I don't want to modify changeFilterValue wich is used everywhere, perhaps create a new…
- User
I don't want to modify changeFilterValue wich is used everywhere, perhaps create a new method or a bigger removeFilterByColumnsToHide wich will do everything? (i can refactore later)
Assistant
You're right to be cautious about modifying
changeFilterValueif it's widely used. That's a good point about potential ripple effects. Let's explore the options of creating a new method or expandingremoveFilterByColumnsToHideto handle everything. I recommend the latter, expandingremoveFilterByColumnsToHide, as it keeps the logic contained within the specific context where it's needed.
✅ Solution: Expand
removeFilterByColumnsToHideThis approach encapsulates all the necessary steps within the method responsible for handling column visibility changes. It avoids modifying a core method like
changeFilterValueand keeps the logic localized.
🔧 Implementation Steps
-
Remove the Call to
gridService.changeFilterValue: Remove the existing call tothis.gridService.changeFilterValuewithinremoveFilterByColumnsToHide. We'll handle the filter updates directly. -
Inline the Filter Update Logic: Copy the filter update logic from
gridService.changeFilterValueintoremoveFilterByColumnsToHide. This will involve calling thefilterManagermethods directly. -
Conditionally Apply Reset/Refresh: Add logic to conditionally call
resetPageandrefreshRowsonly when necessary.
💻 Code Example
Here's how the modified
removeFilterByColumnsToHidemethod would look:private removeFilterByColumnsToHide(activeColumnsIds: string[], gridState: GridState): void { const hiddenColumns = new Set( this.originalListItems .filter((column) => !activeColumnsIds.includes(column.id.toString())) .map((column) => column.id.toString()), ); gridState.filterState.filters.ids .map((id) => gridState.filterState.filters.entities[id]) .forEach((filter) => { if (hiddenColumns.has(filter.id.toString())) { const changeFilterValueAction: ChangeFilteringAction = { id: filter.id, filterValue: { ...filter.value, value: filter.value.kind === 'multiple-discrete-value' ? [] : '', }, }; // Inline the logic from changeFilterValue this.store.state$ .pipe( take(1), concatMap((state) => this.filterManager.changeFilterValue(changeFilterValueAction, state)), concatMap((state) => this.filterManager.changeFilterOperation(changeFilterValueAction, state)), concatMap((state) => this.filterManager.applyFilters(state)), concatMap((state) => this.dataRowLoader.unselectAllRows(state)), // Conditionally reset and refresh concatMap((state) => { // Check if the filter change requires a reset/refresh // Example: Only reset/refresh if the filter affects pagination const shouldResetAndRefresh = filter.value.kind === 'range' || filter.value.kind === 'text'; if (!shouldResetAndRefresh) { return of(state); } return this.resetPage(state); }), concatMap((state) => { const shouldResetAndRefresh = filter.value.kind === 'range' || filter.value.kind === 'text'; if (!shouldResetAndRefresh) { return of(state); } return this.refreshRows(state); }), ) .subscribe((state) => this.commit(state)); } }); }
🧠 Explanation
- Encapsulation: All the logic related to handling filter updates due to column hiding is now contained within
removeFilterByColumnsToHide. - Conditional Reset/Refresh: I've added a placeholder
shouldResetAndRefreshvariable. You'll need to replace this with the appropriate condition based on your application's logic. For example, you might only want to reset/refresh if the filter change affects pagination or the total number of rows. I've usedfilter.value.kind === 'range' || filter.value.kind === 'text'as an example. - Avoids Modification of
changeFilterValue: The corechangeFilterValuemethod remains untouched, preserving its general-purpose functionality.
📌 Refactoring Considerations
You're right to think about refactoring later. Here are some potential improvements:
- Extract a Helper Function: If the inline
changeFilterValuelogic becomes too complex, extract it into a separate helper function within the class. - Create a Dedicated Service: If you find yourself repeating this pattern in other places, consider creating a dedicated service to handle filter updates related to column visibility.
✅ Recommendation
I strongly recommend this approach of expanding
removeFilterByColumnsToHide. It provides a clean, localized solution that avoids modifying a core method and allows you to control the reset/refresh behavior based on your specific requirements. Remember to carefully define theshouldResetAndRefreshcondition to optimize performance.-
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.