows up first which means it has more influence compared to canine? Or do they all carry the same weight and it’s just information about the token?

  6. Assistant

    That's a fantastic and insightful question, as it gets to the heart of how dense representations (embeddings) work in deep learning.

    The short answer is: No, the individual "properties" like "noun," "animal," or "canine" are not explicitly assigned to fixed positions within the embedding_dim vector in a way that index 0 always means "noun" and index 1 always means "animal," giving it more influence just by its position.

    Here's a more detailed explanation:

    How Learned Embeddings Work (Dense & Distributed Representations)

    When we talk about an embedding_dim vector (e.g., 768 dimensions), it's not like a checklist where each item has a predefined slot. Instead, it's a dense, distributed representation.

    1. No Fixed Slots for Semantic Features:

      • Unlike "one-hot" encodings (where position X is "noun", position Y is "verb"), the dimensions of a learned embedding vector do not have a pre-assigned, human-interpretable meaning.
      • For example, embedding_vector[0] doesn't inherently mean "noun-ness," and embedding_vector[1] doesn't mean "animal-ness."
      • The model doesn't explicitly learn "dog is a noun" and encode it as a 1 in a "noun" slot.
    2. Meaning Emerges from the Entire Vector:

      • The "meaning" of a word (or token) is encoded by the entire pattern of numerical values across all dimensions of its embedding vector.
      • Different "properties" like "noun," "animal," "canine," "action-performer," "animate," etc., are not localized to single dimensions but are distributed across many dimensions.
      • For instance, "noun-ness" might be represented by a specific subtle configuration of values across dimensions 5, 12, 87, 203, and 500, rather than being concentrated in just one.
    3. Learned Relationships and Context:

      • The model learns these embeddings by being trained on vast amounts of text. Words that appear in similar contexts will have similar embedding vectors.
      • If "dog," "cat," and "elephant" frequently appear in contexts describing animals, their vectors will cluster together in the high-dimensional space, indicating their semantic similarity (i.e., they are all animals).
      • The "noun" property emerges because "dog" appears in sentence structures typical of nouns (e.g., subject of a verb, object of a preposition).

    How Layers "Look At" and Use These Properties

    The subsequent layers (attention, Feed-Forward Networks) don't "look at" the organization in terms of fixed positions having more influence. Instead, they operate on the entire vector and learn to extract and combine the relevant distributed information.

    1. Weight Matrices are Key:

      • Every linear transformation (which is at the heart of attention and FFNs) involves multiplying the input vector by a weight matrix.
      • This weight matrix has learned patterns. For example, a particular row in the weight matrix might effectively act as a "filter" or "feature detector." When activated strongly by an input vector, it might indicate the presence of "noun-like" or "animal-like" qualities in that input vector, regardless of which specific dimensions contributed to that activation.
    2. All Dimensions Contribute, But Influence Varies:

      • All dimensions of the embedding_dim vector are fed into the next layer. Therefore, all dimensions carry information and potentially contribute to the subsequent computations.
      • However, the influence or "weight" that any specific dimension (or combination of dimensions) has on the output of the next layer is determined by the learned weights of that next layer.
      • If a certain pattern of values across a subset of dimensions (e.g., related to "animality") is highly predictive or important for the model's task (e.g., predicting the next word), the weights of the next layer will adjust to give that pattern more "attention" or influence.
    3. Dynamic Contextualization (Self-Attention):

      • Crucially, the self-attention mechanism doesn't just look at a single vector in isolation. It computes how each token's vector relates to all other token vectors in the sequence.
      • The "query," "key," and "value" transformations are learned to highlight relevant aspects for contextual understanding.
      • So, when vector_dog interacts with vector_barked, the attention mechanism focuses on the aspects of vector_dog that are relevant to being an "actor" and the aspects of vector_barked that are relevant to being an "action." This blending is dynamic and context-dependent.

    In summary:

    • No fixed, pre-assigned meaning to specific indices within the embedding_dim vector (e.g., index 0 isn't hardcoded as "noun").
    • Properties are distributed across many dimensions of the vector.
    • All dimensions contribute information, but their influence on subsequent computations is determined by the learned weights of the layers that process them. These weights learn to extract and combine relevant patterns from the entire vector to form higher-level representations.
    • The model learns what patterns of values across the vector correspond to properties like "noun" or "animal," and it uses these learned patterns, not their arbitrary position, to process the information.
  7. User

    Is the models vocabulary carry forward layer to layer or is it only calculated in the final layer before logit?

  8. Assistant

    No, the model's explicit vocabulary list (the mapping of token IDs to actual words/subword units) is not carried forward layer-to-layer in the form of discrete token IDs.

