Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-pro· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

How viable is it to beat gen 2 Pokemon games with only capturing pokemon in one specific…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Amazon Novaamazon-nova-experimental-chat-05-14’s answer.
  1. User

    How viable is it to beat gen 2 Pokemon games with only capturing pokemon in one specific time?

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Excellent and very creative question! The viability of beating a Gen 2 Pokémon game (Gold, Silver, or Crystal) while only capturing Pokémon at one specific time is highly viable, but it is an extreme challenge that requires meticulous planning.

    This is a fantastic challenge run concept, turning the game into a strategic puzzle before you even start the major battles. Let's break down the viability, the strategy, and a potential game plan.

    The Core Concept & Its Implications

    First, let's define the rules as I interpret them:

    1. The Starter is a Gift: You get your starter Pokémon as a gift, not a capture. It is exempt from the rule and is your most crucial team member.
    2. One "Capture Session": You pick one single moment in the game to use your Poké Balls. This could be limited to one specific patch of grass, one cave floor, or one body of water. Once you leave that area or decide you're "done," you cannot throw another Poké Ball for the rest of the game.
    3. Gift Pokémon are Key: Pokémon given to you by NPCs (Togepi Egg, Eevee from Bill, Kenya the Spearow, Shuckle in Cianwood) are not "captured" with a Poké Ball. A common-sense ruling would be to allow these, as they are crucial for viability. You can set your own rules on this, but allowing them makes the run much more manageable.
    4. Static Encounters Count: Encounters like Sudowoodo, Snorlax, and the Red Gyarados would count as your "one time" capture event.

    The Biggest Hurdles You'll Face

    This run's difficulty doesn't come from battling, but from resource management and foresight.

    1. HM Slaves: This is the #1 obstacle. You need Surf, Strength, Fly, Cut, Flash, and Whirlpool to navigate the world. Your small, permanent team must be able to cover all of these, or you will literally be unable to progress.
    2. Limited Type Diversity: You are stuck with the types of Pokémon you catch in your one session. If you get a bad set of encounters, you could have a massive, unfixable weakness to a late-game Gym Leader or Elite Four member.
    3. No Replacements: If a key team member (especially your only Surf or Strength user) faints right before you need them, you can't just go catch another one. You have to backtrack to a Pokémon Center, which can be a huge pain.
    4. The Grind: With a smaller team, your Pokémon will likely be over-leveled, which is good. However, you'll be leaning on them heavily, and the Elite Four will be a war of attrition on your PP and healing items.

    The Strategy: How to Make it Viable

    Success hinges entirely on when and where you choose to have your capture session.

    Best Starter Choice

    Totodile is almost certainly the best choice. Feraligatr has a fantastic Attack stat, a great STAB move in Surf, and an incredible HM pool. It can learn Cut, Strength, Surf, and Whirlpool, single-handedly covering the majority of your essential HMs. Chikorita is too weak offensively, and while Cyndaquil is great, its HM compatibility is poor.

    Best "One Time" Capture Event: The Lake of Rage

    The single best strategy is to use the static Red Gyarados encounter as the start of your "capture session."

    Here’s why this is the optimal choice:

    • Guaranteed Powerhouse: You get a guaranteed Level 30 Gyarados with great stats. It isn't a random encounter; you know it will be there.
    • Excellent Timing: You encounter it right after the 7th Gym, meaning you've already proven you can handle most of Johto with just your starter and any gift Pokémon.
    • Perfect Location: After catching Gyarados, you are standing in a location with multiple encounter options for the rest of your session:
      • Surfing in the Lake of Rage: You can find Magikarp and more Gyarados.
      • Fishing in the Lake of Rage: With a Good Rod, you can find Poliwag and Magikarp. Poliwag is a phenomenal choice, as it can learn Surf, Strength, and Whirlpool.
      • Grass on Route 43: You can find Flaaffy, Girafarig, Pidgeotto, and Venomoth. Flaaffy (into Ampharos) is an amazing Electric-type for taking on the Elite Four.

    Example Walkthrough for a "Lake of Rage Capture" Run

    This is how a viable run would look:

    1. Start the Game: Choose Totodile.

    2. Play through Early Johto: Use only your Totodile.

      • Receive the Togepi Egg from Prof. Elm's aide in Violet City. Hatch it.
      • Optionally, pick up Kenya the Spearow from the guard in the Route 36 gatehouse. This gives you an early Flyer.
      • Beat the first four gyms. This will be challenging, especially Whitney's Miltank. You will need to grind Totodile to a high level.
    3. Get the Eevee: In Goldenrod City, get the gift Eevee from Bill. DO NOT EVOLVE IT YET. Wait to see what your team needs most. Espeon (psychic), Jolteon (electric), or Vaporeon (water/HP) are all top-tier choices.

