Skip to content
TheChatArchiveThe Chat Archive
gpt-4.1-2025-04-14· OpenAIHugging Face LMArena Human Preference 140K

Let us say I have done a scrub on a ZFS pool, and receive errors(under the heading…

From a Chatbot Arena battleThe same person sent this prompt to two anonymous models at once. Compare it with Claudeclaude-opus-4-20250514-thinking-16k’s answer.
  1. User

    Let us say I have done a scrub on a ZFS pool, and receive errors(under the heading "errors: Permanent errors have been detected in the following files:"). How can I with the help of zdb(or any other available utility) determine the exact offset of the error in a faulty file ?

  2. Assistant

    When ZFS reports permanent errors in files after a scrub, it means that some data blocks could not be read or repaired. If you want to find the exact offset of the error within a file, you can use the zdb utility, which is a low-level ZFS debugging tool.

    Here’s how you can do it:


    1. Get the File's Object Number

    First, you need to find the object number of the file in question.
    Suppose the file is /pool/dataset/path/to/file.

    zdb -dddd pool/dataset path/to/file
    

    Look for a line like:

    Object  lvl   iblk   dblk  ...  path/to/file
    

    The Object number is what you need (e.g., 12345).


    2. Get the List of Data Blocks and Their Status

    Now, use zdb to dump the block pointers for that object:

    zdb -dddd pool/dataset <object_number>
    

    Example:

    zdb -dddd pool/dataset 12345
    

    This will output a lot of information. Look for lines like:

    Indirect blocks:
      0 L0 0:12345:0d0d0d0d ...  <-- block pointer
        ...
      0 L1 0:12345:0d0d0d0d ...  <-- block pointer
        ...
    

    But more importantly, look for checksum errors or read errors in the output. They may look like:

    block BP 12345:0d0d0d0d ... (checksum error)
    

    or

    block BP ... (IO error)
    

    3. Determine the Offset

    Each block pointer in the output will have an offset (in bytes) into the file. For example:

    0 L0 0:12345:0d0d0d0d DVA[0]=<...> [L0 DMU object 12345, offset 0, size 128K]
    

    The offset field tells you where in the file the block starts.

    If you see an error associated with a block at offset 0x20000, then the error is at byte 0x20000 (131072 in decimal) in the file.


    4. Summary of Steps

    1. Find the object number of the file:
      zdb -dddd pool/dataset path/to/file
      
    2. Dump the object’s block pointers and look for errors:
      zdb -dddd pool/dataset <object_number>
      
    3. Note the offset of the block(s) with errors.

    5. Alternative: Using zpool status -v

    Sometimes, zpool status -v will show the file and the offset of the error directly, but it is not always as detailed as zdb.


    6. Example Output

    Suppose you see:

    0 L0 0:12345:0d0d0d0d DVA[0]=<...> [L0 DMU object 12345, offset 0x20000, size 128K] (checksum error)
    

    This means the error is at offset 0x20000 (131072 bytes) in the file.


    References


    In summary:
    Use zdb -dddd pool/dataset <object_number> to find the block(s) with errors and their offsets. The offset tells you where in the file the error is located.

    If you need help interpreting a specific zdb output, feel free to paste it here!

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.