    Instead, here's how the vocabulary interacts with the layers:

    1. At the Very Beginning (Input Layer - Embedding):

      • Vocabulary's Role: The model starts with raw text. This text is first converted into numerical token IDs using a pre-defined vocabulary (e.g., "cat" maps to ID 123, "dog" maps to ID 456).
      • Transformation: These discrete token IDs are then passed to an embedding layer. This layer looks up each token ID in an embedding matrix (a large lookup table). Each row in this matrix corresponds to a token in the vocabulary and contains a dense, continuous vector (e.g., 768 floating-point numbers).
      • What's Passed to the First Transformer Block: What actually flows from the embedding layer to the first Transformer block is this tensor of dense, floating-point embedding vectors, not the original token IDs. The shape is (batch_size, sequence_length, embedding_dim).
      • Analogy: Imagine you have a dictionary. At the start, you look up words in the dictionary to understand their core meaning. Once you understand the meaning, you don't carry the dictionary page-by-page through your thought process; you carry the concept or idea of the word.
    2. Through the Intermediate Layers (Transformer Blocks):

      • Vocabulary is Absent: As the data (these dense embedding vectors) passes through the Transformer blocks (self-attention, feed-forward networks, residual connections, layer norms), it remains in the form of (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim) tensors of floating-point numbers.
      • Continuous Transformation: Each layer transforms these continuous vectors, adding context, refining semantic meaning, and building higher-level representations. The numbers in these tensors no longer directly map to "word A" or "word B"; they represent abstract features and relationships learned from the input sequence.
      • No Discrete IDs: There are no discrete token IDs or pointers back to the original vocabulary within these intermediate tensors.
    3. At the Very End (Output Layer - Logit Projection):

      • Vocabulary Re-enters: After the final Transformer block, the model has its ultimate contextualized representation of each token in the sequence (still a (batch_size, sequence_length, model_dim) tensor).
      • Projection to Logits: To make a prediction (e.g., "what's the next word?"), this final model_dim vector for each position is passed through a final linear layer (often called a "projection head" or "unembedding layer"). This layer's weight matrix has dimensions (model_dim, vocab_size).
      • Output: The result is a tensor of (batch_size, sequence_length, vocab_size) containing "logits" (unnormalized scores). Each value logit[i][j][k] represents the model's confidence that the token at position j in sequence i should be the token corresponding to vocab_id k.
      • Vocabulary's Role Again: It's at this point that the model "re-references" its vocabulary to know what each vocab_id k actually stands for, allowing it to select the most probable next word or assign probabilities to all possible words.

    In essence:

    • The vocabulary is like the interface at the input and output boundaries of the model.
    • Inside the model, all computations operate on continuous, dense numerical representations (embeddings and their transformed versions), which are abstract rather than discrete token IDs. The information derived from the vocabulary is encoded in these continuous vectors, but the explicit vocabulary list itself is not passed along.
  9. User

    When the raw text is mapped to an ID it only maps, the prompt, and not all words in the vocabulary?

  10. Assistant

    You've hit on a very important distinction! Let's clarify:

    Yes, you are correct: when the raw text is mapped to an ID, it only maps the words/subword units present in the input prompt (or whatever text you feed the model), not all words in the entire vocabulary list.

    Here's a breakdown of how it works:

    1. The Vocabulary is a Fixed Reference List (Pre-Built):

      • Imagine the model has a massive internal "dictionary" or "lookup table." This is its vocabulary.
      • This vocabulary is created during the model's training phase by analyzing a huge corpus of text. It contains all the unique words, subword units (like "##ing", "un##", "play##"), and special tokens (like [CLS], [SEP], [PAD]) that the model has learned to recognize.
      • Each item in this vocabulary is assigned a unique numerical ID (e.g., "the" -> 1, "a" -> 2, "cat" -> 1234, "##ing" -> 5678).
      • This entire list (e.g., 50,000 items) is static and pre-determined before you even run the model for inference. It does not change during the forward pass.
    2. Tokenization: Mapping the Input Prompt to IDs:

      • When you provide a raw text prompt (e.g., "The quick brown fox."), the very first step is tokenization.
      • The tokenizer takes your prompt and breaks it down into individual words or subword units that exist in the model's pre-defined vocabulary.
      • For each of these words/subword units from your prompt, the tokenizer looks it up in the vocabulary and gets its corresponding numerical ID.
      • So, if your prompt is "The cat sat on the mat.", and assuming these words are in the vocabulary, it might be converted to something like: [1, 1234, 5678, 9101, 1, 1121].
      • Crucially, only the tokens present in your specific input text are converted to IDs at this stage. You are not generating IDs for every single word in the entire 50,000-word vocabulary; that would be unnecessary and computationally prohibitive.
    3. Embedding Layer: Converting IDs to Dense Vectors:

      • These numerical IDs (e.g., [1, 1234, 5678, ...]) are then fed into the embedding layer.
      • The embedding layer is essentially another lookup table. It has a row for every ID in the vocabulary, and each row contains a dense vector of floating-point numbers (the embedding).
      • For each ID it receives, it fetches the corresponding embedding vector.
      • So, the IDs [1, 1234, 5678, ...] are transformed into a sequence of dense vectors: [vector_1, vector_1234, vector_5678, ...].
      • This sequence of dense vectors is what gets passed to the first Transformer layer. From this point onward, the model operates entirely on these continuous floating-point vectors, not on discrete token IDs.

    In summary:

    • The vocabulary is a fixed, pre-existing reference map that the model uses.
    • The tokenization process uses this vocabulary to translate your specific input text (the prompt) into a sequence of numerical IDs.
    • Only the tokens within your prompt are converted to IDs.
    • These IDs are then immediately converted into dense numerical vectors by the embedding layer, and it's these vectors that flow through the subsequent layers of the LLM.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.