    4. Continue to Lake of Rage: Beat Morty, get the Surf HM, and teach it to Totodile/Croconaw. Clear the Team Rocket plot in the Mahogany Town base.

    5. THE CAPTURE SESSION:

      • Part 1: The Main Event. Go to the center of the Lake of Rage. Save your game. Battle and catch the Red Gyarados. Your "session" has now begun.
      • Part 2: Fill the Roster. Do not leave the area. Stay on Route 43/Lake of Rage.
        • Search the grass on Route 43 until you find a Flaaffy (or Mareep). Catch it. This is your answer to Lance's Gyarados and Charizard.
        • (Optional but Recommended) Use the Good Rod in the Lake of Rage to find and catch a Poliwag.
      • Once you have Gyarados and Flaaffy (and maybe Poliwag), your session is over. You can never use Poké Balls again.
    6. Assemble Your Final Team & Beat the Game:

      • Feraligatr: Your starter. The core of your team. (Surf, Strength, Ice Punch, Crunch/Slash).
      • Gyarados: Your secondary physical attacker. (Strength, Fly, Thrash/Hyper Beam).
      • Ampharos: Your special attacker. (Thunderbolt/Thunder, Fire Punch, Thunder Wave).
      • Togetic: A decent special attacker and support Pokémon. (Fly, Psychic, Solar Beam).
      • Eeveelution: Evolve your Eevee into whatever you need. With Ampharos, you probably don't need Jolteon. Espeon is a fantastic choice for its speed and power, covering Bruno's fighting types and Koga's poison types.
      • Your 6th Slot: This could be Kenya the Spearow (now a Fearow), the gift Shuckle, or the Poliwag you caught for dedicated HM use.

    With a team like Feraligatr, Gyarados, Ampharos, Espeon, and Togetic, you are more than equipped to handle the Elite Four and the Kanto post-game.

    Final Verdict

    It is absolutely viable to beat Gen 2 with a "single capture session."

    • Difficulty: 8/10. It's not for a first-time player. It requires immense patience and planning. The early game with just a starter is a tough grind.
    • Best Game: Pokémon Crystal is slightly better for this challenge due to the Move Tutor outside the Goldenrod Game Corner, who can teach your Pokémon Thunderbolt, Ice Beam, and Flamethrower.
    • Key to Success: Plan your HM users, abuse the gift Pokémon, and choose the Lake of Rage as your capture point.

    This sounds like an incredibly rewarding challenge. Good luck if you decide to try it

  3. User

    No I mean more like only capturing the pokemon that available in specific time. Like only using morning, day or night pokemon.

  4. Gemini Assistant

    Ah, thank you for the clarification! That makes for an even more interesting and thematic challenge run.

    The concept is: Beat the game by only capturing Pokémon that are available during a single, chosen time of day (Morning, Day, or Night).

    This is 100% viable and an excellent way to experience Gen 2! The game's day/night system was a revolutionary feature, and this challenge forces you to engage with it deeply. The difficulty will vary dramatically based on which time you choose.

    Let's establish some ground rules for this run, which you can adjust to your liking:

    • Rule 1: Choose Your Time. Before you start, you commit to either Morning (4:00 AM - 9:59 AM), Day (10:00 AM - 5:59 PM), or Night (6:00 PM - 3:59 AM).
    • Rule 2: Time-Locked Captures. You can only throw a Poké Ball at a wild Pokémon if that species is available during your chosen time. This includes surfing and fishing encounters.
    • Rule 3: Gift Pokémon are Free. Your starter, the Togepi Egg, the gift Eevee, Kenya the Spearow, etc., are all allowed. They are essential for progression and not "captured" in the wild.
    • Rule 4: Static Encounters. Encounters like Sudowoodo, Snorlax, and the Red Gyarados are available 24/7. A fair ruling would be to allow them, as they are unique, one-time events. This makes the run much more manageable.

    Now, let's break down the viability of each time period.


    Option 1: The "Night-Only" Run (Thematic & Powerful)

    This is arguably the most fun and popular version of this challenge. The night introduces many unique and powerful Pokémon.

    • Key Pokémon Available: Hoothoot, Gastly, Zubat, Poliwag, Wooper, Spinarak. In Kanto, you get access to Murkrow, Misdreavus, and Houndour.
    • Team Strengths:
      • Excellent Special Attackers: Gengar is a top-tier powerhouse.
      • Great Type Diversity: You get Ghost, Poison, Flying, Water, and Ground types very early.
      • Solid HM Coverage: Poliwag can learn Surf, Strength, and Whirlpool. Wooper/Quagsire can learn Surf, Strength, and Flash. Zubat/Golbat can learn Fly. You are completely covered.
      • Dark-Types: This is the only time you can naturally get Dark-types (Murkrow, Houndour), giving you a great counter for the Psychic-type Elite Four member. You can also evolve your gift Eevee into Umbreon to fit the theme perfectly.
    • Team Weaknesses:
      • Lack of Fire-Types: Your only Fire-type is Houndour, which is only available very late in the game in Kanto. You'll need to rely on TMs like Fire Punch or your starter to handle Steel-types.
      • Few Fighting Counters: Without a strong, dedicated Psychic-type (besides the gift Espeon), you'll rely on Gengar's power or Noctowl's Flying-type moves to beat Bruno.
    • Viability Score: 9/10. Highly recommended.

