Skip to content
The Chat Archive
deepseek-r1-0528· DeepSeek LMArena Human Preference 140K

When doing business analysis, how do you define the KPI granted rate. Lets say you have…

  1. User

    When doing business analysis, how do you define the KPI granted rate. Lets say you have a merchant a, one customer tries do to the following purchases. Date, Amount, Granted 2025-01-01, 1000, 0 2025-01-01, 500, 0 2025-01-01, 100, 1 2025-01-02, 400, 0 2025-01-02, 100, 0

    What would you defined the granted rate to be in numbers, in volume. What are the best practises and is there an industry standard?

  2. Assistant

    To define the KPI "Granted Rate" for a merchant (e.g., Merchant A) using your example data, we calculate it in two primary ways: by transaction count and by transaction volume. Both are industry standards, but the choice depends on business objectives. Below is a clear breakdown:


    1. Granted Rate by Transaction Count (Approval Rate)

    Definition:
    The percentage of transactions approved ("granted") out of all attempted transactions.

    Calculation:

    Granted Rate (Count) = (Number of Granted Transactions) / (Total Transactions) × 100%
    

    Your Data:

    • Total transactions: 5
    • Granted transactions: 1 (only the $100 transaction on 2025-01-01)
    • Granted Rate (Count) = 1 / 5 = 20%

    When to Use:

    • Best for tracking customer experience (e.g., how often users succeed at checkout).
    • Industry Standard: Widely used in fraud detection, payment processing, and retail.

    2. Granted Rate by Transaction Volume (Approval Rate by Value)

    Definition:
    The percentage of the total monetary value approved ("granted") out of the total attempted purchase value.

    Calculation:

    Granted Rate (Volume) = (Total Value of Granted Transactions) / (Total Value of All Transactions) × 100%
    

    Your Data:

    • Total attempted amount: $1000 + $500 + $100 + $400 + $100 = $2100
    • Granted amount: $100 (only the $100 transaction)
    • Granted Rate (Volume) = 100/100 / 2100 ≈ 4.76%

    When to Use:

    • Best for tracking revenue impact (e.g., how much sales revenue is captured vs. lost).
    • Industry Standard: Critical in industries with high-value transactions (e.g., travel, luxury goods).

    Key Takeaways & Best Practices

    1. Report Both Metrics:

      • Count Rate reveals behavioral trends (e.g., 4 out of 5 users faced declines).
      • Volume Rate reveals financial impact (e.g., 95% of attempted revenue was declined).
        Example: A 20% count rate but 4.76% volume rate signals high-value declines.
    2. Segment Your Analysis:

      • Calculate rates by time (daily/weekly), transaction size, product type, or user segment to pinpoint issues.
      • In your data:
        • 2025-01-01: Count Rate = 33% (1 granted / 3 transactions), Volume Rate = 6.25% (100/100 / 1600).
        • 2025-01-02: Count Rate = 0%, Volume Rate = 0%.
    3. Contextualize with Benchmarks:

      • Compare to industry averages (e.g., payment gateways often have 70-90% count-based approval rates).
      • Investigate declines:
        • In your data, 1900of1900 of 2100 (90.5%) was declined, suggesting potential fraud filters or risk rules are overly strict.
    4. Avoid Common Pitfalls:

      • Exclude non-attempts: Only include transactions that reached the payment gateway (your data includes these).
      • Align with Business Goals:
        • Use count rate for user-centric goals (e.g., conversion rate optimization).
        • Use volume rate for finance-centric goals (e.g., revenue recovery).

    Final Answer for Merchant A:

    MetricValue
    Granted Rate (Count)20.0%
    Granted Rate (Volume)4.76%

    Recommendation:

    • Track both metrics daily and correlate with business events (e.g., new fraud rules on 2025-01-01 caused high declines).
    • If declines are unexpected, audit your payment system’s risk configurations.
    • Industry tools (e.g., Stripe, Adyen) natively provide these KPIs in dashboards.
  3. User

    But if one customer has several failed attemts one day why should you include them in your calculation would it not make sense to only have one failed attempt per day per customer for example. Otherwise the granted rate would plummet if someone just kept on trying?

