Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
o3-2025-04-16· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

How about in judaism? what does the scripture say about gay relationships and what's the…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with o3-mini’s answer.
  1. User

    How about in judaism? what does the scripture say about gay relationships and what's the most accepted interpretation of it?

  2. Assistant

    Below is a concise “Jewish-text tour” of how same-sex relationships are addressed in classical sources, followed by an overview of how the major contemporary streams of Judaism interpret and apply those texts today.


    1. Biblical (“Tanakh”) Passages Most Frequently Cited

    TextHebrew (transliterated)Standard English rendering
    Leviticus 18 : 22וְאֶת־זָכָר לֹא תִשְׁכַּב מִשְׁכְּבֵי אִשָּׁה“You shall not lie with a male as one lies with a woman; it is an abomination (toʿevah).”
    Leviticus 20 : 13וְאִישׁ אֲשֶׁר יִשְׁכַּב אֶת־זָכָר מִשְׁכְּבֵי אִשָּׁה ... מוֹת יוּמָתוּ“If a man lies with a male as one lies with a woman… they shall surely be put to death; their blood is upon them.”
    Genesis 19 (Sodom)(full chapter)Describes attempted male-on-male rape. Often cited historically, though modern commentators emphasize the violence/hospitality angle rather than consensual same-sex intimacy.

    Notes
    • The Torah directly addresses only male anal intercourse.
    • Female-female intimacy is not mentioned in Tanakh.


    1. Rabbinic & Halakhic Development

    A. Talmud
    • Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 54a–b: spells out that the biblical death penalty applies specifically to receptive/penetrative male intercourse.
    • Yevamot 76a: calls lesbian intimacy “maʿaseh nashim” (women’s practice). It’s labeled “prohibited,” but without biblical penalty; later authorities treat it as a rabbinic-level ban.

    B. Medieval Codes
    • Rambam (Maimonides), Mishneh Torah, Issurei Bi’ah 21 : 8: re-states the prohibition and applies lashes for lesbian acts (rabbinic).
    • Shulḥan Arukh, Even Ha-Ezer 24 : 1–2: repeats Rambam; homosexual male intercourse is one of the gravest sexual transgressions; lesbianism discouraged but treated less severely.

    C. Underlying themes in traditional halakhah
    • Orientation vs. act: Classical sources judge the sexual act, not the desire.
    • No explicit discussion of long-term same-sex relationships, marriage, or “identity language” (gay, lesbian, etc.).


    1. How the Major Movements Approach It Today

    Orthodox / Haredi
    • Maintains the classical halakhic ban on male same-sex intercourse (and rabbinic ban on lesbian intimacy).
    • Same-sex marriage and ordination of openly LGBTQ clergy are not permitted.
    • Growing pastoral literature stresses dignity, inclusion, and mental-health support while upholding the legal prohibition on specific sexual acts.

    Conservative / Masorti
    • 2006 CJLS (Committee on Jewish Law & Standards) issued two majority-accepted teshuvot (responsa):
    – Dorff-Nevins-Reisner paper: distinguishes orientation from prohibited anal intercourse; permits same-sex commitment ceremonies, ordination, etc.; still bars the single biblical act (male anal sex).
    – Roth paper: retains the full traditional ban.
    • Since both papers passed, individual rabbis/communities choose which to follow. In practice, most North-American Conservative institutions now officiate same-sex weddings and ordain LGBTQ clergy.

    Reform
    • 1977: first resolution urging decriminalization/protection for gays and lesbians.
    • 1990 s: CCAR (rabbinic body) affirms ordination of openly LGBTQ rabbis/cantors.
    • 2000: formal approval of Reform rabbis officiating same-sex weddings.
    • Underlying theology: biblical verses seen as time-bound; ethical lens of equality and autonomy supersedes ancient ban.

    Reconstructionist & Renewal
    • Fully egalitarian on sexual orientation since the 1980 s.
    • Liturgical materials and lifecycle rituals written specifically for same-sex couples.

    Orthodox-pluralist & “halakhic - inclusive” initiatives
    • Eshel, JQY, Yeshiva University’s “Welcoming Statement,” etc. seek to create supportive space within halakhic bounds.
    • A handful of Orthodox rabbis argue for re-examining the scope of the biblical prohibition, but such views are not mainstream.


    1. Key Take-Aways

    1. Textual core: only two explicit verses (Lev 18:22, 20:13) directly prohibit one form of male-male sexual act; later halakhah generalized that into a broader ban on male same-sex intimacy and, rabbinically, on lesbian intimacy.
    2. “Most accepted” historically = absolute prohibition within traditional halakhah.
    3. Contemporary consensus splinters along denominational lines:
      • Orthodox retains prohibition.
      • Conservative allows committed relationships and most intimacy (opinions vary on the single biblical act).
      • Reform, Reconstructionist, Renewal embrace full LGBTQ equality and ritual recognition.
    4. Across the spectrum, there is a growing pastoral commitment to human dignity, combating bullying, and ensuring full synagogue/community participation—even when disagreements over halakhic permissibility remain.

    Further Reading (Starter List)

    • Rav Moshe Feinstein, Igrot Moshe, Even Ha-Ezer 4:115 (20th-c. Orthodox responsum)
    • CJLS 2006 papers: “Homosexuality, Human Dignity & Halakhah” (Dorff et al.) and “The Halakhah of the Three Prohibitions” (Roth)
    • David L. Weddle, “Homosexuality and the Judaic Tradition,” in Homosexuality & World Religions
    • Steven Greenberg, Wrestling with God & Men (Orthodox, reinterpretive)
    • Ellenson & Culpeper, Voices of Torah, vol. 2 (progressive commentary on Leviticus)

    If you’d like to zoom in on any specific source, responsum, or modern debate, let me know and we can dig deeper!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.

Identical first prompt