    Example "Night-Only" Final Team:

    1. Starter: Any, but Feraligatr or Typhlosion work well.
    2. Noctowl: Your Flyer and a decent special wall.
    3. Gengar: Your ace special sweeper.
    4. Quagsire: A bulky Water/Ground type, immune to Electric.
    5. Umbreon: From the gift Eevee. A fantastic defensive wall.
    6. Houndoom: A late-game Fire/Dark sweeper to round out the team for the final battles.

    Option 2: The "Day-Only" Run (The Standard & Solid Choice)

    This feels the most like a "normal" playthrough, but with some key restrictions.

    • Key Pokémon Available: Pidgey, Rattata, Sentret, Psyduck, Abra, Machop, Geodude. Version exclusives like Growlithe (Gold) and Vulpix (Silver) are day-locked. Sunkern and Girafarig are also day-exclusive.
    • Team Strengths:
      • Classic Powerhouses: You have access to Alakazam, Machamp, Golem, and Arcanine/Ninetales. This is a very offensively-oriented set of options.
      • Excellent HM Coverage: Psyduck is an incredible HM user (Surf, Strength, Flash, Whirlpool). Machop can handle Strength. Pidgey can Fly. No issues here.
      • Strong Early Game: Access to Pokémon like Abra and Machop early on gives you a huge advantage.
    • Team Weaknesses:
      • No Ghost or Dark Types: You have zero answers to Psychic-types outside of brute force. Morty's Gym will be an absolute nightmare without a good counter, forcing you to rely on an over-leveled Normal-type or your starter. Will and Karen of the Elite Four will also be very challenging.
      • Less Thematic: Many of these are the "default" Pokémon, so the run might feel less unique than a Night-only run.
    • Viability Score: 8/10. A solid choice, but be prepared for Morty.

    Example "Day-Only" Final Team:

    1. Starter: Any.
    2. Pidgeot: Your reliable Flyer.
    3. Alakazam: Hyper-fast special sweeper.
    4. Machamp: Physical wallbreaker.
    5. Arcanine (Gold) / Ninetales (Silver): Your Fire-type.
    6. Psyduck/Golduck: Primarily for HMs, but still a decent Water-type. Or, use the static Snorlax for immense power.

    Option 3: The "Morning-Only" Run (The True Hard Mode)

    This is by far the most difficult and restrictive option. Very few Pokémon are exclusive to the morning.

    • Key Pokémon Available: Ledyba, Yanma. Many Pokémon like Pidgey and Rattata are simply more common in the morning but are also available during the day. For a true challenge, you'd only catch the morning exclusives.
    • Team Strengths:
      • ...Flying Types? Honestly, the pool of morning-exclusive Pokémon is incredibly shallow. Ledian is one of the worst fully-evolved Pokémon in the game, and Yanma cannot evolve into Yanmega until Gen 4.
      • Bragging Rights: Completing this run would be a true accomplishment.
    • Team Weaknesses:
      • Almost No Type Diversity: Your team will consist almost entirely of your starter, gift Pokémon, and static encounters. The wild Pokémon available are almost useless for a full playthrough.
      • Terrible HM Coverage: You would be 100% reliant on your starter (Feraligatr would be mandatory) and a static like Gyarados for your HMs.
      • The Grind: You'll be using a very small team, leading to a lot of grinding and an over-reliance on a few Pokémon.
    • Viability Score: 4/10. This is an extreme challenge that borders on not being fun. It's viable only because the gift/static Pokémon can carry you.

    Final Verdict & Recommendation

    The viability of a time-locked run is excellent, and it's a fantastic way to replay the game.

    • For a Fun, Thematic Challenge: Choose the Night-Only Run. It gives you a unique team, great type coverage, and forces you to use Pokémon you might normally overlook. It's the perfect balance of challenge and fun.
    • For a More "Classic" but Restricted Run: Choose the Day-Only Run. It's a bit easier than the Night run but presents its own major hurdle with Ghost and Psychic types.
    • For Expert Players Seeking Pain: Choose the Morning-Only Run. This is a self-imposed nightmare mode that will test your patience and your knowledge of the game's gift Pokémon.

    My personal recommendation is to do a Night-Only Run with Totodile as your starter. You'll have an incredible time building a team of creatures of the night to conquer Johto and Kanto. Good luck

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.