Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
Geminigemini-2.5-flash· GoogleHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Please write an SCP article about a doll. The doll's only anomaly is that, seemingly at…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Mistralmagistral-medium-2506’s answer.
  1. User

    Please write an SCP article about a doll. The doll's only anomaly is that, seemingly at random, a loud agonized scream will emanate out of it. This only happens if at least one person is close enough to hear the scream, and the scream is always in the voice of one of those who can hear it. It only does this once per person. People who heard their own screaming voice report feeling like they're missing a part of themselves.

  2. Gemini Assistant

    Item #: SCP-3578

    Object Class: Euclid

    Special Containment Procedures: SCP-3578 is to be contained within a standard secure containment chamber at Site-77, constructed with a minimum of 10cm sound-dampening material. The chamber is to be monitored by passive audio and video surveillance at all times.

    Access to SCP-3578's containment chamber is restricted to Level 3 personnel and above, and requires prior approval from the acting Site Director. Personnel entering SCP-3578's containment chamber must be fully aware of its anomalous properties.

    All personnel who have heard SCP-3578's scream, regardless of whether it was in their voice, are to undergo immediate psychological evaluation. Personnel who hear their own voice emanating from SCP-3578 are to be immediately rotated to non-critical assignments and placed under long-term psychological observation, with regular assessments to track their mental and emotional state. No individual is to be intentionally exposed to SCP-3578 for experimental purposes without prior O5 Council approval.

    Description: SCP-3578 is a porcelain doll, approximately 45 cm tall, depicting a young girl. It is dressed in a faded blue gingham dress with a white lace collar. Its eyes are fixed, blue glass, and its painted lips are set in a slight, neutral expression. A hairline crack runs across its left cheek, giving it a somewhat melancholic appearance. Standard material analysis has shown SCP-3578 to be composed of common porcelain, cloth, and glass consistent with doll manufacturing practices from the early 20th century. No internal mechanisms or power sources have been detected.

    SCP-3578's sole anomalous property manifests at irregular intervals. While at least one human subject is within auditory range (estimated at 15 meters), a single, loud, agonized scream will emanate from SCP-3578. The scream consistently matches the voice of one of the human subjects within range. It is crucial to note that SCP-3578 will only emanate the scream in a particular individual's voice once. Once an individual's "scream" has been 'used', they are no longer susceptible to having their voice chosen by SCP-3578, even if they remain within range during subsequent manifestations.

    Individuals who hear their own voice emanating from SCP-3578 report a profound and lasting sensation of "missing" something fundamental about themselves. This manifests as a gradual but irreversible decline in emotional range, a blunting of personal identity, and a marked reduction in self-awareness. Affected individuals describe feeling like a "hollow shell," or "an echo of who I once was." They often report a complete loss of the capacity for strong emotion (both positive and negative), a diminished sense of purpose, and an inability to connect with memories on an emotional level, despite retaining full cognitive function and memory recall. No physical changes have been observed in affected individuals.

    Individuals who hear a scream in another person's voice report significant distress, often experiencing nightmares or acute anxiety related to the incident, but they do not manifest the same progressive loss of self.

    The duration between anomalous events is unpredictable, ranging from several days to several months. The specific individual whose voice is chosen from among those present also appears to be random. No known method to reverse or mitigate the effect on affected individuals has been discovered.

    Addendum 3578-01: Acquisition Log SCP-3578 was acquired by Foundation agents on ██/██/20██, following reports from a local antique shop in [REDACTED], California. The shop owner, Mr. Elias Vance, had reported "unsettling noises" emanating from a doll recently placed on display. According to Mr. Vance, he had no recollection of acquiring the doll, stating it "just seemed to appear one morning."

    During initial assessment by Foundation personnel, Junior Researcher Dr. Anya Sharma was within auditory range of SCP-3578. The doll emitted a loud, piercing scream identical to Dr. Sharma's voice. While Dr. Sharma suffered no physical harm, she immediately reported feeling "oddly detached," a sensation that progressed into the typical "missing self" effect over the following weeks, as detailed in her psychological reports. Mr. Vance, who was also present but whose voice was not used, reported only severe fright and a subsequent aversion to porcelain dolls.

    Addendum 3578-02: Experiment Log 3578-Alpha

    Subject: D-3870 (Male, 34) and D-3871 (Female, 28) Procedure: D-3870 and D-3871 were placed within 5 meters of SCP-3578 in a sound-dampened observation chamber. Date: ██/██/20██

    Results: After approximately 20 minutes, SCP-3578 emitted a loud, agonized scream. Audio analysis confirmed the scream matched D-3870's voice.

    • D-3870 (Affected Individual): Immediately appeared disoriented. When interviewed an hour later, he stated, "It was my voice... but it felt like it wasn't coming from me. Like it was a memory of a scream I hadn't made yet." Over the subsequent days, D-3870 exhibited increasing signs of emotional flattening. He reported that "colors seem duller" and "food just tastes like... food." His responses became largely factual, devoid of personal inflection or emotional weight. After three weeks, D-3870 was completely unresponsive to emotional stimuli, showing no reaction to good or bad news, and reported a profound sense of listlessness. He stated, "I don't feel anything anymore. I don't know who I am, but I don't care."
    • D-3871 (Witness): While visibly distressed by the scream, she showed no signs of the emotional or identity loss observed in D-3870. She reported nightmares for several nights but maintained her full emotional and cognitive faculties. This corroborates previous observations that only individuals whose voices are used by SCP-3578 suffer its primary anomalous effect.

    Addendum 3578-03: Theoretical Mechanisms

    Current Foundation theories regarding SCP-3578's mechanism remain speculative:

    1. Soul Fragment Extraction: This theory posits that SCP-3578 does not merely mimic a voice, but extracts a small, non-physical component of an individual's "self" or "soul" – perhaps a psychic imprint of their deepest agony or capacity for emotion – and channels it into the scream. This extraction permanently diminishes the source individual.
    2. Identity Echo: Another theory suggests that SCP-3578 acts as a conduit for a "psychic echo" of the chosen individual's fundamental identity. The scream represents the traumatic expulsion of this echo, leaving the individual's "core" subtly incomplete or damaged.
    3. Memetic Contagion: A less favored theory suggests that the scream itself is a memetic trigger, and the "missing part" is a psychological defense mechanism that the brain initiates upon hearing its own voice in such a traumatic context, effectively "shutting down" core emotional processing to cope with the impossible stimulus. However, the progressive and irreversible nature of the effect contradicts typical memetic responses.

    Further research into the precise nature of the "missing part" and potential avenues for recovery is ongoing, though all attempts thus far have been unsuccessful.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.