Dear editors and authors: I have received and reviewed the manuscript entitled “Seasonal…
- User
Dear editors and authors:
I have received and reviewed the manuscript entitled “Seasonal dynamics of red imported fire ant (Solenopsis invicta) colony structure across agro-ecosystems in South China”, submitted to the journal Animals.
This manuscript investigates the seasonal changes in the colony structure of the invasive fire ant within two specific agro-ecosystems in South China: Camellia oleifera plantations and fishponds. The authors present detailed monthly data on various colony parameters and analyze differences between habitats, correlations among colony/nest characteristics, and relationships with meteorological factors. Understanding these seasonal dynamics is cruciael for effective fire ant management, and the dataset collected represents a significant effort in this regard.
Despite the potential value of the study, several major issues need to be addressed before the manuscript can be considered for publication.
1.Title: Consider specifying “Camellia plantation” and “fishpond” directly in the title instead of using the broader term “agro-ecosystems” for greater accuracy.
2.Line 136-143: Given that ant mounds were randomly selected without apparent shape-based filtering, and that mound volume was calculated using an ellipsoid formula, could the authors clarify how they ensured this geometric model was appropriate for all sampled mounds across both habitats?
3.The Abstract and Conclusion clearly state that“... new colony formation is occurring from late spring to early summer, and mortality increasing in spring, ...”I agree that, if supported, this would be a valuable finding for informing seasonal control strategies. However, I was unable to find any direct evidence in the manuscript, such as nest count data or colony loss observations, to substantiate these claims. It seems more likely that these statements are inferred from patterns of reproductive activity or brood development. If that is the case, I recommend rephrasing these conclusions to make clear that they are based on dynamics of colonies rather than direct observations of colony formation or mortality.
4.Section 3.6 refers to Fig. 12 for the correlation analysis, but the figure seems to be missing from the current PDF.
5.Disscussion: While the discussion regarding Section 3.6 results addresses individual environmental factors, it would be improved by also synthesizing these findings to discuss broader patterns or combined effects on colony dynamics.
6.The manuscript contains several minor grammatical issues that should be addressed to improve clarity and readability. For example:
Line 29: Revise “red imported fire ant’s colony structure” to “the colony structure of the red imported fire ant”.
Line 87: Revise “a period of 12 months monitoring” to “12 months of monitoring”.
Line 145: Revise “Data sources are from” to “Data were obtained from”.
Line 255-256: Revise “is observed” to “was observed”.
Recommendation:
Considering the significance of the issues raised, particularly the missing Figure 12 and the need to substantiate or rephrase key conclusions, I recommend Major Revision for this manuscript.
- Assistant
Thanks for sharing your review comments. 😊
Would you like help with any of the following?• Polishing or restructuring your review before you send it.
• Drafting an authors’ point‑by‑point response to each of these comments.
• Editing the manuscript text itself (e.g., fixing the grammatical issues you noted, revising the Abstract/Conclusions, etc.).
• Creating the missing figure or double‑checking that the figure call‑outs match the PDF.Let me know what would be most useful for you, and I’ll jump right in!
Other models, same or similar prompt
Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.