  4. Assistant

    You've raised an excellent critical point. Including every failed attempt from the same customer/session can indeed distort the granted rate, especially if one user makes numerous retries. This is a known nuance in KPI design. Here's how industry experts handle it:


    The Problem: Repeated Failures Skew Metrics

    In your example, if 1 customer makes 3 failed attempts (1000,1000, 500) before 1 success ($100) on 2025-01-01, counting all attempts:

    • Count-Based Rate: 1 granted / 4 attempts = 25%
    • Volume-Based Rate: 100granted/100 granted / 1,700 attempted = 5.9%

    But if this represents one purchasing intent, the "true" success rate is 100% (they ultimately succeeded). Including every retry penalizes the metric unfairly.


    Industry-Standard Solutions

    Best practices address this by distinguishing between transaction attempts and user sessions:

    1. Session-Based Granted Rate (Most Common for UX/Funnel Analysis)

    Definition: Treat all attempts within a single user session (e.g., 30-minute window) as one logical "purchase intent."

    • Granted = 1 if any attempt in the session succeeded.
    • Not Granted = 0 if all attempts failed.

    Your Data (Grouped by Customer/Day):

    SessionOutcomeSession Volume
    2025-01-01 (Customer X)Granted$1,600
    2025-01-02 (Customer Y)Denied$500
    • Count-Based Rate: 1 granted session / 2 sessions = 50%
    • Volume-Based Rate: 100granted/100 granted / 2,100 attempted = 4.76%
      (Volume still includes all attempts – see note below)

    When to Use:

    • Analyzing customer experience (e.g., "What % of users successfully checkout?").
    • Standard in e-commerce funnel reports (Google Analytics, Adobe Analytics).

    2. First-Attempt Granted Rate

    Definition: Only count the first transaction attempt per user/session.
    Your Data:

    • 2025-01-01: First attempt = $1,000 → Denied
    • 2025-01-02: First attempt = $400 → Denied
    • Count-Based Rate: 0 granted / 2 first attempts = 0%

    When to Use:

    • Measuring system's initial decision accuracy (e.g., fraud detection efficacy).

    3. Volume-Based Rate (Unadjusted)

    Definition: Still include all volume, even from retries.
    Why?

    • Reflects total revenue opportunity ($2,100 was "at risk").
    • Used when analyzing financial impact (e.g., "We lost $2,000 of potential revenue").

    Best Practice Recommendations

    1. Report Session-Based + Volume-Based Metrics Together:

      • Session Success Rate: "50% of users successfully paid."
      • Volume Capture Rate: "We captured only 4.76% of attempted transaction value."
    2. Context Matters:

      • For risk teams: Use first-attempt rates to tune fraud rules.
      • For product teams: Use session-based rates to optimize checkout flows.
      • For finance teams: Use volume-based rates to forecast revenue loss.
    3. Segment by Reason Code:

      • Distinguish between "hard declines" (permanent failure) vs. "soft declines" (retry encouraged, e.g., insufficient balance).
      • Soft declines inflate attempt counts but aren't true failures.

    Applied to Your Data

    MethodCount-Based RateVolume-Based Rate
    All Attempts (Raw)20% (1/5)4.76% (100/100/2100)
    Session-Based50% (1/2)4.76%*
    First-Attempt Only0% (0/2)0% (0/0/1400)

    * Volume rate remains unchanged as it measures total monetary exposure.


    Key Takeaway

    There’s no single "correct" rate – the choice depends on business context:

    • Session-based best reflects user experience.
    • Volume-based best reflects financial risk.
    • Always clarify methodology in reports to avoid misinterpretation.

    Top companies (Stripe, Adyen) provide all three metrics in dashboards, letting stakeholders choose based on their needs.

Responses were produced in different, uncontrolled contexts (system prompts, settings, prior turns). This is not a benchmark.